okay in an au where everyone is alive you need explanation I will will give it to you, all the boys would be kidnapped either at the same time or over the course of a few months and they would be it and Finney would be the last one.
By now the others are injured and Robin, Vance and Billy out of commission leaving Griffin who was the first and has healed scars that still hurt and Finney who just got in.
They’re all held in the same basement and it goes as cannon just with Finney actually talking to them and one thing leads to the other Finney is fighting as the others watch and Finney has to carry all of them at the same time up as they are sent to the hospital and unlike oh Finney not having any visible scars he gets a cut from the axe.
After all the shit they stay close and quickly become friends because why wouldn’t they? You all just experienced one of the most trauma enducing shit together why not stick together no one else will understand.
After they would hangout everyday at school and after school like the whole 9 yards, definitely would have sleep overs because all of them have sleeping disorders there is no questions about it.
Anyway it can either be as fluffy or as angsty and honestly had to get this out of my system