I fully agree with you about the post on Rick's characterization. His infatuation is unnatural and uncomfortable. They've given themselves this golden opportunity with a new set of characters to create something MORE than they did before. Yet the continue to try to bring to life the scenes from the comics. I love both the show and the comic, but there's so much opportunity being wasted. And really, can't they see that show!Rick is so much more than his counterpart. Sorry...rambling. I love you
You don’t have to apologize! I absolutely agree with you that they’re trying too hard to bring the comics to life, and in doing that they’re wasting some amazing character development and plot enhancement opportunities. The show and the comics are two different entities that stem from the same ideas-- they aren’t the same, and I don’t think they should be treated the same.
I think that earlier seasons prove that you can deviate from the source material and still come up with a similar story. Just look at Shane; he lasted all of a minute in the comics, he was a much flatter, weaker character, and his death came much more quickly. In the show, they gave him an entire character arc, they deepened him and developed him, used him to further plot points (Lori’s pregnancy, the question of morality, “we’re all infected”), and gave him a more meaningful death. You can tell where all the inspiration for him and his scenes came from, but it didn’t follow the comics directly and it gave us a more fleshed-out, dynamic, and interesting character to watch on screen.
You don’t always have to follow the source verbatim; the characters have developed differently and had different experiences in the show vs. the comics, so it doesn’t always make sense to have tv!Rick do the same things that comics!Rick did. They’re branches off the same tree, but that doesn’t make them the same. .
Don’t get me wrong, it’s fun to see some iconic scenes from the books on screen. I just think that Gimple and the writers are straining to make it happen. The Rick/Jessie subplot could have been semi-successful, I think, if it had been better executed and Rick’s previous character development had been taken into account. They could have made it work if they didn’t rush into it so hastily.