i was already reading him this way but the confirmation that shanks feels guilty about being descended from celestial dragons makes me like the way he interacts with marco even more. he clearly wants that bird on his crew! but the most he'll do is make an offer, and he accepts the rejection with a smile and a laugh.
it really puts into perspective why shanks is known for taking in weak crews, why he's so beloved by his territories and fleet, why children are so obsessed with him. he's gentle BECAUSE he's so powerful, and he's seen what power (political and physical) can do when it's used to harm others and take away their agency. he's so conscious of the possibility that he's coercing others with his influence or his strength that he won't even take the finishing blow against higuma kid (x2) and barto.
he's been to marygeoise, he was implied to have been the one to facilitate fisher tiger's uprising, and he was so repulsed by what he saw there that he willingly sacrificed his arm to the lord of the coast to get rid of the mark that imu had left on him. he was a kid who was raised on roger's ship, a ship where freedom is so paramount to their way of life, and as an adult he commits himself to never taking that freedom from others, and stopping anyone who intends to.
no matter how much he likes marco, no matter how much he wants him for his crew, he'll never force him. and he doesn't even mention it when he saw to whitebeard and ace's funerals, primarily because it would be really inappropriate 😭 but also in that moment, marco owes him EVERYTHING. shanks stopped the war, shanks made sure the crew and fleet got back to the new world, shanks arranged the funerals.
if he'd said 'in exchange, join my crew', marco's in such a vulnerable position that he would probably feel obligated to say yes. so shanks doesn't ask.
there's this impression in OP fandom, esp among newer/younger fans, that shanks is stupid or careless or immature, and imo that couldn't be farther from the truth. he can give off a carefree vibe because that's the life he wishes he could live, but he's always shown an extraordinary amount of restraint, and he's also shown to be a calculating, deliberate person. even his kindness and generosity are deliberate, like if he gave in to his selfish impulses that would make him just like the celestial dragons he's related to, and that's probably one of his most deeply-rooted fears.



















