Then I Saw You
Basil Stitt X f!Reader
Beta Read By: @xbellaxcarolinax - Using prompts by @my-secret-shame-but-fanfiction, a few Nonnies, and my own ideas.
PLEASE READ TAGS/DISCLAIMERS/WARNINGS BEFORE READING THIS FIC. THERE ARE DARK THEMES!
Summary
You moved in next door to Basil Stitt two weeks after his incident. After everyone he cared about ignored his calls and acted like he didn't exist, he was starved for affection, and your pretty voice caught his attention immediately. He decided he'd do just about anything to have you all for himself...anything.
Tags/Warnings
Disclaimers: There is heavy non-con in this fic, it's not for everyone. If you're sensitive to that sort of thing in fanfiction, please keep on scrolling thanks.
NSFW, non-con, rape, sex, unprotected sex, praise kink, masturbation, obsessive behavior, possessiveness, porn with some plot, smut, creampie, breeding kink if you REALLY squint, non-consensual somnophilia, drugged sex, non-consensual drug use, minor mention of suicide but NO actual death or implied death in fic, also me making some shit up like how peepholes work, neighbor!Reader, dark fic, dark Basil Stitt. DEAD DOVE DO NOT EAT (that means that what you see in the tags WILL be in the fic, don't act surprised when you get exactly what you were warned about.)
Word Count: 9.8k
Basil saw the moving truck outside when it pulled up by the curb. Two men got out, opened up the back, and started to bring someoneâs belongings inside. His apartment was only one of the two on his floor. The old man across the hall went to a nursing home a couple of weeks agoâŠwas he getting a new neighbor? Sure enough, he heard them opening the door across from his and moving things inside.
He looked around at his living space, a disgusting mess of old pizza boxes, empty alcohol bottles, and his broken belongings. No doubt heâd need to get a better handle on his outbursts. Heâd already received a notice from the landlord with all the banging and shouting the person living below him had dealt with. Depending on the kind of person the new neighbor would be, he might get more than just a warning if they heard him being too rambunctious.
Thatâs when he heard your voice, a sweet thing that crept under the gap between his door and the hardwood floor that he was likely to lose his security deposit for after destroying it. He ran to the peephole, looking through the lens and seeing you for the first time.Â
His heart felt like it stopped beating. His entire body shook as he pressed his palm to the door. You wereâŠbeautiful.
âWhat the fuckâŠâ he whispered to himself, as you walked into your apartment. âW-what theâŠâ he stepped away from the door, âfuck.â
The second your door opened again he was pinned to his own, his good eye glued back at the peephole to get a glimpse of you. He whined, seeing your pretty smile as you handed the movers some money. Why were you smiling at them like that? Basil paused. Why did he care?
Maybe it was that you sounded, and looked, so nice. His calls to his girlfriend had still been unanswered, and the same could be said for his parents. You looked like someone who would care about him. Someone who could look pastâŠ
No.
Despite wanting to stare at you longer, he stepped in front of his mirror instead. There was no way you would be able to stomach looking at someone like him. He touched the reddened, rippled deformity on the left side of his face. An overwhelming dread poured into his chest, making him feel heavy with sorrow. How could anyone love him? His own mother couldnât even be bothered to speak to him, even after all the voicemails he left.
âYeah absolutely, Iâd love that,â you giggled in the hall.
Youâd love what? Basil thought, rushing to the door once again to see who had you feeling so upbeat.
You had a piece of paper in your hand. He didnât like how one of the movers was smiling and looking at you. Was he flirting with you? Basilâs hand reached for the door handle, but he stopped. What was his plan? Was he going to walk out there, someone youâd never seen or met before in your life, and just tell the guy to fuck off?
In a perfect worldâŠyes.
Heâd step out there, no paper bag on, and tell the man off. Basil imagined youâd be so enamored with his actions that youâd kiss him, smiling at him the way you were smiling at the mover right now. Youâd touch his cheek and look at him as though his face were normal, like it was just a couple of short weeks ago. Your lips looked so soft.
Basil whined, pressing his entire body against the door, cock rubbing between the wood and his abdomen. He saw you go into your apartment again, closing the door behind yourself. Over the next couple of hours he sat in front of the door, waitingâŠlistening for your voice. All he heard was the sound of the movers going in and out, until finally there was nothing.
He stood there in the still of the silence, breathing slowly and trying to contain himself. He thought about opening his door again and knocking on yours, introducing himself as any good neighbor would. His breath hitched in his throat when he considered your reaction though. What if you saw his faceâŠ
What if you saw the monster heâd become?
âNo, no, noâŠâ he shouted, feeling emotionally overwhelmed at the thought of your rejection.
He would rather spend his life watching you through his peephole than risk your outright denial of him. At least in his mind, he could think up a million fantasies where you loved him, let him take you on a beautiful date, and where you were pinned underneath him, screaming his name while he made you come over and over again.
He was still so fucking hard. He needed you to step out of your apartment. He needed you now. Just the sound of your voice would do something for him. If he could just hear it, just a little bit, it was all he needed. He slowly opened the door and stepped into the hall, ensuring no one was there. He walked up to your door, looking through the lens to see if he could get a glimpse of you.
You walked by, and he thought he might collapse. Youâd changed into something more comfortable, a pair of cotton shorts and a tank top. As you should, it was rather warm that day. You deserved to be comfortable, perhaps even naked. Basilâs thoughts consumed him as he watched you bending over to open a box, pulling some things out, and disappearing from view. How lucky he was that you put those boxes right there by the door.
