1. Nobody is saying *all* trans men are being marked red, just the ones who are vocal about the oppression they face. Also ignoring that a large amount of the people marked red are nonbinary and intersex. Trans men are just an easy target for posters like this because “guhhh MEN think they’re oppressed 🤣🤣🤣” is easier to argue than acknowledging the non-men who are also targeted.
2. Given that the people I interact with are fellow intersectional/inclusive transfeminists, transmasculine and intersex theorists and activists, being marked red = not being openly transandrophobic, exorsexist and intersexist, and in support of people in those groups.
3. Again, see point 1 and 2 for who is being erased here. Also the erasure of “trans” from the equation, where many “women” have historically been trans men who did not or could not come out. Feminism directly benefits all groups of people including transmasculine people, who like transfeminine people have always been tied closely to feminism. Additionally, the myth that shinigami eyes was always meant to primarily serve the interests of binary trans women has been debunked multiple times, even if that is functionally how it is used. Though this is partially the fault of SE’s creator for being disingenuous and misleading with what the extension actually is, because as many will point out on all sides it is not actually “for all trans people” unless you are arguing that only binary trans women are trans (which, well. Gestures.)
4. This seems completely irrelevant to anything else in this post other than more false equivocation between cis and trans men. “Of course trans men are going to be marked red, men are misogynists so trans men are transmisogynists!” is a logical fallacy that fails for all the aforementioned points + that cis men aren’t inherently misogynistic, so trans men are not either. Trans men do not benefit from misogyny or transmisogyny and are often its victims, even though some may perpetuate it (just like cis and trans women may.)
TL;DR, this “logic test” fails all basic intersectional analysis and is inconsistent with the lived reality of the people shinigami eyes is used to target. The focus on specifically trans men is the motte in this scenario conspicuously ignoring nonbinary and intersex victims. The idea that the only people whose viewpoints matter in the trans community is binary trans women bleeds out of this post with every word.