Requested by Mithveaen - A storm broke one of the library’s windows, and while Finch and Reese clean up, Finch tells Reese about his favorite book.
I apologize for not quite sticking to the prompt here, Mithveaen--I had a truly difficult time attempting to chose an adequate book which Finch would reasonably call his favorite, and, well, by the time I had this was already half written. I hope you enjoy it, anyway!
It was very late at night to be in the library—although, to be fair, Reese would likely still have been awake despite the hour, prowling the apartment floor or cleaning his arsenal, had he not received Finch’s distressed call just half an hour before. The thunderstorm that had struck the city with an inexplicable force in the late afternoon had not dissipated, it seemed, before shattering a set of glass panels in the farther ‘J’ section of the library, and wreaking havoc on the nearest six shelves. First and second editions were strewn haphazardly across the floor, pages rumpled and covers damp from the rain.
They’d cleaned up the worst of it, and Finch’s mood had evened out considerably—he had been as livid as Reese had ever seen him upon his arrival, scowling and going so far as to shout at the makeshift window guard whenever it billowed hazardously inwards.
Reese didn’t have to say that he would have the frames reinforced when he installed them the next day. It was an unspoken understanding they seemed to have developed; Reese anticipated Finch’s desires, like a well-trained watchdog, and responded accordingly. He stored away the tiny, approving smiles and appreciative nods he received from the other man for times when he was alone, and felt like wallowing in something other than self-pity and distain.
Reese bent down and picked up a sore looking number titled The Trial, its cover leaking woeful tears onto the wooden library floor. It was one of the more tragic looking ones; most seemed to have escaped the brunt of the water.
“Kafka isn’t looking too good, Finch,” Reese said as he handed the pathetic thing to Finch. Finch took the waterlogged book carefully, placing it open-faced on the desk.
“I suppose even in his literature he is prone to unfortunate bad luck,” Finch sighed, his fingers hovering just above the exposed pages before he pulled away and continued his business of replacing the salvaged books onto their appropriate shelves.
Reese smiled softly, and let out a light chuckle. Finch continued his work, not turning to look back at him.
“I can’t help but find his writing fascinating, if not incredibly morbid,” Finch continued. “Although I wouldn’t consider myself one for cheerful literature, Kafka’s examination of life as a whole is thoroughly troubling. Have you read any of his work?”
“Metamorphosis, in high school,” Reese said.
“Hmm, a perfect example of Kafka’s self-deprecating mindset,” Finch said, as if in agreement. “A fascinating short story, true.”
“What’s your favorite book, Harold?” Reese asked, suddenly. Finch did look up then, turning to face Reese with a faintly surprised look. Reese was surprised, too; he didn’t generally ask direct questions, when talking to Finch. It was a learned habit, when working with paranoid people like his partner for so long. Direct questions almost never produced valuable answers, especially when they were just pulled out of the blue.
Finch was silent a moment, his stare calculating as he eyed Reese, perhaps looking for an angle. Eventually he dropped his gaze, considering.
“That’s a bit difficult a question, Mr. Reese. Of course Kafka is a talented writer but I hardly would consider him one of my favorites. I suppose Jane Austen has some merits; her impressions of life and love in the eighteenth century are quite captivating. Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451 is rather exceptional. I read Kate Chopin’s The Awakening the other day; it was quite thought provoking.”
He looked at Reese again, for a long, thoughtful moment.
It was those moments, those considering moments when Finch’s eyes would move about him, intent and invasive, penetrating his flesh, staring into his soul. His stomach twisted, a familiar feeling. Finch had that sort of effect on him, he’d noticed. Likely, Finch had noticed at some time or another, too, but he never mentioned it. A small kindness, Reese assumed.
“I suppose A Tale of Two Cities must be the one. Have you read it?”
Reese shook his head, wishing very much that he had, if only to impress Finch.
Finch smiled faintly at him. “I’ll have to lend it to you. It’s really quite a wonderful read. Although I fear you may associate yourself too closely with Sydney Carton—I assure you, the only commonalities the two of you have are your dedications to the people you love.”
“Yes,” Reese said, and Finch paused. The air seemed to still about them, and Reese took in a breath, wondering if it would be wildly inappropriate to ask Finch if he would read the book to him. Finch had a wonderfully relaxing voice, a safety harness keeping Reese from slipping over the edge, a trusted gleam of light in the otherwise dark abyss Reese called home.
He’d already taken a risk asking a question of Finch in the first place, however, and his bravery was spent.
“John,” Finch said, and Reese felt a chill spread across his skin at the sound. He waited.
It took a moment for Finch to continue. He seemed almost surprised that he had spoken at all.
“Yes, Harold?” Reese asked, softly.
“I’ll bring the book to the library as soon as possible, Mr. Reese.”
It wasn’t often that Finch anticipated Reese’s desires, but when it happened, he was always ludicrously on point. “… If you’d like, I could read the book to you, during stakeouts. If memory serves, they can be incredibly tedious in silence, and I know you’re not usually a fan of long afternoons reading on the couch.”
If that couch had Finch, sitting alongside him with a book in his hands, then Reese absolutely wouldn’t mind at all. But even over the comm, while watching a number, Reese could imagine Finch’s steady voice reading aloud his favorite novel, and his heart thudded pointedly in his chest. “Yeah, Finch, that sounds great.”
Finch smiled at him again. “I find the idea rather appealing myself.”