Rdr2 oneshot idea, basically reader has the molly dutch relationship but gets fed up with dutch investing his time into other, younger women,so she gets with Arthur and dutch gets mad😚
Pairings: Arthur Morgan x Reader, Dutch Van Der Linde x Reader
Warnings: Smut, Emotional Neglect, Toxic Relationship
A/N: First Rdr2 oneshot, hope you like it and thank you so much for the request!!!🩷🩷
"Dutch..." you release a breathy moan as he thrusts harshly into your entrance. Your eyes shut tightly in an attempt to control yourself as he pushes you over your limit.
"Look at yourself," Dutch laughs between deep grunts, "not very ladylike of you, Miss L/N." A smirk takes over his face as he watches you fall apart because of him.
You're certain that whoever's sleeping next door probably hates the two of you considering how much the headboard continuously bangs against the wall.
Since relocating to Shady Belle, you were secretly excited to finally be able to sleep in a bed. Despite the furniture being old and worn out, so was everything else in camp which means you're already used to it.
Sharing a space with Dutch means that everything needs to be tidy and kept organised. After what happened Rhodes and the kidnapping of Jack, the gang's atmosphere has become distant and cold.
So was Dutch at the beginning. You couldn't really blame him for not wanting to speak a lot considering the stress he's having to undergo, but his words have been what you can only describe as harsh and bitter towards you.
Constantly having to convince yourself that he doesn't really mean it takes a lot of energy. On one occasion, a few days ago, you overheard him complaining about you to Arthur. Saying that you've been irritating him during this time after wanting him to talk about how he's feeling.
Because of that, you stayed quiet. Mostly out of annoyance due to the fact that he would spread this information to someone like Arthur rather than just telling you.
You've stayed like that for the past few days. Hardly speaking to Dutch. And when you did, giving the most short and dry answers. Until today, he finally broke. He began asking you why you haven't spoken to him. Why you haven't been your usual self.
That's when you told him exactly what the reason is. You told him about his little conversation with Arthur being heard. You told him about how much it hurt that he spoke so little of you.
As he listened, you remained very calm and professional. Not giving in to the lustful stare he gave to your body, practically undressing you with his eyes.
A few moments after you finished providing your piece, Dutch was quiet. He had a hungry smirk which made it clear that he didn't process a word you said. At this point, you're used to his routine. Whenever he hurt you, he would never apologise. It wasn't in his ego to do so. Instead, he'd take the initiative to make you feel good through sex.
And that is what's happening right now.
It's embarrassing how much you actually missed him. The way he makes you feel when you're both happy is unmatched. As much as you tried to hide it during the time you decided to ignore him, you were internally screaming for his attention.
You always finish before Dutch. For some odd reason, his body forces him to wait until you've released before he can do the same.
His cock twitches in that moment. His pace becomes irregular and eventually slow as the orgasm shoots through your entrance. Legs squirming slightly as his release briefly catches you off guard.
Because suddenly, you realise you've failed to hold back from his clearly manipulative advances. But in the end, a side of you is happy that he's returned to his usual self. Even if that is for a short while until his temper flares again.
"You always take me so good," Dutch praises, collapsing beside you on the mattress as a relieved smile takes over your face. You begin to wonder if you were both just sexually frustrated and needed a release.
Your hand supports your head as you look into Dutch's eyes. "You know..." he continues, tracing a finger over the side of your hip, "you're the only one who understands me."
"Of course," your brows knit softly together at his touching words, "I love you, Dutch."
"You're a good girl," he smiles at your confession. Having you wrapped so pathetically around his finger, your loyalty seems almost amusing to him. "Go to sleep," he instructs as if you aren't your own person. As if he's in charge of every tiny detail in your life.
Regardless of the fact, your eyes close. You smile at what seems to be kind treatment from Dutch rather than controlling. Due to the hot temperature, even at this time of night, you don't bother to cover yourself with the blankets and instead, decide to go straight to sleep.
Meanwhile, Dutch stays awake to read his book. You can sense the candlelight through closed eyes, but you don't complain. Not wanting to strain your lover with being a burden, you decide to stay quiet and deal with it. After finally getting him back, you don't want to lose him again.
In the morning, your sleep schedule allows you to naturally wake up. The torn, sheer curtains bring sunlight into the room as it shines directly onto Dutch's bare back. Your attention is brought to him as his hands cover his face.
"Is everything okay?" Your voice is evidently sleepy. He doesn't respond straight away as his position faces away from you.
He releases a pent up sigh, "with Pinkertons breathing down our necks, I don't know if I can look out for everyone."
"What do you mean?" You straighten up to rest against the headboard. Bringing the thin sheet of blanket higher to cover your exposed chest.
