Ooc: Hello! I realize I'm a Sephiroth, but i don't hang around any one fandom. I float around. That said, I saw what you put in your tags. Ruby, Weiss, and Blake all deserve to be in Beacon. Here's why. Blake wasn't "put" in Beacon. She tested in. Ozpin said as much when he talked with her. He knew she was a Faunus, and outright stated she passed with flying colors. Weiss got to beacon not through wealth, but as a way to distance herself from her Father. I'll continue in another ask. One sec.
Continued: Weiss came to Beacon as a way to distance herself from her Father, who was shown to be a manipulative asshole who threw his Money around even though he married INTO the Schnee family. She abhorred his ways. Weiss comes off as Arrogant, but that is just a barrier because she's damaged and keeps leople away. Ruby, while a skilled prodigy, got into Beacon for her eyes. Ozpin knew what her eyes meant, even took note of them. He put her into Beacon so he could keep her away from Salem.
i was a bit confused by what you meant at first because i don’t think i’ve ever intended or implied that those three don’t deserve to be at Beacon - but i’ve just checked the notes and i think you’re responding to this reblog?
the three do deserve to be at Beacon, but i do think it’s important to acknowledge that Yang is the only main character we know for definite got into Beacon through the proper channels (she graduated from a combat school, she wasn’t under different circumstances, she just worked her way through school and got in the regular way)
Blake, yes, got in through the entrance exams with no prior qualification, just based on skills acquired through growing up outside the Kingdoms and being part of the White Fang; there’s nothing wrong with getting in based on acquired skill (though we hear from Ozpin that this only happens with a few students), as not everyone has the same circumstances (Blake, and possibly Nora and Ren due to them both being orphans, have been in situations where they’ve had to take care of themselves outside the safety of the Kingdoms, they’ve had to acquire the skills in the field as opposed to in a classroom)
Weiss, we don’t know for definite, however due to her family’s wealth, we can actually presume she had access to private tutoring so she could excel (as Jacques was fine with her attending a combat academy, he just wanted her at Atlas where he could keep an eye on her and prevent her from embarrassing the family, she had to past a test that was stacked against her in order to attend the school of her choice). it’s reasonable to assume she had some additional benefits with her training because regardless of her home situation she’s still in a position of exceptional privilege
as for your last point, that’s actually incorrect
Ruby got in for her eyes and skills, yes, but not to keep her away from Salem (as Salem didn’t know Ruby existed until Cinder was injured) - which also makes it sound like you’re saying she doesn’t deserve to be at Beacon if that was the real reason - Ozpin only found out about Ruby after her encounter with Roman and Cinder, she stopped a robbery and demonstrated exceptional combat skill (similar to Qrow), Ozpin only noting the silver eyes when he actually met her. given how useful her abilities are and the implication that Summer was most likely on mission for Ozpin when she died, the implication is that Ruby was boosted ahead two years and got into Beacon because Ozpin wanted to make use of her Silver Eyes. he didn’t want to protect her, he wanted to train her up and use her as quickly as he could
the point i’m making is that it’s important to acknowledge that Yang got into Beacon through hard work, training and study at a combat school and passing the exams, she got through and put in the work she needed to do in order to get where she is, without benefiting from special recommendation (Ruby), coming from a privileged environment with greater access to training resources (Weiss), global renown or reputation (Pyrrha), or any of that helping her. because a lot of the time Yang is dismissed or mischaracterised as this idiot slacker that doesn’t try when there’s nothing in canon even suggesting that (and indications that she has and does put in a lot of hard work to get where she is in pursuit of her own goal)
the actual idiot slacker that doesn’t try is also the only person who actually doesn’t deserve to be at Beacon - Jaune. he committed fraud to cheat his way into the school to fuel his own egocentric need to be a ‘hero’ (and not to help people or anything selfless, it’s because he’s a glory hound), he’s shown sleeping in class when it’s obvious he doesn’t know or care to know, Pyrrha has to force him to study and take his comics away and he never had to own up to the authorities that he did something horrendously selfish and stupid, not only insulting everyone who put in the time and work to get into Beacon but also endangering the lives of himself, his team and anyone he might try to save because he doesn’t know what he’s doing and never put in the effort to find out, he just figured picking up a sword and being able to swing it was enough