AT&T, T-Mobile Deal Will Hurt Consumers & Stifle Innovation
Dan Hesse, chief executive of Sprint Nextel Corp. (S), said he's concerned that AT&T Inc.'s (T) plan to takeover rival T-Mobile USA would stifle innovation and hurt consumers.
[It would give] AT&T and Verizon control of 79% of the market if the deal goes through.
He said this while speaking at a roundtable discussion at the CTIA Wireless trade show today. Both AT&T's mobility chief executive, Ralph de la Vega, and Verizon Wireless (VZ) Chief Executive Daniel Mead shared the stage with Sprint's CEO.
Somewhat unsurprisingly, Mr. Mead had a "curiously low-key reaction to the AT&T/T-Mobile merger plan" (@waltmossberg). The reality is that with control of 79% of the market, AT&T and Verizon will be the big winners, not consumers or their competitors.
Assuming the government does not intervene, it will result in both companies having more pricing power over consumers, suppliers, which will in turn result in the ability to increase their margins/prices.
We don't think there will be a price war between the two big players, as it would hurt them both in the long run. Also, we believe their market share is unlikely to be rivaled by competitors, leaving their pricing power in place.
More specifically, in an industry where infrastructure spending is key to survival, any potential competitors will have to spend big just to provide equivalent service to consumers. Without including spending on advertising, this would be an extremely hefty bill.
This is all assuming that the government will not intervene and that is just one scenario.
On our end, we hope they will, as innovation will suffer due to a lack of competition and consumers will be hurt because of higher prices.