"They're all relying on me..." he brings a cigar to his lips as a puff of smoke escapes. Staying quiet for the next few seconds, he stares straight ahead at the murky wall. Your eyes drift to your surroundings, wondering whether you should say something to lighten the mood or stay silent.
"Dutch..." you crawl towards him until your chest comes into contact with his back. Wrapping your arms around his neck, your fingers brush soothingly against his cheek, urging him to look at you, "we'll get through this."
He releases an empty laugh beneath his breath as if he doesn't believe you. That your optimism is amusing and your reassurance means nothing.
In the end, he gets up from the bed. Your body collapses onto the sheets as he isn't supporting you anymore. Moving around the room, he lifts the clothes which were swiftly thrown onto the floor from the night prior to get dressed into.
Meanwhile, your face and arms hang over the bed. Refusing to get up just yet, you remain in the position Dutch had forced you into.
He doesn't say another word. Just leaves. Not even a single glance at the unusual way you're lying on the bed which looks as if you're dead. You're left to wonder why he's acting this way. Last night, he wanted to know why you were hardly saying anything to him. In the end, he managed to take your clothes off and have his way. Distracting you from the conversation completely. Your problems never get solved.
You begin to blame yourself for even falling into his trap. All you want is for him to honestly communicate with you. Truly tell you how he's feeling. You understand the difficult situation he's in, and the fact he's clearly bottling every emotion inside, but you can't take the dismissive attitude he's portraying anymore.
Eventually, you push yourself off the bed to begin getting dressed for the day. You're slow at completing the task as your mind constantly drifts to how easily you gave in to Dutch.
Once finished adjusting your blouse and skirt, you leave the room to find Karen has just left hers which she shares with the other women. "Hi," you greet her with a polite smile.
"How you doin', Y/N?" She waits a second for you to catch up so that you can both travel down the stairs together.
"Fine," you nod, trying to muster a convincing expression when everything was far from being okay.
"Fine night it was," Karen laughs knowingly under her breath as your face immediately drops in embarrassment.
"What do you mean?" Your head tilts slightly as if you don't already know what she's referring to. Trying to put on the act that you're completely clueless.
She catches the shakiness in your voice, detecting your lies, "we ain't stupid, everyone heard." Her eyes close as she mimics your moans, "oh, Dutch...oh yes, fuck me."
"Shut up," your eyes roll dramatically before breaking into a small fit of laughter. Despite everyone hearing you, no one would even dare bring it up to Dutch. They'll be able to complain in private though.
"There you are," Miss Grimshaw walks angrily towards Karen, the usual moody expression taking over her face, "you're already late." She pushes a tub of soapy water into her chest, "here, laundry."
"Old hag," Karen whispers under her breath once Miss Grimshaw takes a few steps away to shout at Tilly.
You begin to laugh as she does the same. "Would you like some help?" You offer, but Miss Grimshaw interferes before Karen can even get a word in.
"We'll be fine without your help, Miss L/N," her tone completely changes as she provides a warm smile.
"Are you sure?" Your brows knit together supportively, "I really don't mind."
"I know our girls are lazy, but honestly, you don't need to lay a finger at all." Her hand rests against the small of your back, a small gesture to guide you elsewhere rather than the area of doing chores.
Since beginning a relationship with Dutch, she's always been so strangely lenient towards you. Before, she gave you the same treatment as she does with the other women.
"Bitch," Karen whispers again as she crouches to the ground to begin scrubbing clothes. Tilly overhears, snickering loudly as Miss Grimshaw turns to shake her head, already exhausted with the day.
You leave them to it, feeling really bad that they clearly don't want to spend their days doing this. In all honesty, you were hoping to be given a list of chores to occupy yourself with for the day.
With everything that's going on, from Pinkertons to Jack, you need something to distract yourself with. If Miss Grimshaw isn't going to provide that, you decide to seek it elsewhere.
Stepping further away from the house, you're able to identify Mary-Beth hiding from who you assume to be Miss Grimshaw. Behind a ruined wall, she turns the pages of her novel. Deciding to interrupt her reading, you begin to walk closer until the sight of Dutch comes into view and you come to a stop.
Instinctively covering yourself behind the thick trunk of a tree, you're at a safe distance where you can hear the conversation but still remain unseen.
As Dutch approaches, he clears his throat to assert his presence as Mary-Beth lowers her book slightly. "Reading again?" His hands relax against his belt as an amused smile covers his face.
"I like it," she shrugs softly, "gets my mind off things."
Dutch chuckles beneath his breath, "a woman with imagination, that's a dangerous thing."
Mary-Beth laughs awkwardly, "dangerous?"
"That's right," he leans against the ruined wall beside her with a lit cigar against his lips, "most people stop dreaming after a while; you've still got hope in you."
She smiles at the compliment, "I suppose."
"Don't lose that," the side of his lips curl into a smirk as he watches her carefully, "this gang needs people who still believe in something."
