do you think gaining percival pickens in season six was worth losing hiram lodge?
This has been lodged (heh) in my mind for the whole three days since you sent it to me, anon. You are devious. What a question!!!
The answer is a yes from me, because Seasons 5 and 6 of Riverdale are about the main characters learning that they are, at best, kind of mediocre adults, like the vast majority of the rest of humanity. Percival Pickens is necessary to puncture their still-adolescent levels of vanity.
Percival Pickens was part of what Riverdale the show wanted to say about how being a precocious child doesn't always - or ever, really - translate to having usable skills as an adult. (As a former precocious child I'm enraged by this daily, btw.) Percival Pickens brought the heartless indifference of the adult world right into my beloved characters' innermost sanctums - their bedrooms, their gyms, their bunkers, their minds. Betty, whose was always imbued with reckless courage, is scared of him bc he effectively fucks with her sanity. Archie, who survived many an incident of terrible violence including a bear attack as a child, almost dies at Percival's hands in a single boxing match. Veronica is run out of her business by him very handily. Jughead, who lives so much in the narratives in his head, has his whole brain invaded.
These now-adult, formerly-precocious children are confronted through Percival with the fact that all the adults of their adolescent misadventures, terrible as they were, were holding back because of love and social connection. Percival however doesn't give a fuck about them, doesn't find them special or interesting, has no connection to their mommies and daddies, no complex emotional connection to their hometown, and they are defeated by him. The narrative is on their side on this, so it posits that Percival Pickens is a demon and must be defeated by Satan himself. The only person who isn't completely decimated by Pickens is Tabitha Tate, and that's because she arrived in Riverdale as an adult.
This is getting too long but - you know how the ruthless Gladys looks at her former high school alumn's kids and mutters, Oh great, more teenagers or Hiram, deeply aggravated by Jughead, will still remember he's just a sixteen year old nerd? These are parental gestures, made by people who can see their children, and therefore the children that were, in more grown people, no matter how obnoxious they're being. The scary, painful thing about being a real adult is that you continually lose people who see you that way, and meet ever more people who will never exercise that empathy for you. That's why I'm for Percival Pickens replacing Hiram as the big bad.