So i did it. Imma explain myself real quick.
Edward killed Victoria in Eclipse, so obviously his mind reading ability helped him beat her. For Carlisle and Aro, i picked Carlisle because I refuse to think about that bullshit fighting scene in Breaking Dawn part 2 because it was impossible for Alice to see any type of future during the trial. So it’s my opinion that Carlisle is a better fighter than Aro because there is no canon text where Aro has fought, so we don’t even know if he can fight. I like to believe that Rose is stronger than Laurent because Rose has fought the wolves and survived while Laurent was killed by them. Jasper is a fighter so of course he beats James. Alec can beat any of them, hands down, besides Bella because his power can’t touch her. Emmett is physically stronger than Bella and after her newborn strength leaves her he can beat her into a pulp. Of course Jane, like Alec, can beat anyone except for Bella. Alice can see if Jane will be able to use her power on her of course, but what can Alice do to stop that? And Resume, well. . . . do I really need to explain this one?
Edward beats Carlisle for obvious mind reading reasons. Jasper is a better fight than Rose, so sorry but Rose is out. Of course Alec beats Emmett; brute force means nothing if all of his senses are gone. Of course Jane beats Riley.
Edward, once again, wins because while Jasper is a better fighter, Edward can read his mind. I think Jane will be able to beat Alec because Alec’s power works slower than Jane’s.
And of course Jane ends up the winner because Jane got Eddie boys ass on the floor writhing in New Moon, so she can beat him any day.