Your head shakes in disbelief at the sight. He's hardly spoken to you for the past few days and he's been nothing but cold to you all morning. But here he is, sounding so light with Mary-Beth. Giving her all the attention you starve for.
He walks away once Mary-Beth's eyes return to her book. Your anger doesn't even lie with her. She was clearly trying to be nice, and Dutch was the one who approached her. None of this is her fault. It's not as if she's actively seeking his attention.
He wanders near the pier as smoke from his cigar leaves a trail. You follow closely until he notices and turns around. "What was that?" You immediately confront.
His brows furrow at your question, "what do you mean?"
"You've been acting so off with me, and then I find you smiling with Mary-Beth...why are you like this?" Your voice shakes with emotion. Trying to maintain your composure, it's difficult to do so when you're forced into a vulnerable position.
"This is why," he releases an annoyed sigh, "you just have to be so far up my ass, I can't even talk to anyone."
You scoff loudly, "that's bullshit, Dutch."
"Don't use that language," he drops his cigar to the floor, stepping on it as his head shakes. He always hates to hear you curse, "ladies don't do that. You would know if you had any manners."
"This is the problem," you laugh despite there being no humour behind it, "you treat me like a fucking kid."
"You certainly act like one," he moves closer, clutching his hand around your arm tightly.
"Stop that," you try to remove the painful grip he has over you, "that hurts." He finally loosens it, but his glare remains piercing as he begins to walk away from you.
Watching him disappear, you're holding back tears of anger. Not even fear or shame. He's countlessly proven to be unworthy of your concern.
In an attempt to distract yourself, you walk onto the pier to stare out at the swampy water. It's nothing pretty, but a habit you find yourself doing wherever camp is set.
"You be careful around these lakes, Miss L/N," Arthur's voice breaks your concentration, "John and I found crocodiles when we first got here."
"Hopefully they eat me." You sound very monotone he can't help but take you seriously. "I'm only joking, Arthur," you turn, providing a reassuring smile as he looks totally speechless.
"Oh, right," he nods, glancing down at the wooden planks he’s standing on before looking up at you again, "is everything okay?"
You hesitate for a second, wondering whether you should include Arthur into the messy details of your relationship. He sounds genuinely concerned, as if he wants to make you feel better.
“It’s Dutch…” you begin awkwardly as Arthur adjusts his stance, listening carefully, “he’s just acting like a total bastard.” You explain in simple terms.
“How?” Arthur presses for more information as you sigh, wondering where to start.
“Well,” you pause for a second, trying to collect yourself from becoming emotional, “he doesn’t talk…at all. I’ve been trying to have a normal conversation with him for so long and he just…shuts me out.” Arthur nods with furrowed brows as you continue, “I overheard him speaking about me to you…”
“Yeah,” his hands relax over his belt as he remembers the moment, “it wasn’t nice.” Your hands begin to fumble with one another as even Arthur admits that Dutch was saying horrible things about you.
“Look, Y/N…” Arthur sighs as you immediately look up at him, “I’ve been around Dutch for most of my life, and as much as I respect him, I don’t think you should be with him.”
“You don’t?” It’s the first time you’ve spoken about this subject to someone other than your reflection.
“No,” he firmly answers, “he don’t deserve you. Hell, if you were my girl,” his hand awkwardly rubs the back of his neck at the thought, “I wouldn’t treat you like that.”
“Thank you, Arthur,” you honestly beam at his kind words, “I would really like that.”
His smile drops for a second, “you would?”
“Well…yeah,” you freeze slightly. Many of the women in camp take a liking to Arthur. Especially Mary-Beth. You can’t really blame any of them either. He’s strong. Easy on the eyes. And always helpful.
“To be completely honest with you,” Arthur stays in place, looking around to avoid eye-contact with you as he speaks without thinking of the consequences. “Ever since you joined the gang…a lot of the men have had their eyes on you.”
“They have?” Your eyes widen slightly at the confession.
“Sorry if I’m making you uncomfortable,” he notices your expression.
“You’re telling me Uncle has had thoughts about me?” You clarify as Arthur nods with an amused smile. “Ew, what the fuck.” Your reaction causes him to release a small laugh as you do the same. “And what about you?”
“What about me?” His head tilts slightly to the side.
“Do you like the thought of me?”
“Well,” his voice begins to stammer as you step closer to him, “I don’t want you to think of me as some sort of pervert, Miss L/N.”
He slowly backs away which enables you to stop and cover your mouth at the realisation, “I’m sorry, Arthur. You probably think I’m some whore.”
“That ain’t what I’m thinking,” he quickly reassures, resting his hand over your shoulder, “I just don’t want you to act on any harsh feelings you have about Dutch.”
