Asked a friend what it would be like if James Sunderland, Alice (American McGee), Ame-Chan, and Sayaka Miki were all together, in a group. Here's what they said:
"They're probably gonna be the only ones who knows and understands each other and will probably be the only ones they'll have."
"James is pretty much the black sheep of this group, oldest one, pretty much the adult and the only guy here. It would take awhile for the others to trust James, especially people like Ame and Sayaka, because I really don't think they'd like James by the start unless they get to know him better even though he means no harm, Alice would probably just be indifferent about James."
"Though I don't think they should know about the fact that James killed his wife with a pillow."
"Considering what Sayaka went through, everyone is probably gonna do their best to take care of her, Alice would be the best kind of sister here, she cares about kids a-lot, so she would get along with Sayaka the best." At least with James and Ame they would try their best."
"James and Ame are pretty much the only normal humans in terms of mortality and prowess, they don't have to kind of capabilities Sayaka and Alice have (assuming Alice has her Wonderland abilities)."
"James fought monsters with a wooden board, steel pipe, and guns, Ame hasn't really fought anyone though she would definitely stab someone to death with a knife or box cutter, those two can get pretty aggressive."
"What I am amused by however is the amount of medical supplies James and Ame can potentially eat through, especially Ame."
"It would seem downward-spiraling and "toxic" on the outside, I'm pretty sure they're in fact pulling each other up and making sure the others get home safely. In a more grim and dark setting, they could be four wrecks who somehow fix each other."
this is the kind of Suicide Squad I need to see, now