hello there! i see you watch the Witcher series and i'm thinking of giving it a go - would you recommend it to someone who's not a fan of too much violence and grimdark? from what i can tell looking at gifsets it sounds like good cute fun with good character development and fun chemistries and that's what is appealing to me. Do you think i'd like it? (if you have time / spoons to answer obviously ^^) Cheers!
Hello, and thank you for the ask! There’s definitely violence and gore, I would say around GoT level if I was to make a comparison. It’s not majorly censored or prettied up, but it’s also not exaggerated for shock value. If you’re not used to this from GoT, or games like Skyrim and Dragon Age: Origins, it might be a bit off-putting. They do censor it when animals are involved, though.
It definitely feels grim and even hopeless, at times, but I also sensed a subtle undercurrent of “this will be okay”, though in a “lots of bad stuff will happen first” kind of way. Personally, I found much of GoT (the parts based off of the books, not the later seasons) to be more grimdark than the Witcher, but I might also be a bit desensitised after watching Sir Gregor Clegane rip people apart and Cersei Lannister go off on her mad schemes. There’s moments of kindness and mercy that, to me, doesn’t make it feel truly “grimdark”, if that makes sense. Then again, I’m far from an expert on that genre.
You’re absolutely right about the fun parts, character developments and chemistries. To me, that was what truly drew me into the Witcher TV show, and it drove the story beautifully. I say this as someone who’s neither read the books or played the games - everything made sense past the first two-three episodes, and it didn’t at all feel jumbled to me.
Overall I was left with the impression that the good parts balanced out the bad pretty well. If anything, the chemistry between characters seemed more important than the violence, the latter of which is not in any way, shape or form glorified.
In conclusion: It has both violence and grim moments, but with a good dose of emphasis on characters. Overall I’d say it’s more character-driven, which to me makes it a better story by default. I’m no expert, and others might have a completely different experience after watching the first season, but that’s my two cents at least. If others have something to add, then please do!