His hands gripped the doorframe tightly, and he rutted his hips involuntarily against the door. His whole body shook, watching you move so freely around your new home. He wondered what would happen if he just walked in and took you while you were bent over in a box. Your pussy was right there, hiding behind such a thin layer of fabric. Surely it would be easy to justâŠ
He bit his lip so hard he tasted iron, rolling his cock faster against the door. His breathing was labored, needy, and desperate for you. Basil knew he wasnât good enough for you, but you might like him if you just gave him a chance. He could thrust into your wet, velvety heat and make you scream out like it was the best thing youâd ever felt. Or maybe youâd cry out in terror because no one wants to fuck a monster.
He let out a low growl, feeling his cock ache while it leaked in his pants. Youâd heard the sound, stopping what you were doing to turn and face the door.Â
That was it.Â
That was all he needed to see before he lost it. His body shook against the door while a soft whimper left his lips. Hot cum spilled out through his clothes, leaving a wet streak on the wood heâd been rutting against. He sighed, finally feeling some sense of satisfying relief. Even after all the nights heâd spent palming his own release, heâd never felt so good.Â
You did this to him.Â
He had to move, looking into the peephole to see that you were coming closer. Basil darted from your door, opening his quickly and locking himself inside silently. He didnât want you to know he was there. He couldnât let you know he was there. He couldnât let you see his fucking face.
----
It only took him a few days to get your schedule figured out.Â
In the morning when you left - he presumed for work - you were dressed so nicely. He wouldâve followed you but, on account of his horrific deformity, he couldnât. So he settled for what little bits of you he could. He loved it most when youâd come home, tired from the day and retreating to your apartment so he could sneak over to your door and peek at you.
He would only allow himself a few moments of watching before his conscience forced him back to his own place where he would fuck his fist raw, passing out on the couch. Everything was fine, and he could see himself doing things that way forever, until it wasnât enough anymore.
He needed more.Â
Basil found a gift card to a coffee shop up the road that he knew only had a dollar and some change left on it, and made his way to your door late one night about a week after youâd moved in. You were already in bed, at least, he assumed you were. It was two in the morning and he couldnât hear a sound coming from your apartment. Basil stuck the card in between the frame and the door, wiggling very slowly so as not to make a lot of noise.
Click.
When your door opened slowly, he felt his heart fluttering wildly. This was it. This was the moment that he finally would get to see you. He stepped slowly, sock-covered feet treading silently over your floor. Your apartment was laid out exactly the same as his only mirrored, making it easy for him to get to your bedroom. He stopped when he got to the doorway though. There was a mirror on the wall to his right.
Turning to see his appearance, he lost all confidence. The grotesque creature looking back grounded him. He couldnât go in there, not like that. What if you woke up? Maybe if he was still attractive he could make you understand why he was there, standing over you and watching you sleep, but not like the way he looked now. If he tried that now, youâd scream, calling him a freak, or a monster. He couldnât risk hearing such horrid words coming out of such a pretty mouth, so he backed away.
âAnother dayâŠIâll see you another day then,â he whispered with a soft cry leaving his lips. âGoodbye.â
On his way out, he stopped when his foot landed on something unexpected on your living room floor. He reached down, feeling something soft in his hands. He knew immediately what he was holding, but he brought it to the dim light coming through the window from the moonlit sky to look at it anyway. They were black, made with delicate laceâŠyour panties.
----
Basil stared at your panties on his bed for at least two hours. He hadnât smelled them yet because he wanted to pace himself. He wanted to savor them, enjoy them as long as he could before he had to steal another pair. Deep down he hoped they would fix him; that theyâd be enough to satisfy the unquenchable thirst you seemed to fill him with. At the same time, he knew deep down that this was likely only the beginning of what would become something very, very, dark.
Taking the delicate fabric in his hands, he brought them to his face, rubbing the place that touched your cunt along his nostrils and inhaling so deep he thought he might faint. He shuddered, falling back and catching himself on his desk. He moaned, feeling them against his face once more.
âFuck, fuck babyâŠâ he whined, breath coming out in a ragged pant.
His tongue darted out, dragging along the place where your flavor was most potent. He whimpered, squeezing the desk so hard his knuckles ached. He licked again. You tasted too good, so delicious he thought he might die if he never got his mouth on the real thing.
Basilâs elbow brushed against the handle on the knife heâd stabbed into his desk multiple times. He snatched it up, holding it and turning it in his hand, letting the moonlight shine off the metal. He could see his mattress just over the edge, and had - what he thought was - a brilliant idea. His cock ached, and it was your fault. Once again he needed to satisfy his urges because you wouldnât.
He stormed over to the bed, knife in hand, before stabbing a hole deep into the center, making sure it was big enough to take him. He didnât even know where the knife landed when he threw it to the other side of his apartment, and he didnât care. Basil wrapped your panties around his pillow before hastily removing his pants, hands shaking in the process. Heâd never felt so fucking desperate.
If he closed his eyes, he could almost convince himself that the stuffing in the mattress was a good substitute for your beautiful pussy. It wasnât, nothing would ever be a good enough substitute for you, but this wasnât too bad. He slid himself in all the way, body shaking at the sensation as the cotton moved aside for him. Basil buried his face into your panties, taking in your smell some more, and licking them to breathe in your taste.
The bed rocked against the floor, probably loud enough to piss off the occupant of the apartment below him. He didnât fucking care, he was busy.
âMm, thatâs it, baby, you feel so fucking good,â he whispered the words he wished he could say to you. âSo tight, youâve been waiting for someone like me to come stretch you out hm? Fuck.â
He wondered if youâd like the way he sounded when he was grinding into you. Would you like listening to his hungry moans and low growls? What about when he whimpered and whined? He always thought he sounded a little pathetic, but would you judge him for it? He couldnât help it, when the pleasure overwhelmed him he had to vocalize it.
