What was the precipice for Carla? The point of no return, if u will. Where/when her loyalty and devotion to Simmons turned to loathing. Was there ever a moment where she could have been saved, talked back from the ledge? You said, "Carla was meant to enact the cycle of violence on the Earth." Who meant this for her? Did she decide this purpose for herself, or was her eventual action a subversion of what Simmons intended for her to inflict on the rest of the world?
She didn't have a sudden precipice, it was a month long climb and then a PROFOUND fall instead. There was a "voice" in her head that she began to hear louder, and louder. She lost grip on reality within a month of actually acting as Simmons's wife. Her loyalty turned to loathing after she discovered what he did, and the extent of what he had been doing. It's not loyalty either. She's his slave. She even describes herself as "his loyal servant" that will "do anything for him". Her loyalty was gone over this month of discovery, and then it was a fall off a cliff into madness. She didn't stop falling either for years.
There wasn't a moment she could've been saved! That's what makes it so horrible, and so fucking tragic. She actually LOOKED for Ada to try and help her in 2010-2011, and she couldn't find her faster than Simmons (her employer for Damnation was Simmons).
And yeah. She decided this for herself. Simmons idolized her (dehumanizing) and it gave her this idea that no matter what she did, she could reach as far as she wanted to, and not have any limitation on the extremes she could go to to accomplish her goals.
And it IS a subversion of what Simmons intends! He wanted her to be beside him as he put himself into the fantasy seat of power he imagined. She destroyed everything and was intending to be Queen of Ashes and dead.
I do think Ada had the best shot of talking her away from the ledge, but it wouldn't have ever been easy. Carla was convinced Ada should have the final say on if she wanted to join Carla in this hell or kill her, because EVENTUALLY the bad guy should face some kind of justice.
sighs.











