I was trying to figure out why I was so upset about Jesse’s death, and it’s not only because it’s sad, but because It seems unfair in a way that isn’t good storytelling if that makes since.
If Billy died too, maybe I wouldn’t see it that way, but all of these people died for him and for what? For us to not even really get a moment of that anguish that Billy might feel? I understand he releases his pain through Justice, but was killing Catron really the justice that made since for that? Or even Garrett?
Don’t get me wrong, I love Billy, and I don’t even necessarily hate the ending he got, and I understand that not everyone can have a happy ending, but It would’ve been nice to see a positive outcome from everything he did reflect on one of his friends lives. Like maybe Jesse lived and that would’ve been a good way to counter his resistance to kill Catron in the last ep and explain why he came back. With him dying, it gives off Billy just being able to use anyone to get what he wants, even if it’s for good intent.
Realistically, most endings in a show or movie could work, it all comes down to how we get there and the writing. And this season definitely saw a decline in both, overall making for a unsatisfying and sad conclusion.
I don’t know if this made sense, but I was really trying to see why I had such a problem with it, other than just being sad that Jesse is dead.
you’re making sense and I agree with you!
I don’t really see how him succeeding in both Killing Pat and Catron really does much, i feel like something the show forgot is that a lot of times when Billy shoulders this duty like he needs to do something for the people, he’s actually doing it a bit more selfishly than he realizes, and I think the show going the way it did, doesn’t even acknowledge this. Sure, Catron was a bad guy who affected a lot of people, but an article about the ring isn’t going to change everything for good, and there’s always gonna be another. Always another Murphy, always another Pat. It solves nothing except his personal vendetta but did it NEED to be? I don’t think so. Making Pat live a miserable life is better than giving him death imo.
It honestly would’ve been more interesting to start seeing Billy second guess himself about if he should be killing Pat or Catron and decide to take the higher ground instead of feeding the system he didn’t even want to get into
I always thought that Jesse ‘redeeming’ himself and becoming a better person BECAUSE of what Billy’s done and meant to him and what he’s learned from him, would’ve been a much more satisfying arc for him alongside Billy’s death. Like in Billy’s death, Jesse chooses not to necessarily enact revenge but to change his ways a bit in memory of Billy and what he stood for, and take care of those who Billy’s left behind. I get the idea he sacrificed himself for Billy and his family here but it does make it feel like Billy can’t be harmed in any similar way. Emotionally? Yeah, but we barely even see that.
We don’t even get to see Billy mourn Jesse all that much. You could argue he’s just so desensitized to his friends dying now but like…their relationship has always been one of the cruxes of the show, and it felt so rushed.
I do agree with your second to last thing, and I think that some of the ideas they had this season like with Billy’s recklessness with the revenge plan could have worked, but how we got there and how that plot progressed was just not executed well enough to feel earned or satisfying.