âHoney, youâre so sweet,â he kissed your panties, imagining that youâd squirm for him when he did. âSuch a pretty little pussy.â
He was good with his tongue, he knew youâd like it if youâd just let him have you. There wasnât a man alive that would spend hours with his tongue flicking over that swollen little clit until you were nearly pissing yourself from overstimulation, not the way Basil would. No one could love you the way he would.
His drool made your panties wet, the taste and smell already mixing with his own while he fucked the hole in his mattress sloppily. He got louder, practically yelling in a loud rasp while he mouthed at his pillow.
âYouâre so good, s-so g-good.â His voice became heavier, deeper, more like a low, feral growl as his climax closed in.
Basilâs body stopped with his cock buried to the hilt inside the mattress. His body trembled and shook while he pumped shot after shot of hot sticky cum into the cotton. He was practically screaming, face buried into the pillow to muffle the sounds. His mind went blank, except for your face. He felt his cock twitching, emptying every bit it could into the damn mattress.
It was just a fucking mattress.
Basilâs heavy breathing slowed and eventually turned to sobs. He held the pillow close, crying into it, soaking the fabric with his tears. What kind of loser fucks a mattress? He thought to himself, feeling his cock getting soft inside the hole heâd made.
----
Basil woke the next morning with his drool adhering your panties to his scarred cheek. His cock was dried with cum to the hole in his mattress. He groaned, feeling like heâd had the night of his lifeâŠonly to quickly realize that he looked like a pathetic mess that his own mother couldnât even bring herself to love. Heâd fucked his mattress.
What kind of loserâŠ
His thoughts trailed off before he could finish repeating the sentiment of the night before. He peeled his face off the pillow and winced in pain while pulling his dick out of the bed. He heard your voice in the hall, calling him like a siren song to his peephole. He looked out there, and you were standing in the hall laughing with your phone to your ear.
âYeah you can pick me up at seven, that would be great,â you said as you disappeared out of view.
âThe moving manâŠâ Basil said to himself, turning away from the door and running both hands through his hair with his eyes wide, his anger building.
He saw himself in the mirror again, face dropping as he was reminded of his disgusting appearance. His hair was everywhere, cock limp and just hanging there like a sad, pathetic thing. His shirt had pizza sauce stains all over, and discoloration under the armpits. In a moment - a very short moment - of clarity, Basil realized that even if he did manage to get you to move on from the scar, he wouldnât be able to impress you looking, and smelling, the way he did.Â
âAlright, youâre going on a fucking date with some fucking loser huh?â He said, feeling the pain ripping through his chest. âLet me show you what youâre missing!â
He showered, feeling clean for the first time since the incident. When he stepped out of the shower, he noticed the good side of his face for the first time in over two weeks. The way the steam covered the mirror, only the unblemished side was visible. He touched it, feeling comfort in the fact that he could pretend for a moment that he was normal, that everything was normal.
He turned the hot water in his bathroom sink on, keeping the mirror steamed up while he took his razor blade and shaving cream out of the cabinet. He had to keep wiping the mirror so he could see himself, and that was probably why he nicked his cheek a little. He cursed, finishing the shave and then holding a small bit of toilet paper to the wound. As if he needed more deformities on his face.
Once composed, Basil walked out to his living room, realizing finally what a mess it was. He couldnât possibly bring you in there with it looking like that. And he was going to bring you in there one way or another.
It took him all day to get his apartment back to a, somewhat, normal state. Basil had to push through several mood swings in the process, fantasizing about how impressed you would be, complimenting how nice his place was, and reality creeping its way into his mind and reminding him that you were going on a date tonightâŠ
A knock on his door forced all the thoughts to a stop. Who the fuck was knocking on his door? He hadnât bought pizza or groceries. The new mattress he ordered wasnât expected until next week. Basil walked up to his peephole, peering through only to nearly collapse when he saw you. He stepped away from the door as if it were made of hot coals.
âHoly shit,â he whispered. His body immediately started trembling. âUmâŠI canât come to the door right now!â
âOh!â He held his chest when you spoke. You were speaking to him. âWell thatâs okay, I just wanted to leave you some cookies.â You chuckled softly. âI honestly didnât even realize I had a neighbor until I heard you playing some cool music yesterday.â
âC-cool music?âÂ
Basil was still so in shock that you were even speaking to him that heâd forgotten how inconsiderate heâd been yesterday afternoon. He remembered playing music so loudly it probably could be heard by you and the downstairs neighbor.
âIâm sorry if it was annoying, Iâll keep it down nextââ
âNo itâs alright! I actually like it!â You couldnât be that perfect, you couldnât be. âWell, I hope you like chocolate chip, Iâll leave them here! Iâm not the best cook but I tried.â
Your little giggle would be the death of him.Â
âI would like anything you made for meâŠâ He said softly as he was struggling to breathe.
âWhat did you say?â
He cleared his throat, âI umâŠthank you so much Iâm sure theyâre great.â
âOkay well, have a good day! Maybe Iâll see you another time.â
With that, you were gone, and Basilâs knees felt so weak he had to sit on the floor. You talked to him. You fucking talked to him. You really did like him. You must have liked him, why else would you have come to his door and left him such a nice gift?
Basil waited by his door until he was sure you were gone before opening it and pulling the cookies inside. They were still warm, you mustâve just made them and waited for them to cool off before bringing them to his door. He held one in his hand, turning it around to decide which side to bite first. He finally bit into it, feeling the sweet flavor fill his mouth, forcing a smile over his lips.
You made those for him.Â
Basil ate too many cookies, and with the pang of despair rushing through him periodically at the thought of you going on a date in just an hour, he found himself with his head in the toilet bowl, vomiting uncontrollably. He groaned into the bowl, beginning to cry in frustration. He couldnât keep himself together. You deserved to go on that date with someone else, someone who wouldnât flush the delicious gift you brought them because they didnât know how to establish self-control.
