I found the Sogdians incredibly fascinating and briefly considered looking into something related to them for my final project before settling on something else. Learning about this group of people really brings to mind the concepts of identity, ethnicity, and culture, connecting somewhat back to my second post here. The Sogdians were rather spread out with their city states, practiced multiple religions and ‘conflicting’ funeral rituals (Marshak, 233), had influences from different cultures in their art... who were they really? A merchant group, as Juliano and Lerner outline, but as we discussed in class, how biased is this view of them? I do not doubt that they were merchant based necessarily, but I wonder about the opinions other cultures had of them, if they were really seen as money-greedy as a quote from that particular reading implied.
Why did the Sogdians choose to decorate their homes with art so heavily influenced from other cultures? I am curious if this comes about due to the fact that Sogdiana “capitals” lay on the silk route. Perhaps it is inevitable that when a group is in contact with those passing through from many other places, some of their culture is left behind. The conquests that came from interactions with some did not diminish the Sogdian importance, as Lerner says. If the Sogdian identity was abstract, or at least may appear so to us now, how did they retain it with conquests? It seems, from what knowledge I gained from this week’s readings, that they were a relatively easygoing people.
Honestly, within the three selections this week, I can’t see much to pick apart and look at deeper. I do find Sogdiana, from this superficial view, to be puzzling however do not know much of what to say about them. I am aware this post is rather lacking, but my main question is of what signifies identity. Was the Sogdian identity distinct because of their hybridity, and was it this that shaped them? How did they manage to maintain their identiy through the conquests by other groups? I am left with many questions and few answers from this week’s readings. The Sogdians are a people who I would love to study at length in the future.
Learner, Judith. "The Merchant Empire of the Sogdians." Monks and Merchants: Silk Road Treasures from Northwest China. New York: Abrams, 2001. 221-227. Print found online.
Marshak, Boris. "The Sogdians in Their Homeland." Monks and Merchants: Silk Road Treasures from Northwest China. New York: Abrams, 2001. 231-237. Print found online.
Feng, Luo. "Sogdians in Northwest China." Monks and Merchants: Silk Road Treasures from Northwest China. New York: Abrams, 2001. 231-237. Print found online.