spoiler about Batman: Enemy Within. Telltale Series. God, this game has the hardest choices of my life😱 I just finished and will play again to see the other endings😬 What did you think of the BatCat moments of this game? What is your opinion about this game? and what was your end? Did you choose to be Bruce or Batman?
Haha I think you’re in clear for spoilers. Batman: The Telltale Series is probably my favorite alternate media batcat. It makes me feel bad that I enjoyed the game so much, when Telltale employees were being mistreated. Bruce and Selina’s characterizations were flawless. I know that to a certain extent it depended on the decisions you made in the game, but by the way I played Bruce was a genuinely nice person who wanted to help everyone and give everyone a chance. He was kind of an embodiment of BTAS Bruce Wayne. Firm but fair.
I had kind of mixed feelings about Selina at the end of season one, but I came around after season two. Overall, I think that she had the right amount of moral ambiguity and repentance. I like that Selina’s redemption arc in season two was on her own terms. She made mistakes, regretted them, and wanted to make up for them.
Obviously, we got the first non-comic sex scene, which is bizarre that it only happened in 2016 considering just how much history Batman and Catwoman have. Although I enjoyed it immensely, what I really liked was how the writers/developers had a great understanding of Bruce and Selina’s dynamics and it didn’t come off as contrived. You can read more about it here, but even in the earlier episodes they really conveyed how Bruce believes that Selina is a good person, even when no one else (including her) thinks so.
My personal favorite scene in the series was the apartment scene in “New World Orde.” Selina was telling Bruce about her criminal lifestyle, and how she felt trapped by it. It was very subtle, but it conveyed Selina’s own insecurities about who she is. Selina also admits that she steals from good people as well as bad, and what I like about this confession is that it holds her accountable. Sometimes I feel that fans try to sanitize Selina’s thievery and create this perception that she’s some kind of Robin Hood who only steals from evil rich people, but this is not always the case. Sometimes it’s purely self-interest, and, even though I don’t think it’s ever really her intention, what she’s doing is very selfish and she’s hurting people.
In this moment there are a few different ways that you can have Bruce respond:
1. “There’s more to you than that”
2. “I’m not sure I trust you”
3. “That’s what I like about you”
This moment is important because Selina remembers this. You can either confirm what Selina thinks about herself and the little expectation she expects of how others view her (options 2 and 3) or tell her differently (option 1). If you choose Option One, Selina says “Now you’ve ruined it.” Telling Selina that there’s more to her, inspires her. I am truly amazed the good folks over at Telltale Games, knew to include this.
Some people criticized the game because they felt like the choices didn’t differ the outcomes dramatically enough. I’m not enough of a gamer to notice something like that so it didn’t bother me. I don’t remember what I ended up picking. No matter you’re in a bad position because the choices that you make as Bruce Wayne impact Batman’s ability to fight crime, and decisions you make as Batman affects Bruce Wayne’s life and partnerships. I think that I chose being Batman over staying with Alfred. My thought being, in anticipation of a third season, Batman going AWOL would have a worse impact on Gotham City, than Bruce potentially being hindered in his ability to operate as Batman without Alfred.