Your door opened at 6:55pm on the dot. Basil was, of course, watching you. He felt his cock aching immediately at the sight of you in that tight black dress. Watching the way it shifted as your hips swayed down the hall made his heart rate rise quickly. He couldnât believe that someone else would be seeing you in that, touching you in that.
He had the urge to be destructive again, feeling his breathing become rapid and labored in panic. He went to the window where he could see the street below to watch you get into the manâs car, only to see you standing there shivering. Why hadnât you worn a coat? Basil looked over at the clock, 7:01pm. The guy was late.
While he didnât enjoy seeing you waiting in the cold, Basil did like knowing the man was unreliable. He watched you pull out your phone, likely calling your missing date. He could tell the man didnât answer by the way your arm dropped to your hip and head hung in disappointment. You waited though, still hoping he would show up, just standing there in the cold.
For ten more minutes Basil watched you wait, full of hope, only to end up disappointed in the end on your walk back into the building. He couldnât remember the last time heâd been so happy, wanting desperately to rush out into the hall and offer to take you out. He couldnât thoughâŠthat stupid fucking scar was ruining his life.
It hit him suddenly, that you would be hungry. He couldnât let you go hungry, not after how sweet youâd been to him, so it was time to repay the favor. Even before the incident, Basil couldnât cook for shit, and he wasnât about to try now. This opened the door for another opportunity thoughâŠan opportunity to see you in personâŠ
âNo, no youâre crazy,â he said, looking at himself in the mirror.
He couldnât see you like that, not with the horrible scar. And showing up at your doorstep with food in hand and a paper bag on his head would be even weirder than the scar. But if you were asleep, well, it would be hard to be afraid of him thenâŠwouldnât it?
With a plan in place, he called to order a pizza. He didnât know what you liked yet, but everyone liked pizza, right? You were nice, youâd probably eat it even if it wasnât your favorite. Plus youâd be hungry. He was banking on you being hungry.
The food arrived at his door a little while later, and the delivery man knew to just leave it on the floor. Basil took the sleeping pills he was prescribed and crushed them, sprinkling the dust over each slice so you were sure to get some in your system. Every bit of reasonable thinking was gone. He needed more than just your damn panties and a cum filled mattress.
He needed you.
Basil put the pizza in front of your door and knocked before scrambling back into his own place. He watched through the peephole as you stepped out, dressed in a comfortable pair of sweats and a loose t-shirt. You sniffled and looked down at the pizza with a confused expression. It was obvious that youâd been crying.
Thatâs what you get for thinking someone else could do better for you than I can. Basil thought to himself.
You lifted the sticky note heâd adhered to the box, reading over it slowly before a smile appeared on your face.
Thought you might be hungry.
The cookies were really good, hereâs some pizza.
Your neighbor, Basil
Basilâs heart nearly stopped. You were smiling because of something he did. You were smiling because of him.
âThis is so nice of you,â you said softly, looking at the door. âWould youâŠwould you want to come in and have some too?â
Thereâs no way this was real. Thereâs no way you were actually inviting him into your apartment. Basil looked down at his clothes and straightened out his shirt. His breathing became shallow at the thought. This was so unexpected, he couldnât believe it. Basil looked over at the table next to the door and caught a glimpse of his reflection in the bowl he usually tossed his keys in.Â
âUmâŠI canât, but you should enjoy it,â he said with a crack in his voice.
He was surprised to see the look of disappointment on your face. This must be his delusions toying with him again. You werenât disappointed that he wouldnât come to your apartment, that would never be the case. He stood there awkwardly, watching you through the peephole, waiting for you to leave.
âWell, you didnât have to do this, but thank you so much, I actually am hungry.â You paused and sighed, âIâm glad you liked the cookies,â you said to him before retreating to your own apartment once again, pizza in hand.
Basil was trembling at the door for the better part of a half hour. He was stunned by your reaction, by the fact that you invited him over. It couldnât be real. Youâd fucking invited him over! If youâd known what a loser he was, would you have still invited him? If youâd known he fucked a hole in his mattress while intoxicated by the smell of your cunt would you still want him in your home?
----
He waited until it was late and he knew youâd be sound asleep. He walked into your apartment, noticing the pizza on the counter, the box still open, and three slices missing. Surely youâd consumed enough to be comatose for the time being. He stepped into your bedroom and froze.
âWow,â he whispered, staring intently at your half-dressed form on the bed.
You hadnât even covered up. Did you know there was a chance he might creep into your house and you wanted to be ready for him? Did you wear that tank top that barely covered anything and those lacy panties knowing he would like them? What about the way your lips partedâŠwere you expecting him to kiss them?
Basil knelt down, reaching his shaking hand out to touch your cheek. Your skin was so soft. He felt a sob swelling in his chest. If his face was still soft, would you let him touch you while you were awake? Would you be able to actually look at him without being disgusted? He couldnât even look at himself without being disgusted anymore.
âSo prettyâŠâ
He leaned in, brushing his nose against yours, in a small way he was testing to see if it would wake you. You stayed asleep, and so he moved forward, pressing his lips against yours. He stayed there for so long, just letting his mouth linger, feeling the way his skin felt against yours. He felt his cock growing already, aching and pressing against the zipper in his jeans. He wanted to feel your mouth in other ways, a kiss wasnât enough.
âSomeday I hope youâll be able to enjoy this while youâre awake butâŠfor now this is how we need to do this, okay?â he looked at you, knowing you wouldnât answer, but hoping your subconscious would somehow hear him and understand.
Basil unbuttoned his pants, sliding the zipper down slowly and pulling the waist down with his boxer briefs as well. His fat cock bobbed out, already leaking from the head, slick strands dripping to the floor beneath him. He held the top of your head with one hand, and his length with the other, bringing the weeping tip to your pretty lips.
