Tips from Tamar
Click, Cookie, or Compliment
When we are training dogs in our prison re-entry programs, we use clickers as a mark to let dogs know when they have performed a cue correctly and when they will be rewarded with a treat. Clickers are small, box-like tools that make a unique short “clicking” sound. Clicker training is not a new or high-tech method of dog training, but it is a very useful technique that allows us to train multiple dogs in the same way and to the same standard.
In general, the pattern we teach is: cue-behavior-click-treat. It’s simple and easy once you get the hang of it. However, sometimes we need to tell our handlers to treat the dog when they aren’t following any specific cue, and this can be frustrating at first. Even later on, many people think that giving treats without a cue spoils the dog or makes them food dependent.
Giving a food treat as a reward for a cued behavior reinforces the likelihood that the specific behavior will be repeated in the future. Giving a food treat without cueing a behavior first classically conditions that current situation. This would be classical conditioning: giving your dog some feel-good cookies in a new or uncomfortable space. One common use of free feeding treats is in new environments or around loud or fast items like bicycles. If the dog gets a yummy treat every time a bike flies past bikes become pretty cool. The dog didn’t specifically sit or stay, but merely being in the presence of the scary object can be worthy of a reward.
When is “good dog” enough? Are there times when just letting a dog know she is a “good dog” enough? What if you pair it with a cookie? Your voice carries emotion; this generally means that you can use praise and compliments when want to communicate you think your dog is wonderful, OR when your dog is doing a duration-type behavior as you build up to a food reward. It does not mean it's a great reinforcer in precision or cue training. For example, in loose-leash walking you should definitely talk to your dog and keep her engaged the entire time she is learning; however, you should also feed when in the best position and to encourage continued attention. Walking itself is not a precision behavior to reward--as long as your dog is walking nicely, no specific step deserves a reward more than the next step.
So when should I use a click? When you are teaching an exact behavior, such as sit, which is binary: either a dog is sitting or not sitting. They are either sitting quickly and straight or they are not. No matter what level of “sit” you are training, there is a precise moment when your dog does the right behavior that you need to mark.
When should I use free-feed cookies? When you are trying to build or change an emotional response, as opposed to a specific behavior, free-feeding cookies is useful. “Cookies without fuss” help change your dog’s mind about an event or environment or teach them something should be fun.
When should I use praise and compliments? Give compliments freely all the time! Your dog probably loves hearing you happy chatter to them, and it's a good way to let them they are on the right track. This is not necessarily the best choice for teaching a specific skill or altering perception, but it is a great way to reinforce your relationship.













