Since you sent me Freddie Mercury vs Robert Plant i’ll send you Brian May vs Jimmy Page! 😉
Aaahaha, I expected this actually. :D
Brian kinda looks like a floofy stork with narrow, sharp features. So he’s not, objectively, perhaps the most handsome man in the world. But he also has the loveliest, brightest smile and an intelligent twinkle in his eye so, therefore, I can’t completely separate his looks from him being just Brian: smart and sweet and kind and generally wonderful.
Jimmy, then. Well, he took after his Irish mother, I’m guessing, with the whole pale and dark-haired and vaguely mischievous and fey thing. And I’m known to be into that, generally speaking. He was cute, honestly, when he wasn’t yet too coked up anyway. Still kinda is. He has always had this slight smile that looks like he knows a hilarious, wonderful secret.
So… While I have to say I love Brian considerably more, Jimmy wins this round by a small margin. :p