How do you feel about Garnet's ability to call things, or I guess, an easier way to say it is... her ability to be fallible? We see her take a "violence definitely solves all" position in So Many Birthdays and she takes another "wrong" call in Coach Steven. The Gems obviously look to her to solve a lot of problems (again, thinking of So Many Birthdays), and view her in high esteem (given how they both react to fusing with her)...
I really love how they’re showing Garnet isn’t always right. I wouldn’t say they went out of their way to push this too hard in the beginning, but they were definitely creating an image of Garnet as pretty unflappable and solidly reliable. She knew what to do and when and how to do it. If Garnet said it, you could trust it.
There’s still that element there, but now it’s in a different shade. Garnet comes across as completely certain and confident, and you instinctively believe whatever she says, but she can be wrong. And when she’s wrong, she tends to be pretty badly wrong, too. She either loses her shit (ala So Many Birthdays), or she become a fifty-foot giant angry smashy Mum.
Kind of like I was saying about Usagi the other day, I am all about the flawed characters. If Garnet were always right, my interest would fade pretty quickly. Instead, what I suspect we may have is someone trying really, really hard, but who may be projecting a whole lot more confidence than she necessarily feels.
That’s SO much more interesting to me.