A/N: Ya didn’t think I would not write for my Sonnyverse in this bingo round, did ya? This square (Marry Me) fits so well with an idea I’ve had for ages! Cause surprisingly I’ve yet to write them actually getting engaged! So here we go! Bingo: Candy Hearts. Bingo Master: @sweetcannolicarisi
You had notice a change in Sonny for the last month now, but you couldn’t pin what it was. So you just figured it was the stress of the job. Surely there was no reason to be suspicious right? Apart from the odd phone calls, and trips to see his mother or sisters without you.
There wasn’t a reason to worry, was there? When it was getting closer to the new month, your mind starter churning. Was Sonny going to leave you? Had he grown tired of you, and looked for a way out? Surely he would tell you if he was, wouldn’t he?
Not being able to take the silence and the stepping around anymore, you decided to question him about it. «Sonny?» You asked, quietly, stepping into the living room of your small apartment. «Yeah, doll?» He sounded calm now. «Have I done something wrong?» It was a simple enough answer, but you could see him begin to panic again.
«What?! No of course not, doll!» He exclaimed, jumping off of the couch and rounded the corner to you. «Then why are you sneaking around like this and hardly talking to me? You tell me you’re going to see your family and don’t want me there, but you don’t give me a reason why.» Tears were forming in your eyes as you stood there.
He took a step towards you, reaching out to take your hands in his. «This wasn’t how I wanted it to go», he started, taking a shaky breath, making you nervous. «I was going to propose to you, doll. I’ve been meeting with your family and mine to help pull this off.» You gasped at that. «Oh, Sonny! I’m so sorry!» You said, your voice low as you looked to the floor. «Hey, no, it’s okay, doll. Look at me, it’s okay», he said in his soothing voice.
«Bu—but I ruined your surprise!» You said matter-of-factly. «It’s okay doll, really. The most important thing for me is that you say yes», he murmured, cupping your cheeks in his hands so you had to look at him. «If you ask nicely», you half joked, tears treating to spill.
Letting go of you, Sonny quickly ran to your shared bedroom. «Babe?» You called after him, confusion lacing your voice. «Give me a second, doll!» He called back. «I knew I wanted to marry you since before our one year anniversary. I even got the ring ages ago», he said, returning from your room. That made you smile wide as you watched him with keen eyes.
Sonny took your hand again as he got down on one knee. «My darling, love of my life. I’m forever grateful that I have you in my life. And I wouldn’t want to be without you. I will always thank my lucky star for the day I found out you liked me back, our first I love you, our first kiss, our first time and all our other shared moments. Not a day goes by that I don’t love you entirely. And I can’t imagine spending the rest of my life with anyone else. So, would you do me the honors of becoming my wife?» Sonny asked, looking up at you with teary eyes as he opened the velvet box to reveal your nonna’s engagement ring. It had been handed down through generations in your family, and held extreme value to you, so it made you even more emotional to see Sonny giving it to you.
«Yes!» You managed to choke out through treats of happy tears, «A million times yes!!» Sonny smiled wide as he carefully slid the ring onto your finger before standing up and wrapping you in his arms. «God, I love you, doll! So much!» He murmured, kissing you passionately, «And I love you so much, Sonshine!!» You responded returning the kiss with just the same passion.
- Sonny immediately felt protective over Sam and Dean from the first moment he saw them
- They were just innocent kids without a good father looking after them (Personally, i don't really like John but i don't outright hate him. I think the only reason i like him is because of Jeffery Dean Morgan)
- It takes a while for Dean to warm up to Sonny and even more to let him near Sam
- But the man is always kind and helpful and never raises his voice, he talks out what the problems are which is something Sam desperately needs
- Sam takes to Sonny almost immediately, thriving under a supporting father figure
- Sam and Sonny talk deep conversations and have their moments of silence but they’ve never fought like Sam and John do
- Sonny listens to Sam, to what he wants and does his best to give the kid what he needs
- Sam doesn't judge the older man by his past, something Sonny is grateful for
- Dean doesn't judge him either, given all the bad he’s done to keep his brother alive and safe
- Dean and Sonny take a bit longer to get along but almost immediately, Dean respects the man
- Sonny respected Dean in return but going along with Dean’s wishes regarding Sam, giving Dean chores for discipline but not driving him to the ground with training and disappointment
- Sonny supported Dean and acted like a friend, one Dean desperately needed too
- When Dean brought up wrestling, he expected Sam’s slight worry but overall okainess with it but he was worried Sonny would tell him it was useless and not needed
- Instead the man clapped his shoulder and asked how much was for the gear and uniform because Dean was gonna do it properly
- Sonny also helped Dean train at home but it usually ended up in a big tickle fight Dean always loses
- And he enjoys it
- There were other kids at the home but most weren't allowed inside the bubble of two
- Sonny may have favorited the Winchesters but he NEVER forgot about the other kids in his care
- That made Dean respect him even more
- Sonny loved teasing Dean about his girlfriend and Sam would join in and Dean would wonder if that’s what a family really was like
- Sonny would help Sam with homework and let him ask his millions of questions without getting annoyed
- Sure, he might tickle the boy to shut him up but it was all worth it to see Sam breathless, giggly and happy
- The boys and Sonny became a family and a happy one at that
- He’d hate to see them go and secretly wished John wouldn't come back
- The boys secretly wished the same
This stems from a conversation my friend Dani ( @itsjustmyfantasyroom ) and I had after I shared this post with her on discord 🥰
“Babe? I’m headed to work! Your ma is coming in 30 to help get the boys to—”, you let out a scream as you saw your husband, electric razor in hand and a clean shaved face. “Are you okay, doll?” A look of worry gracing his face. “Wh—what ... did you ... do?!” You gasped, pointing at his face, tears slipping down your cheeks. “Why are you crying?” He was biting back his own tears as he put the razor down and moved over to you, wrapping you in a tight hug.