You blink at your partner’s mention, “actually…I haven’t even been thinking about Dutch.” You look up at Arthur, “I forgot all about him.” You gasp suddenly, “I’m more worse than him.”
“No you ain’t,” Arthur looks as if you’ve just said something which could not have been more wrong. “At least you treat him good.” You freeze entirely as he continues, “I need to find a woman who cares for her man exactly like you do.”
His words cannot get any more kinder. Your attention is suddenly brought to the hand he has over your shoulder. Your lips suddenly press against his hand in multiple kisses as Arthur can’t help but just stare.
You then glance at his face before moving closer to plant your lips softly against his neck. The fabric slightly interferes, but the feeling of your nose rubbing against his Adam’s apple takes him slightly off guard.
In the heat of the moment, Arthur pushes you gently away. “We shouldn’t do this,” his eyes close, trying to fight his impulsive thoughts to give in.
“I don’t think anyone’s around,” you assume they’ll be too preoccupied with their chores, “and Dutch will probably be somewhere where there’s no hags like me.”
“This is wrong,” Arthur further excuses.
You sigh, “it is…I’m sorry.”
He quickly opens his eyes, “there’s no need to apologise. I...almost gave in myself.” He admits slightly embarrassed.
You’re still so close to him. Staring into each other’s eyes despite knowing it’s wrong to. Your gaze drifts to his lips, and before you know it, you’re slowly leaning in to press yours against his.
Arthur sighs into your mouth. Briefly pulling away just to tilt your head and lean further in, each kiss becomes so wet and heated. His hands rest against your waist as yours go around his neck.
“I think about you a lot,” he confesses as your lips press together again. “I can’t help it…” he manages to say between them. “Your body…” You smile against him. The image of Arthur touching himself at the thought of you turns you on.
You pull slightly away from Arthur’s grasp to hook the long skirt you’re wearing and lower it to your feet. Then untying your blouse, you lift it over your head to expose your naked body to him.
Arthur’s mouth parts in surprise that you’re not even wearing undergarments beneath your outfit. His eyes take in your entire body with a hungry expression. After months of picturing what you would look like, it’s even better than he could ever have imagined. Sketching this moment won’t do you any justice, he needs a camera to capture your beauty.
His mind flickers to last night and the noises everyone heard. The way his hand stroked over his hard cock to your moans. He can suddenly feel the fabric strain against his trousers just at the sight of you standing naked in front of him.
You smile at his reaction, unaware that he’d be this speechless. Slowly walking closer to return back into his arms, they instinctively wrap around you to touch every inch of exposed skin. You’re pressed so closely together that his hardened member pokes intrusively against your entrance through the fabric.
His fingers gently pinch your ass as if he’s exploring these areas for the first time on a woman. Discarding his hat onto the floor, your hands brush softly through his hair to continue making out. “You’ve got a sexy body,” Arthur pulls back to look down at your breasts as you laugh against his shoulder.
The moment’s suddenly ruined as the distinct sound of footsteps get closer. You immediately panic at the thought of who it could be as you quickly pull away from Arthur. The next few seconds pass by in a weird blur as you kick your clothes to the side and dive into the swampy water.
“Y/N,” Arthur calls, becoming suddenly conscious of the crocodiles which reside in what you’ve just jumped into.
Dutch appears to find Arthur crouching beside the water. “My boy, what in the hell are you doing?”
Arthur doesn’t answer as he suddenly dips his head in to find you clutching onto the pier’s legs underwater. He lifts you up immediately despite your protest, not wanting to risk the chance of a dangerous animal getting to you.
“Y/N?” Dutch’s brows furrow as he nears the two of you. You’re naked and shivering which confuses him even more. You hold onto Arthur so tightly as you cry into his shoulder after being exposed.
Dutch pats Arthur as a signal for him to move and allow you into his arms. “Dutch,” you cry even harder as your fingers dig into his skin through his now filthy shirt, “I’m sorry.”
“Why were you in the water?” He tries to obtain answers. “Get blankets,” he instructs Arthur as he nods and leaves the two of you alone. His mind keeps drifting to what happened prior to Dutch coming back. He’s always viewed Dutch as a father figure. Touching his lover so inappropriately is a new low even for him.
Meanwhile, dirt from the swamp sticks to your skin. “Was it me?” Dutch begins to ask, mind immediately thinking the worst, “were you trying to drown yourself?”
You remain quiet, just staring at him with wide eyes as he demands an answer. You’d rather jump back into the swamp and get eaten by crocodiles than admit what actually happened.
Your silence acts as its own answer as Dutch assumes his suspicion was true. “Y/N,” his hand cups your cheek, “don’t do that again.”
“Okay…” you slowly nod, relieved that you actually got away with it.
@akiraaa1239 @isleepwith7blankets @outlawforlife @sherleyholmes