I’m back on my Scream bullshit so here we are! The second thing is already a fic on my ao3 but anyway!
- Stu and Billy being soft on reader and doing absolutely everything to keep him from their killing sites and just the murder in general.
- Movie playing out how it does but the two of them treat reader just a touch differently compared to everyone else.
- Reader walking in on Billy and Stu murdering someone on the carpet. They think reader’s gonna rat them out and freak out and run and they’re so prepared for it but reader just sees it and goes ‘you fuckin morons better know how to get blood out the carpet’ and goes on their way. Billy leaves Stu to clean it up while he goes after them, questioning them only to find reader knew for a while and doesn’t care much, as long as it’s not their family members then he doesn’t care.
- The boys telling reader that they kill people. They’re fucking terrified of his reaction and wish nothing more than for him to just accept them. They’ve got a minuscule hope that he’ll join them even but they know how much of a reach that wish is. Reader finds out and while he’s mildly uncomfortable he doesn’t hate them for it. He logics it out and reasons that if he isn’t dead yet then he’s not gonna die anytime soon, and he makes them promise to not go near his family. It all turns out better than the boys had ever hoped for.