“Daddy why is mommy crying?” Matteo asked, looking at his father, “what did you do?!” He added, gasping in horror.
Pulling away from Sonny you scooped down to pick up your son, hugging him to you. “I don’t understand. Why are you two talking about?!” Sonny asked, still none the wiser at your outbursts.
“The moustache, Sonny. Why did you shave the moustache?!” He knew you loved the stash, so the fact that he had just gone ahead and shaved it without as much as a warning, didn’t sit right with you. Of course, he’s his own person, and if he wanted to change something he was allowed to, you wouldn’t stop him, but if you had known, you would have taken more advantage at the time you had before he got rid of it.
“It was time for a change, doll. I didn’t know you liked it so much”, he confessed. “I hope you’re joking. Matteo go to the living room and wait for nonna, mommy needs to talk to daddy”, you said, putting your 5 year old down.
Waiting until your son was out of earshot you turned back to your husband. “You know damn well I liked the moustache Sonny”, you said, crossing your arms over your chest. “I—shit, I’m sorry, doll.” You shook your head, “too late now. Shit, I’m gonna be late. Be safe. I love you.” Leaning up you pressed a quick kiss to his lips before turning on your heels and running out the door.
Pairing: Sonny Carisi x wife!reader
Fandom: Law and Order Special Victims Unit
Warning: Smut ahead! 18+ to read!
A/N: In my Sonnyverse series. Feel free to send in requests regarding Sonny, his wife and their family! I have A LOT of ideas for them! (not to mention it’s a reader insert type series!) -Karen
MASTERLIST!
It had been a good while since you had been able to go out and be grownups. Your first child, which you had named Dominick Gabriel, was the miracle child you had been praying for since getting married. But being a parent meant sacrificing your personal time together. Not only were you and Sonny getting a date night, something you both desperately needed, you were celebrating that he had finished the police academy and started working as a patrol officer with the Staten Island PD. That way he was able to be there with you and Dominick.
«Doll, you look absolutely ravishing! I’m a lucky man», he said, praising you as you sat in the ferry café on your way to the city for your date. «That you are baby. Thank you», you murmured, leaning over to kiss your husband.
The feeling was barely there at first. His hand placed carefully on your thigh. «Sonny?» you questioned, looking at him. «Hmm?» he knew exactly what he was doing, but seemingly played dumb. «What are you doing baby?» you asked, placing your hand over his to stop him. There was no way you would be doing anything like this in public. «You just—you look amazing doll, and you’re making me so hard», he groaned, sending chills down your spine. He really knew how to make you feel good, even just by his words. «Sonny you’ve got to wait until we get home. Can you do that for me?» you knew damn well he couldn’t wait that long. You were watching a play and then have dinner, if you were lucky you wouldn’t be home that late. «Please doll. I need you so bad now», he pleaded.
Looking around you got up and dragged him with you to one of the more remote bathrooms. «If we do this you’ve got to be quiet baby. If not, I stop, and you won’t get anything until we’re home», you stated, looking at him before locking the door behind you. «Yeah. Please doll.» You pitied him, honestly. He was always weak for you. Always wanting you.
You were about to go down on your knees when he stopped you, kissing you passionately. «On your elbows», he murmured, unbuckling his belt and opening the button and zip on the slacks he was wearing. Letting out a small groan you did as he said, leaning on your elbows on the sink in front of you. It was his favorite position for a quickie.
He was quick to pull his member out and pushing into you, and you had to clamp a hand over your mouth to stop the oncoming moan from slipping out. «You feel so good doll», he murmured, quickening his pace. «Oh shit Sonny, just like that baby», you responded in a whisper. He quickly picked up speed and he moved in and out of you like there was no tomorrow.
Normally, this pace would have you screaming his name, but due to the current situation, but clamped a hand over your mouth, hoping to trap whatever sounds wanted to escape. Your body however did all the talking you needed as it responded to the feeling of your husband’s movements within you. Clamping down on his impressive member you let out a small whimper when he bit down on your shoulder to keep from letting out a loud moan.
Grabbing hold of the sink you let out a string of small moans and whimpers at the fullness you felt. It had been a while since you got to go at it, being parents, and Sonny being busy with the Staten Island police department meant there were little to no time for each other, and it was only so little your fingers could do to satisfy the need. «Shit doll, I—I’m gonna—!» he moaned. You knew he was close to release, you could feel the coil within yourself, ready to snap too. «Cum with me baby», you moaned, clamping down on him.