His body trembled immediately, feeling the way your mouth opened around his girth. He moved in further, feeling the wet heat of your tongue on the underside of his shaft. If he gagged you would you wake? He tested it, sliding forward more, watching those lips stretch around him. If you were awake youâd look up at him so pretty, eyes filling with tears as you struggled to take him all the way.
He stuffed himself all the way into your mouth, the tip of his cock resting in your throat. He could feel your body responding to the foreign object naturally, throat closing around him while you gagged, but you stayed asleep. The feeling was indescribable, causing his entire body to shake and tremble while he kept your head impaled on him.
âYouâre too good baby, too goodâŠyou're gonna make me comeâŠgonna make me come too fast! Ah!â
Basil pulled his cock out of your mouth and jerked his spend onto your cheek. He fisted himself angrily, beyond pissed that he couldnât hold it in for more than one fucking minute. If the time ever came - which he expected it wouldnât - that he managed to get you in bed while awake, if his face didnât scare you off, the fact that he was a minuteman surely would.
He looked all around for something to clean you up with, but anything in your apartment would have to be taken out, or else youâd know someone was there. Basil decided to peel off his t-shirt, using that to wipe your face clean. He leaned against the wall, looking at you, still scowling and infuriated with his inability to perform, even while you were sleeping.
The longer he looked at you though, the more aroused he became all over again. Maybe getting off so quickly wouldnât be a dealbreakerâŠnot with you being his own personal aphrodisiac. He walked over to you again, touching your hip and squeezing your flesh. He pushed you onto your back, hooking a finger into the waist of your cute little panties. To his surprise, between your lips was sticky, warm, and wet. Did he do this to you? Did he have this effect on you?
Basil pulled your underwear down your beautiful legs slowly, staring at the slit between them hungrily. He felt some drool spilling over his bottom lip that he wiped away quickly. Tossing your panties aside, he crawled onto the bed, lowering his head between your thighs. He could smell you as he closed in, the same familiar smell heâd spent the other night drowning himself in.
Using two thick fingers, he spread your lips, watching the slick strands of your arousal stretch and break as they moved further apart. Everything was glistening and wet, and it was all for him. He leaned in, licking a stripe up and collecting what he could on his tongue, bringing it in past his lips and letting the taste settle in his mouth before swallowing.
He became immediately addicted, going in and pressing his face against your mound, moaning loudly into it. He wondered if youâd notice the feeling of his textured skin against your thighs. Would you find that disgusting? Of course you would. Youâd probably yell at him and throw him out of your apartment just for looking at you with that milky broken eye in his head while he ate you out.
Not while you were asleep though. While you were sleeping he could plunge two fingers into your tight little hole and feel your cunt clenching around him. In your sleep you wanted him, you were pulling his fingers in deeper like you were starving and needed to taste him. It wasnât enough, his fingers just werenât going to do it for you, you needed more.
Positioning himself between your limp legs, Basil brought his cock to your entrance, gliding it between your folds to get it slick with your juices. If you were awake he imagined you might be moaning, whimpering, maybe even begging for him. He tested your threshold, seeing how well the last man in there had stretched you out. Not very well it would seem.
Slowly, he slid himself in, shuddering as he felt your walls closing down over every inch. He used two fingers to hold your puffy lips open so he could watch your cunt swallowing his cock. He needed to last, he needed to keep himself from coming too soon again. He might be a pathetic freak, but he wasnât going to spill his load like one.
Fuck.
He wondered if this was how he would keep you. It was entirely possible heâd just pumped a baby into you without your knowledge, but that was okay. It was perfect actually. You wouldnât want to have a baby without someone around to help you, right? Heâd be able to swoop in and be there for you, to care for you.
He touched your stomach as he pulled out of you. He shuddered on the way out, looking down at the mess he made as it trickled from your pretty little hole. Basil had never been so proud of something in all his life. He may have been a hideous monster, but he made you look so beautiful just by stuffing you with everything he could. He wanted to do more. He wanted to do it again.
But he wanted you to be awake this time.
----
Another week went by of you and Basil trading food and notes throughout the day. It started the morning after he fucked your sleeping body that you came by with breakfast. He smiled and nearly cried again as he watched you put down the plate with a metal lid keeping it warm as if heâd ordered room service.
âGood morning. I donât know if you like coffee but, you can come over and get some if you want,â you said, waiting to see if heâd respond.
He didnât, instead he just stood there staring at you. He didnât want to come over yet. Not while you were awake anyway. He couldnât stand the idea of you seeing him and being afraid of what you saw. The thought of it was devastating and it hadnât even happened yet.
âUm, no thank you. Thank you for the breakfast though Iâm looking forward to it. Youâre a great cook.â He said through the door.
You looked disappointed again. Were you lonely or something? Why did you care if your neighbor wanted to come over or not? You didnât even know him, wasnât that dangerous? He sniffed out a laugh at his own thoughts.
âItâs fine, my offer stands,â you started for your apartment again.
âIâll cover lunch,â he said quickly before you disappeared.
When lunch came, he wanted to do something better than pizza. You deserved something good after what youâd done for him the other night, so he ordered from one of the fancy restaurants nearby and had it delivered to your door. When you retrieved your food, you furrowed your brow and smiled widely.
âReally? Ginoâs? That place is pretty pricey.â
âWell, youâre really kind so⊠I thought Iâd do something nice for you,â he felt nervous every time you spoke to him.
To his surprise, you left the bag in the hall and disappeared into your apartment. Did he do something wrong? He started panicking, thinking maybe heâd offended you somehow. Did you hate expensive food? Did you not like Ginoâs? He reached for the handle, ready to pull the bag into his apartment and hope you forgot about it altogether when your door opened again and you stepped out with a folding chair in hand.
