Some other thoughts about the Dove Beauty Sketches videos
If you haven't seen the videos I'm talking about, you can find them here: http://realbeautysketches.dove.us/
I realize there has been some controversy about them. Some people find them so inspirational that they are brought to tears and some people find that they make them angry, and pretty much everything in-between.
I posted a link to the video the other day, and I've read a lot of what other folks have had to say about them, and I think many of the points made on both ends of the spectrum are incredibly valid. Here's the thing that I keep coming back to though, there is a large portion of society that has never really thought about this sort of thing. While I realize that those of us who are involved in size diversity activism or who are actively involved in learning to love our non-mainstream media typed beautiful selves might find it hard to believe - it is, none the less, true.
Is there a serious lack of diversity in the individuals involved in this project? Yes, absolutely. Fat, male, Hispanic, red headed, Native American, Indian among many others aren't represented at all, and Blacks and Asians are barely represented. Does it go far enough to be the whole conversation that I think needs to be happening? Nope, not at all. But that doesn't disqualify these videos as a pinky toe dip into the idea that our self-image is often much more negative then what others see in us. It presents the idea, the concept that perhaps how we judge ourselves against the unobtainable perfection of glossy magazine covers and carefully shot, professionally made-up movie stars is damaging or at the very least a negative thing. And, it offers this idea in a way that is non-threatening to people who have never really given it any thought, it allows them to begin to think about it without a knee-jerk defense mechanism kicking in and without them automatically disqualifying the validity of the idea because of who the messenger is.
Some people leap into the deep end, some people need to wade in. Sometimes when someone has waded in up to their ankles on their own, it's a whole lot easier for those swimming around at the deep end to coax them further out into the pool. Because of Unilever's (the manufacturer of Dove products) vast media reach, these videos have way more people talking about the subject then were before they were released. So instead of shouting down individuals who found them thought provoking or inspiring, because the videos "didn't go far enough", why not use them as a stepping off point for intelligent, even more thought provoking conversation?
I understand that sometimes revolution only comes with shouting and loud noises, but I think sometimes it comes with the whispered voicing of a thought on a million pairs of lips as well.