You and Sonny came together with a string of muffled moans and curses.
Straightening yourselves up, you were about to leave the bathroom when the captain came on the speakers, telling passengers that they were ready to port in Manhattan. «Let’s go», you murmured, taking his hand in yours and leading him to the exit.
It took longer than expected to find an apartment that you could both agree on. Either the kitchen was too small, or there wasn’t a tub in the bathroom. «Does it have to have a tub though doll?» That had made you look at him with a small scowl. «Of course it does Sonny!» you had said, crossing your arms over your chest.
Best thing about buying a place instead of renting it, was that you could have a dog there, something you had wanted for a long time. Your last dog, Dotty, had passed away your senior year of high school, and your parents didn’t want to get a new one after that, so you were bursting to get a four legged friend. You had told Sonny as much, and to your surprise and utter joy, he had agreed!
…
You had almost given up on finding something you could both agree with, when you found the perfect one. It wasn’t far to the ferry, it wasn’t far from where you worked. It was perfect! You’d put in the offer almost as soon as you had walked in for the viewing.
A week later you were moving in. You had to admit, as much as you loved living with your parents, nothing would beat living with Sonny.
«I can’t wait to get done here», he stated, putting a box down in the living room. «Yeah? What was your plans for later then?» you smirked, looking over at him. «You know what I want to do doll», he said with a growl, his arms wrapping around your waist. «Hmmm. Think you can wait that long babe?» you asked, pulling him in for a searing kiss.
«Can the two of you wait until we’ve left? Please!» Teresa said with a groan. «Sorry Tessa», you said, laughing as you pulled away from Sonny. He didn’t like the loss of contact one bit and tried pulling you back however, which made you laugh even more. «Listen! We’ve only got a couple more things to carry in, and then we’ll leave you guys alone», Teresa commented, looking at her brother.
«Let them live Teresa», her boyfriend, Tony, said, nudging her. «Where do you want this (Y/N)?» he then asked. «Oh, just put that on the kitchen counter, thank you», you said with a smile.
After all the boxes were carried in, Tony and Sonny got the couch while you and Teresa set on putting the tables together.
…
By the time you had finished putting things together it was close to midnight. «I’m too tired to cook babe, but I’m so hungry», you groaned, sitting down on the couch next to your boyfriend. «Let me order pizza», he offered. With a simple nod in response he ordered the food.
«30 minutes», he mumbled, pulling your legs over his lap. «Plenty of time.» smirking you straddled his lap, your lips on his in seconds. No more needed to be said as lust took over the two of you.
Breaking away from the kiss you grabbed the hem of your shirt, pulling it off your tiny frame. The shirt had barely left your hands before Sonny leapt forward, kissing you with such hunger it almost knocked the breath out of your lungs.
«Couch or bed?» he murmured, the vibration from what he said sending shivers down your spine. «Bed», you whimpered, wrapping your arms around his neck. A surprised squeal left your lips when he picked you up and carried you to the next room.
Placing you back down on your feet when you reached the bedroom, you both set to work on undressing each other quickly. «Doll, shit, you look so good», he groaned taking in your almost naked form as you stepped out of your sweatpants. «Yeah? You like what you see?» you asked, trailing kisses over his bare chest. «Yeah», he growled, pushing you down on the bed before hovering over you, «We’ve got to be quick doll, no foreplay this time», he murmured. «I’m always wet and ready for you babe», you commented, getting a growl from him.
You sat up quickly, rolling the condom on while kissing him. «Ready for me doll?» you nodded at this laying back down as he lined himself up with your entrance.
Pushing in he stilled for a moment to let you adjust before he started a slow pace. «Sonny, baby, faster», you whimpered, a moan ripping from your body as he pounded into you relentlessly. «Just like that Sonny!» you screamed, feeling your walls clenching around him.
«F—feels so good doll!» he stuttered, moaning. It drove you wild to hear him be so vocal about his pleasure.
Knowing you had to be quick you reached a hand down and started flicking your neglected clit. That only spurred your boyfriend on more as he picked up his speed, and you could soon feel yourself getting close.
«Baby, I—I’m close!» you screamed, your movement on your clit becoming more sporadic. «Let go for me doll», he moaned into your neck. With those final words you let go, crashing down hard as your inner walls held onto him like a vice. «Oh, oh shit, you feel so good around me doll!» he moaned hitting his hight shortly after.
You had both almost regained your breaths when there was a ring on the doorbell. «That would be the pizza», you commented, trowing your sweatpants and his t-shirt on to go pay for the food. Leaving Sonny behind, grinning wide, that’s my girlfriend, my beautiful, strong girlfriend.
(Y/N): Angie’s loving the dress your sister made out of her old shirt!
Sonny: Look at our little angel! I wish I could have joined you guys at the beach today!
(Y/N): It’s okay, next time. For now, get back to work detective! ❤️ Love you babe ❤️
Sonny: Love you too doll, and the kids, give them all the cuddles from me! ❤️