âWell, if youâre going to buy me an expensive meal, the least I can do is join you for lunch. Did you get something to eat?â You asked, sitting down and pulling out the meal heâd bought for you.
âUh, wellâŠâ he felt his stomach grumble suddenly when he realized he hadnât thought of his own hunger in the slightest, âI had a big breakfast.â
You chuckled, âYeah so did IâŠhereâŠâ
Basil watched in awe, still shocked you were even giving him the time of day, as you sorted the containers of food and made two meals out of the one he bought. You reached for his door and then stopped, dropping your hand at your side.
âI know you like to keep to yourself, so Iâll leave this here and turn around so you can get it, okay?â
Why were you so understanding? Were you quite literally the epitome of perfection wrapped up in the most beautiful looking person heâd ever seen? Basil, at this point, was nearly certain he was having visual hallucinations. It wouldnât be the first time since the incident that heâd thought heâd seen thingsâŠor heard things. Maybe this was just him going completely nuts. Maybe this was just an extension of his psychotic break. You put the box of food down and turned.
Slowly, Basil opened the door, not peeking his head out far enough that youâd be able to see even if you did turn around, and he pulled the food back inside. You didnât even try to peek. You didnât let - what he assumed to be - your morbid curiosity get the better of you. Basil pulled a chair over and sat with his half of the meal on the other side of the door.
He couldnât see you now, but he could hear you, and that was good enough for him.
âSo, you obviously saw me get ridiculously embarrassed last night,â you said from the other side of the door.
He smirked, thinking about how much he enjoyed you last night, and how much you seemed to enjoy him, despite not ever knowing he was there. You called it embarrassing, but to Basil, it was an amazing, and unwasted, opportunity to show you something better.
âWell, maybe itâs good that heâs doing this now instead of wasting your time later,â Basil said, taking a bite of his food.
He thought about Katherine and the way sheâd been to him. She cheated on him for so long, and yet he stayed. Since seeing you, Basil considered that he never really loved her, he just hated the thought of admitting someone could cast him away so easily after so many years. He further hated the thought of losing the social status that came with having a girlfriend. Everyone seemed to respect you and treat you differently if you had a pretty girl on your arm. He wouldâve dealt with the cheating to avoid the shame of admitting sheâd cheated on him, but he never really loved her.
Not the way he loved you.
âYouâre very right about that,â you agreed with a mouthful of food. âWhat about you? Are you seeing someone?â
Basil laughed loudly, âme? Is that a joke?â
âHey, just because youâre a hermit doesnât mean you donât have some online girlfriend or something.â
âNoâŠno, no one would be interested in me,â Basil felt the weight of his loneliness on his chest again.
âYou seem like a sweet guy, and you do have great taste in music, Iâm sure thereâs someone out there who would love to date you,â you chuckled, âthis kinda feels like a date.â
Basil put his food down, having completely lost his appetite in favor of this conversation with you. He stood, going back to the peephole. You mustâve heard him because you looked up at him with those beautiful eyes of yours and stared.
âWhy?â He asked. âThis is weird.â
âWhatâs weird? Me talking to you about my dating life when you literally live next door to me? You probably know more about whatâs happening in my personal life than anyone,â you said, shaking your head and putting your food on the floor too.
You got up and walked to the door, putting your palm on the wood paneling and resting it there.
âWhen I came in from that date, well, lack thereof, I called my best friend and my mom, and no one answered,â you looked at the floor and then back at the peephole. âSome stranger who I hardly know, but who also seems to be going through something, was kind enough to send me a pizza. That kinda checks off a lot of boxes for me as far as someone I might be interested in getting to know better.â
âWhat if you find out Iâm actually a horrible person? Like you said, you donât know me,â he retorted, thinking about what heâd done to that pizza you were so grateful for.
âAre you a murderer?â You asked bluntly, keeping your eye on the peephole.
âWell no, no Iâm not.â
âOkay then I donât thinkââ
âWhat if Iâm hideous?â
âI donât give a shit about looks really,â you sighed and sat back down in your chair. âI know this is weird, thatâs why I just want to talk to you, get to know you a little. Is that alright?â
You were right. There was no harm in getting to know him, except it gave him hope. The last thing he could handle was the thought of you leading him on and then turning him down once you saw his face. What if getting to know you only made his obsession grow? How would he ever recover from the crushing despair if you rejected him once you saw what he really looked like?
âFine,â he said, sitting back down.
For days you shared meals and stories, taking turns sitting outside the otherâs door while getting to know one another. Basil was falling for you. It was more than just that obsession to fuck you now, it was that need to call you his. It was the need to have you smiling and laughing with him on a lazy Sunday morning or while apple picking in the fall. Simultaneously, it was the need to have you moaning his name while you took every inch he had.
He would overcome anything for you, even his greatest fear, which was risking your potential rejection of him.
He gave himself the excuse he needed to knock on your door and come inside. Youâd had a heavy package delivered, and while he was certain you could handle it, he decided to offer some help. Basil knocked on your door, heart pounding with every step he heard you took toward him. He adjusted the paper bag on his head, knowing he looked foolish, but he wasnât ready to show you everything yet.
You opened the door, and he saw your eyes scanning him up and down. This was the first time he was seeing you in the open while awake, and you took his breath away. It was evening, so the two of you had already had your dinner date. The UPS driver came late, and you probably hadnât planned on company, hence the short shorts and ill-fitting tank top.
âBasil?â You asked, raising an eyebrow.
You were judging him, he could tell. His palms started to sweat and he lost the ability to speak. Could he remember how to breathe?
âOh, my package!â You exclaimed, walking over to it and trying uselessly to lift it.
âI got it,â he said, coming out of his stupor and rushing to aid you.
