What are the best toad designs in your opinion? I like evolution
This is a very fun question! It seems like every other artist has a new design for him, so there are a lot to choose from. X-Men: Evolution Toad will always have a place in my heart, but I don't think it's my all-time favorite. Steven E. Gordon is such a strong artist, and I think Todd is one of the best designs in the show. Unlike other characters supposedly in the same age range, he looks like a young teen. Some of them look like full-on adults, but this thing?
That's a fourteen-year-old. Look at how awkward he is, with his big ol' eyes and gangly limbs. I just want to feed him and help him with his homework. Adorable.
Wolverine and The X-Men (the cartoon) is also among my favorites! Craig Kyle is a great artist; all his characters have great shape language. Mort immediately won me over. And he is very obviously inspired by another version of Toad I like, the one from the Ultimate X-Men, specifically Adam Kubert's design.
The green skin, the sharp nails, the pointy teeth! Instantly identifiable, and so cool! But my favorite feature is the dark, textured hair. I'm just a sucker for curls. Dreadlocks are always neat.
I'm also fond of the art in the 2011 Wolverine & The X-Men comics. This Toad has the bulky frame of the original design, the scarred green skin of some newer ones, and the saddest bowl cut I've ever seen. He's so pathetic. It's amazing. Look at his little bow tie!
My favorite fan design goes to, of course, @croxovergoddess ! Go look at her Brooklyn Heroes art! She's been keeping the fandom fed for years.
Special mention to The Trial of Magneto issue #4
Literally sopping wet. So good.
I don't think one is better than the others, because they're all nice in different ways. All Toads are good Toads. I've played around with my own design, but I'm not set on it yet. He for sure needs the green skin, the huge eyes, and the too-wide mouth. I'm pretty attached to the wider frame, but I also like the oddly long limbs. He will have curly hair, but that's just for me 💚
Everyone should draw more fan art of him, of any version. Right now. Do it.













