ME AND YOU BOTH ON SILENT SALT
it doesn't sound like much but ever since people started the theory that SS and EF would be the same person I so desperately hoped they were wrong.
I feel like there are so many ways to explore a character like SS and making him a villain that's super-secretly-your-weird-situationship-half-not-thing is boring. Besides, I feel like everyone genuinely forgets how ELDER FAERIE COOKIE IS DEAD??? like he DIED? RIGHT IN FRONT OF US???
Removing all that drama and character story from WL also feels like a disservice, and the connection SS and WL could've made together from shared loss is just disappointing.
I don't even think it's a case of "its so obvious devsis would never do that!!" I just straight up don't like the idea and it would undermine so much of the previous story for a not even cool reveal. Whateverrr have a nice dayy ⚔
There's also this. Doesn't seem like anyone recalls it
Elder Faerie himself is telling us to our face that it's not that deep lol
I'm with you in just not liking the idea and believing it detracts from Silent Salt (and Elder Faerie, but especially Silent Salt). I said pretty much everything I have to say in another ask but I honestly can't stress enough that I just want Silent Salt to be his own man and I don't believe a WL/DE parallel actually services the story. To be honest it comes across as a lot of people not really understanding or appreciating Silent Salt OR Elder Faerie for who they already are and thinking mashing them together will fix something that wasn't even broken (at least not with Salt). I understand wanting Elder Faerie to be more important but why does it have to be like this? Can you really not think of a better way to make a character important besides making him secretly be somebody else? Really don't get why they couldn't have just been former friends/associates, that one cutscene in episode 10 already frames it like that anyway
And really, like. I will say it as many times as I need to: I know that I'm not entitled to Silent Salt being the way I want him to be. I have my own ideas and expectations for him both as an individual and as part of a duality with White Lily (shippy sense and not, I can appreciate a dynamic without taking romance into account ofc) and him having a split soul thing with Elder Faerie would just. Completely ruin everything and I would be Very Big Mad lol. Actual nuclear bomb to that part of my imagination. I know that's ridiculous but it is what it is. It's at least comforting knowing that I wouldn't be alone in my disappointment lol