You thanked him as he brought the package into your apartment and placed it down on your floor by the couch with a heavy grunt. He stood up, stepping away from the package. His paper bag rustled as he did so.
âThanks. I probably couldâve dragged that in here myself butâŠI appreciate the help,â you sighed, giving Basil a smile that nearly stretched ear to ear.
If you could see his face, youâd see how flushed his cheeks were at your charming expression.
âWhat?â He asked, keeping his eyes on you.
âIâm just happy to see you out of your apartment,â you explained sincerely. âYou donât have to keep the bag on unless you want to, but itâs going to be kinda hard to drink some wine with it on.â
You went to one of your cupboards and pulled out a bottle of Barefoot Moscato and two glasses.
âAll Iâve got is white, and itâs cheap,â you said, pouring the drinks.
âOh umâŠIâm notâŠI was going to go backâŠâ
âCome on Basil, please just stay for one glass?â
How could he say no when you looked at him like that? So sweet and begging that it nearly brought a tear to his eye to even think about turning you down.
âY-you really want me to s-stay? You donât think Iâm weird orââ
You laughed, âI mean, you are wearing a bag on your head, I canât lie and say thatâs not odd butâŠâ you trailed off as you handed him the glass of wine. âWeâre all a little weird right? I mean, Iâm letting a guy I barely know have wine with me in my apartment with a bag on his head. Whoâs weirder?â
Basil couldnât help laughing. You made a good point, so he decided to try and relax, and the wine certainly helped. Three glasses in each and you were both feeling a bit more loose, but he was also feeling something else. While you were laughing and telling him about how annoying this girl at work was, your breasts were bouncing with every wild movement of your arms. He was mesmerized.
â-And when I tell you thatâs all she ever doesâŠare you listening?â The bag on Basilâs head shifted as he looked back at your eyes.
âYeah, yes.â
You chuckled, looking down at your chest and back up at him, shaking your head.
âAll you men are the same, just after one thing huh?â You asked, downing a fourth glass of wine.
Basilâs heart stopped in terror. No. No, you couldnât possibly think that of him could you?
âNo, no itâs the wine Iâm sorry I was zoning out and I wasnât even looking at them IâŠIâm so sorrââ
âIâm kidding. You think I wouldâve answered the door when I saw it was you out there wearing this if I didnât want you to look at me?â
Basil let out a half-hearted chuckle, trying to breathe again, âkidding, rightâŠâ he finished off another glass as well. It was then that he realized what youâd said. âYou want me to l-look at you? LikeâŠlike youâŠâ he gulped, âyou want me toâŠâ
You laughed, nodding and sighing at him affectionately.
âBasil, I think youâre a nice guy, I want you to look at me.â
His mind was fuzzy, and even with only one good eye, he could see clearly as you started to bring the straps of your tank top down. Either your self-esteem was so on the floor, and youâd take your top off for any man that gave you the time of day, or you were really into him. He didnât want to get his hopes up only to have them crushed, so he took what he could get, and enjoyed the moment, watching you lower your top down, showing your beautiful chest off in a lacy bralette.
You couldnât see the way Basilâs jaw dropped, or see the way the drool dribbled down his chin, but he couldnât breathe again.
âIâm going to assume that you like what you see, even though I canât tell what youâre looking atâŠâ you raised your eyebrows.
âYes, yes Iâm sorry Iâm justâŠwowâŠâ
âWanna feel âem?â You asked with a hiccup.
Could you get cuter? Your big, gorgeous eyes were looking at him from the other side of the couch, begging for validation. You really needed someone as pathetic as him to validate you? Someone so beautiful needed his reassurance to feel adequate? You were practically asking him to tell you just how much he loved your tits and wanted them. Who was he to deny you?
âUmâŠIâŠâ
Before he could stutter any longer, you were crawling on the couch over to him, sitting on your knees, your chest perked up for him to admire. Basilâs cock had been at half mast for the better part of the hour, and now it was threatening to bust through the seam holding it back. With a shaking hand, he reached out, touching your breast underneath the thin fabric of the bralette. You bit your lip as his thumb brushed over your hard nipple.
âYou have really big hands,â you said with a giggle that made Basilâs body spark with an electric shock.
âYou like that? Big hands?â He asked, bringing his other hand to cup your neglected right breast.
âI do,â your tone was sultry and sweet.
A breathy moan escaped as his hands massaged your tits, taking his time to rub his thumbs over your peaks, feeling the way they got harder under the bralette. He pinched them, enjoying the way you whimpered when he did. You were so sensitive, he knew you would be, he could feel it.
He felt something else too, the unmistakable and insurmountable arousal growing inside of him and pooling in his groin. He cursed under his breath, squeezing your tits tight while he felt the heat, shooting in spurts, and wetting his lap, making a mess of himselfâŠright in front of you. Basil froze, afraid to move, afraid that you would see how pathetic he was, blowing his load after only touching you for a second.
âDidâŠdid you justâŠâ you started, looking down at the dark, wet spot on his lap.
âIâm so sorry, this has never happened to me before,â he lied, trying to cover himself with his hands. âIâll go, oh myââ
âNo wait,â you say, putting a hand on his shoulder before he could leave. âAre you kidding me? Thatâs so fucking hot.â
That was it, the proof Basil needed to convince himself that you were all in his head. Though he usually couldnât feel his hallucinations, not like this anyway. He wouldâve kissed you right then, but he couldnât. You still didnât know what he looked like, and no matter how much of his odd behavior you were willing to accept, he couldnât be certain you would accept his deformity.
âCan you bend over for me?â He asked, voice soft and pleading.
You bit your lip and nodded slowly, turning around and putting a throw pillow under your chest. Basil removed the bag from his face, letting it drop off to the side of the couch. He could see you much more clearly now, bent over so nicely for him, rear poised and ready for him to touch. He stood up and unclasped his belt, then pulled down his soiled pants and boxer briefs, discarding them on the floor.
