Have realized that one reason I love Dostoevsky is how often his characters have to Do Things while sick? One of the main antagonists in C&P is Raskolnikov’s inability to think straight or stay upright for long periods of time. I love that. I’ve been reading a lot of T/M/A sickfic (w-well, Jon sickfic, let’s not overgeneralize), but much of what I’ve found leaves me w/ an itch unscratched,* and, I think that’s what it is.
Like don’t get me wrong there’s a stag ger ing amount of fic out there w/ the premise “Jon shows up to work sick,” and I am so glad it exists. But most of it is, like--Jon shows up to work so ill he can’t stay awake at his desk; one of the assistants drives him home or drags him to the cot in the spare room. Or, Jon shows up to work in so much pain that after two or three hours he physically cannot move; one of the assistants &c. Or with a fever so high he’s too delirious even to drink water, and one of the assistants has to take him to A&E for a bag of fucking saline, jesus christ Jon why are you like this. And don’t get me wrong, I can subsist fine on these! They’re my potatoes and molasses
But this is not my favorite kind of “Jon shows up to work sick”-fic. I think it is for many--I have observed that lots of people in this fandom see. Jon’s tendency to push through crap, hide scary things that happen to him even from people whose own safety it might help to know about them, and wave away/refuse other people’s concerned gestures. And respond to that with “I want to see something break him”--usually so Martin (or Tim or Daisy or Georgie or Basira) has to put his pieces back together. I like this! Again, really don’t want to come off as blowing raspberries at it
I just like best fic where he Does Things while sick other than Be Taken Care Of. Where the scenes where he’s trying to work (or socialize or track down a monster or whatever else) serve some function in the story other than proof Jon should not try to do this right now, I guess. You know--where his illness plays a role in the plot like illness does in a Dostoevsky novel! I’ve seen plenty of T/M/A equivalents of the scene in BK where Alyosha interrupts Ivan’s dream about the devil and listens to him rave and watches over him until he falls asleep, but. Give me a T/M/A equivalent of the part where Ivan staggers out into the snow after visiting Smerdyakov, and proves to himself that he’s thinking straight by looking after the peasant he knocked down earlier. Or oh my god, how about an equivalent of the part in C&P where Raskolnikov goes back to the pawnbroker’s apartment to hear the sound of her bell again! Or the part where he forces himself to endure his mother and sister’s visit even though he feels evil before them (and even though he ended up on the floor last time he tried), and Dostoevsky describes his stoical expression as that of a man who’s undergone a painful operation. Or--god, brave new world, dare I even to say?--of the scene in The Idiot where Lizaveta Prokofyevna comes to see Myshkin, expecting to find him at death’s door, and then, once she discovers him fully dressed and upright, thinks he must not be ill at all and keeps her whole family at his house till after midnight.
Just--does it scare you guys, how in T/M/A canon when Jon goes right back to work after an injury he gets away with it? How he never learns his lesson, nothing bad enough ever happens to him to make him stop doing that? Does it feel wrong to you?--give you an itch to fix it, maybe? Is that maybe part of where the urge to break him comes from? Because... yeah, right there with you, but. I am constantly hungry for art that lives with that fear, that stares at it, rather than trying to paper over it with stories about bodily suffering as an aberration that suspends the normal rules. In fanfic I have rather less lofty aspirations, lmao, since, I mean, even I’m not horny for my fear of the uncaring universe (unlike certain Fairchilds). But in real life, pushing yourself till you shatter into pieces and your boyfriend (or friend, or coworker) puts them back together isn’t how you learn to take better care of yourself.
Like? I’m not saying real life is “all h, no c”; it isn’t. Nor am I saying no one’s ever gonna drive you to the hospital if you come into work with a 104-degree fever; of course they will. I’m saying that a lot of the time, in real life you push and push and push and never shatter. You come in with a 101-degree fever, and it’s really fucking boring because you can’t concentrate, but no one notices you’re ill until you tell them, at which point they ask once, maybe twice if you shouldn’t be at home, and then change the subject for fear you’ll think they’re judging you. Whatever milestone you tell yourself you have to hit before you can stop? Either you’ll endure countless unanticipated miseries on the way but never find it, or you’ll pass it and think, “Huh, that’s weird--I don’t even feel that bad. Guess I’ll go another mile.”
And I guess I crave the intellectual company of stories that know that? So, like, fic-wise, give me mundane, unrelieved misery, or give me a Jon who decides not to push this time. Rather than having his body decide that for him.
*N.B. I reblog only exceptions to this rule! Please don’t take what I say here as reflecting badly on anything in this blog’s T/M/A tag