The conversation John had with Kanaya before Vriska contacted him was when "Rose" (aka John on her account) told Kanaya to talk to John in the past about "her" interest in his movies.
John and Kanaya: When John pretended to be Rose, he suggested that Kanaya talk to him in the past. So she did - page 4605!
1. The Kanaya/John pesterlog was on page 4605. It was quite a long time ago so don't feel too bad about forgetting it. 2. The Reckoning has been going on during all of A5A2, but all the meteors so far have been teleported to Earth by Skaia's defense portals, so you couldn't see any of them from the Battlefield.
"I admit I’m not a hundred percent on whether the Reckoning has actually happened yet." It's actively in the process of happening. Reckoning is a 24-hours long event, mind you. And Tumor is set up to explode when it ends, so it would be a little obvious if it ended.
Great post as always! Re: the Reckoning - it started in [S] Descend, and is still ongoing. The baby meteors were among the first to go. If it was over already, you'd probably know; Rose said the Tumor is calibrated to the end of the Reckoning. :)
Ahh, re: the Reckoning, that totally makes sense! I somehow managed to forget about all the tiny meteors that bombarded Earth aside from the kid-specific ones. I guess at this point the Reckoning has sped up to the point that the defense portals can’t handle all the meteors.
I totally forgot about that John/Kanaya conversation, but I remember it now! That bit came right after he talked himself up to her as ‘Rose’. (heheheheheheh)