âCan you promise me you wonât look?â He asked, holding onto your hips as he positioned himself behind you.
You giggled and nodded, âyeah, I wonât look, I promise.â
He leaned over you, âthank you,â he whispered in your ear, feeling your body shudder in response, âsuch a sensitive girl.â
You whined as he kissed down your shoulder, bringing his hands to your waist and holding tightly. He ran his cock between your ass cheeks, feeling the sweet friction they provided was going to set him off again so soon after he just came. You said it was hot thoughâŠ
âIâm sorry, itâs coming again I canât stopâah!â
Basil moved his hips faster and faster until he was shooting heavy ropes of white all over your back, getting some on the couch. He felt his cheeks flush with embarrassment, despite your saying how much you liked it. You laughed again, wiggling your ass a little and rubbing it along his length.
âSuch a needy boy,â you taunted, âget it in me next time.â
He furrowed his brow, running the fat tip of his cock along your slit. You still made him so fucking hard, no matter how many times he came, he could keep going as long as you were around. Basil watched your lips part, swallowing him whole until his pubic hair was brushing against your rear. He whined, feeling your walls flutter around him and hearing your satisfied sigh.
âYes, oh wow, youâre f-fucking h-huge,â you said, gasping as though heâd been pounding you for hours, but he still hadnât moved since he slid into you.
âYou really like it? You think itâs big?â He pulled back, seeing how wet you made his cock until he slammed forward again.
You cried out, âoh god yes!â
Basil squeezed your waist tighter, finding a smooth rhythm that kept you wailing and drooling on your own couch. He watched you hold onto the arm of the couch, burying your face into the pillow and screaming into it like he was killing you. He pushed on your back, forcing you to gasp and groan, face being forced into the cushions.
He leaned forward, kissing your shoulder, âtell me how much you like it,â he whispered, âplease, I need to hear you tell me how good I feel.â
âI-oh god I canât-mm!â
âPlease,â he begged pathetically, kissing your back again, âtell me itâs good, please.â
âItâs good Basil itâsâŠoh!â
He felt your pussy squeeze around him, and when he looked down he could see it throbbing while you gushed over his cock. You were incoherent, making high pitched whines as you continued losing yourself in the euphoria. Heâd slowed his movements, trying once again to contain himself a little longer. It was clear you wanted more when you started moving on him again on your own, taking what you knew you needed.
âBasil,â you mewled.
He leaned into you again, âyeah?â
âI want to see you, please,â you said, voice pleading for the one thing he never wanted to give you.
Basil would give you his soul, his body, everything in his bank account in order to avoid letting you see his fucking face. He slammed into your hips, growing a little frustrated with your curiosity. Did you want to see it so you could mock him? So you could laugh at the man while he fucked you full? Why did you need to see him so badly?
âI want to see your face when you come,â you said as though you could read his mind.
Basil pulled out of you.
This was it.
He couldnât keep hiding from you.
He sat back, feeling the cool leather of the couch against his rear.
âFine,â he said coldly, feeling dread weighing on his chest, making it hard to breathe.
You turned around slowly until you finally met his gaze. Your lips parted slowly, eyes scanning over his face as though you were mapping it out, memorizing the details. As you leaned in closer, Basil turned his face away from you, shielding the deformity from your eyes as though it might make you hate it less. He could feel the tears welling, he was already anticipating your harsh words.
âWhy are you hiding from me? Pretty boy,â you cooed in the softest voice, reaching out a hand and touching his scarred cheek, turning him to face you.
âW-what did you just say?â He asked, a tear spilling over and running down his cheek.
âI canât believe youâd keep your beautiful face hidden from me like that,â you climbed over his lap, straddling his hips.
âAre you playing with me? Huh? Whatâs your angle? Are you going to go to work tomorrow and tell all your friends you fucked a freak?â He was getting angry, but trying to keep it from boiling over.
You giggled, âdo you really think that lowly of me, Basil?â your face closed in on his and your lips brushed against the rippled skin on his cheek softly.
He choked out a moan as you lowered yourself on him, stuffing your cunt full of him once again. You liked his face? You really liked it? He threw his head back, hair falling out of his eyes as he looked up at you. He guided you as you bounced up and down on his dick, feeling it bruising the deepest parts of you. You brought your hands to the back of his head, holding onto his dark curls tight while you kissed him deeply.
âMm, youâre so so-good-baby,â he growled lowly, âuse me, use me to get off again, I want you to come on me again and again Iââ
âShh,â you whispered, pressing your lips to his, forcing your tongue past his lips, and the second he tasted you, he let out a whimpering moan.
He squeezed your hips tighter, intoxicated by the feeling of you, and the sounds of your wet pussy slapping against his lap. He started rolling his hips upward, feeling himself getting deeper and deeper with every pass. It was like your body knew he belonged in there, making room for him as it should. You let out a guttural moan, deep from inside of you, and Basil could feel your cunt starting to flutter around him again.Â
He latched his lips to your neck, and you immediately held onto both of his shoulders and lurched forward, hips freezing while your cunt contracted over him in waves. Basil came once again, cock throbbing while it filled your little hole with everything he had. He pulled your hips down, placing both hands on top of your thighs and holding you there while he rutted upward, sobbing as he did.
He couldnât believe you let him take you. He couldnât believe you called him pretty. Most of all, he couldnât believe that when you were both finished, panting heavily on the couch as clarity set in, you didnât call him an ugly monster and scream at him to leave your apartment.
âSo youâŠwas thatâŠdid I do alright? You liked it? You donât think Iâm hideous?â
âBasilâŠâ you leaned in and kissed his nose, âyouâre perfect.â
Miscellaneous Character Masterlist
Main Masterlist
