Yo Ho - A Sylus/Rafayel x Reader CrowFishMC Fic
Rating: Explicit
Wordcount: 1.7k
CW: No MC pronouns used, Gender Neutral genitalia , No Y/N used, Pegging, Strap-ons, Bottom Rafayel, Established CrowFish, Dragon Tail Sex, DP One Hole, Dragon Hybrid! Sylus, Lemurian God Rafayel, Pirate Captain Reader
Events: BBPT (Bring Back the Porn on Dreamwidth) and Straptember
Link to A03 for easier reading: here
Preview: You are a pirate captain and stumble upon two of your newest crew members on your bed.
“Would you like to try as well, Captain?” Sylus drawled as you entered your cabin, frozen on the spot as you watched his cock plunging in and out of Rafayel who was face down on your sheets, gripping them and whining as the ship rocked back and forth.
You had been tasked by your ruler to hunt down rogue Wanderers on the deep sea and sabotage any enemy vessels or steal their relics if need be and you had thought of no one better to join you than some of your closest friends and the two rogue Wanderers you had grown fond of aboard your ship The Unicorn. Rafayel had been trailing your ship for weeks underwater, a giant shadowy figure in the depths that had your entire crew nervous and prepared to attack. You nearly had, until he had emerged as a strange half human, half fish in a whirlpool and warned you and the crew of three enemy ships approaching before taking them down. He had injured himself in the process and you had taken him aboard when a dragon had landed on the bow of your ship, growling in warning about his mate. Sylus, as you learned his name was, had also been trailing your ship from above for whatever reason you had yet to learn, and had ingratiated himself as your relic keeper and appraiser on the ship while Rafayel painted your adventures. Caleb, your first mate and navigator, often found in the crow’s nest had fought against having them onboard while Zayne, the ship medic, did not seem to care. You had caught Xavier, who defected from the royal army to join you, and handled the ship’s weapons and cargo, trying to throw them both overboard several times.
But here you were, Captain of The Unicorn, with the Legendary Wanderers known as the Terrors of the Skies and Seas fornicating in your bed.
“This explains the storm. Any reason you two are in my quarters when I have given you your own and turned a blind eye to the treasures you have been hiding away in your little nest in there?” You drawled, crossing your arms and raising an eyebrow as Sylus didn’t even have the decency to stop pounding into Rafayel who was whimpering and looking at you with teary eyes and a flushed face.
“Because I thought that you might like to punish him as well. Our little fish had swam off on his own and has become… rather ill.” Sylus said, his wings flaring out as his draconic tail swished under the black toga he wore in his more humanoid form, a gladiator’s golden pauldron on his left shoulder.
You rushed over in alarm, pushing back Rafayel’s long, sweaty tresses back as shimmering blue scales appeared on his cheeks. No member of your crew would suffer.
“I am alright, just… hot…” Rafayel mumbled with embarrassment, cheeks red as he turned slightly from you and let out a cry.
“Yes, tell our dear Captain how you foolishly coated yourself into aphrodisiac anemones to lure them to our bed but could not stand it and begged me to fill you.” Sylus said as heat grew in your abdomen.
“You two are mates, why would you want me in your bed? Out of obligation? To repay me? I don’t want that.” You spat, even if it hurt to deny the strange connection you felt with them.
“Perhaps you are our mate as well… have you not wondered why we followed you for so long? We were waiting for the right time, but someone was impatient. Yes, Darling, hold on.” Sylus grunted, pulling Rafayel up by his arms with one hand to deepen his thrusts and stroke Rafayel’s long slender cock that had a strange light blue hue at the leaking tapered tip. You found that you could not avert your eyes nor could you find words.
As Rafayel came, thunder cracked and his cries echoed with a haunting tune in your cabin. Sylus did not slow his thrusts and you watched as Rafayel’s cock twitched and hardened once more.
“Well, must I ask you again? Would you like to try? We found quite the fun looking toy in your chest, isn’t that right?” Sylus crooned, biting Rafayel’s neck as he nodded and you felt yourself throbbing.
You knew what they had found. You had won it in a card game at one of the secret pirate taverns you frequented, The Nest.
You pressed your lips together, biting them. This would be crossing a line. You couldn’t exactly abandon these two powerful Wanderers the next time you went ashore. There would be no coming back from this, but you were a Captain for a reason.
“Are you both sure?” You asked hesitantly and Rafayel panted and whined.
“Yes, please. Want you. Have for a long time after I was chained. Need you both.” Rafayel sobbed and you sucked in a shaky breath as you saw his toned stomach bulge from the force of Sylus’ thrusts.
“Oh, yes, Dear Captain. Now come here and let me taste you.” Sylus said, tail curling around you and bringing you to him as he kissed you. You moaned as his tail slid between your legs slithered against your core, each ridge sending a shock of pleasure through you. You pulled back and gave him a warning look as the curled barb threatened to hook into your coat and shred it to pieces. You had worked hard for it and it was your favorite.
Rafayel gave a desperate whine as you stepped back to avoid Sylus’ tail and you bent down to kiss softly, before disrobing, shivering under the heated, hungry gazes of both. You swayed over to your chest, naked as the ship rocked amongst the waves and pulled out what they had discovered. A golden phallus was nestled against buttery leather straps that would sit over your hips, another strap running under you and buckling in the back.
“Allow me.” Sylus said, suddenly appearing next to you in a swirl of red mist as Rafayel trembled on the bed.
Sylus took the device, helping you into it as he nipped and sucked at your inner thighs, before buckling it around you. He swiped two fingers under the strap that ran between your legs, rubbing the throbbing wetness there and teasing you as you moaned before withdrawing them and licking his fingers.
Rafayel keened, watching the two of you as he stroked his cock frantically and shoved two of his own fingers in his hole.
“So needy. One might not be enough.” Sylus said with a dark laugh as he guided you to the bed, tail snatching the vial of oil you kept in your bedside drawer on the way. He dripped the oil on the golden cock and rubbed it down as you watched, feeling yourself clench and throb.
Rafayel moaned as Sylus guided the cock into Rafayel’s slick hole and you let out a moan of your own as you watched the cock slowly disappear into Rafayel.
“Will you make him feel good? Yes, no, maybe so? This is supposed to be a punishment after all.” Sylus whispered in your ear, kissing your neck as he gripped your hips pulling them back and then thrusting them forward, causing you and Rafayel to cry out.
You whimpered as his tail slipped against you again, the hard ridges rolling against your core as you bucked into Rafayel who dragged you into a desperate kiss. Rafayel’s cock was trapped between you as you fell on him, thrusting deeper into him to hear more of his melodic moans, wanting to make him feel better.
Your hips stuttered as Sylus trailed hot kisses down your spine until his hot breath was at your dripping center. Two fingers plunged into you as he lapped at you while you ground into Rafayel, helpless to do anything else. Rafayel shook and sobbed as you wrapped a hand around his cock, rocking back and forth against Sylus’s face and into Rafayel’s greedy hole. He arched his back and came, his eyes a swirl of desperate colors as your thighs trembled and you shook, clenching on Sylus’ tongue. Sylus gave a pleased purr before retreating, pushing your hips forward once more.
“Stay. Our brave Captain can help me give him one more orgasm, can’t you?” Sylus murmured, kissing you as you nodded before he leaned down to kiss Rafayel, settling under him. Rafayel writhed as you held him steady while Sylus slipped his thick, ridged, and veiny cock in alongside your faux phallus. You pressed down on the bulge that appeared on Rafayel’s lower abdomen, Rafayel crying out as more scales appeared on him. Sylus gave you a hungry look over Rafayel’s shoulder before crossing his arms over Rafayel’s chest and bracing his feet on the bed, lifting Rafayel up as you scrambled to your knees, gripping his hips to anchor him. When one of you would pull out, the other would slam in, a brutal quickness growing between the three of you as the cabin creaked and groaned.
You gasped and whimpered as the curved barbed of Sylus’ tail, covered in oil from the smashed bottle on the floor, rubbed against you before slipping into your hole. You clenched around the intrusion stretching you, the dull ache from the straps and his earlier ministrations returning as you thrust deeper into Rafayel and rode Sylus’ tail. You leaned forward as best you could, Sylus’ tail helping to lift you slightly as you kissed Rafayel and then Sylus, grabbing at their nipples as you all became a writhing mess. Rafayel’s moans grew into a frenzied song until he was thrashing between the two of you and coming with a loud yell. You whimpered, burying your face in his chest as you stopped thrusting, hilted in him and rode against Sylus’ tail, the two of them whispering praises until you two were cumming. Sylus roared, his wings flaring out as he spilled into Rafayel, his cum dripping over and out of Rafayel’s hole onto your bedding.
Rafayel shuddered, stroking your back as Sylus kissed him and you struggled to catch your breath, sore but satiated.
“You two owe me new bedding.” You mumbled as Rafayel laughed and kissed your head.
“Just come to our nest, My Dear Bodyguard.” Rafayel said as you gave him a half hearted glare and flicked him.
“That’s Captain to you and I’m not done with you yet. There’s still that punishment.” You said as Sylus chuckled.
“Yo Ho then. Anchors away, Captain.”
A/N: I love interacting with readers in the comments and I promise I don’t bite so please let me if you enjoyed it in the comments/tags!!! Reblogs and likes greatly appreciated
