I'm always looking for new and interesting drum products, and while I applaud this latest introduction into the drum market from new percussion manufacturer Whole Foods, I'm afraid that I cannot wholeheartedly recommend the Watermelon Drum Kit. I've spent significant time playing these drums and quite frankly, I can say with confidence that they have a decent sound at best. Here is my evaluation of the entire drum kit, piece by piece.
Muddy kick drum
There is no argument that this kick drum is beautiful and delicious. However, rather than the deep boom combined with a nice punchy attack that I am accustomed to hearing with my other kick drums, this drum produces a somewhat muddy and watermelon-like sound at best. If you are looking for a kick drum that sounds as though it's made of some kind of summery, water-based fruit, this is the kick drum for you.
Fruit-like overtone in the snare
I'll admit that I'm a bit finicky when it comes to my snare and rather fanatic about achieving a great snare sound, so please take this comment with a grain of salt: This snare has a bit of a thick, fruit-like overtone. One of the problems could be in the overall snare design: It appears to be made from a slice of watermelon. Also worth noting, there is no throw-off switch and the underside of the snare has no snare wires, which seems a bit unconventional.
Toms not structurally sound
The toms are a beautiful watermelon color and have lovely green rhine-colored rims. But while the toothpick tension rods are admittedly adorable, unfortunately they snapped and collapsed after playing Van Halen's "Hot for Teacher" just three times. Just three times! Any attempt at tuning the toms proved somewhat fruitless ... no pun intended (OK, actually, the pun indeed wasintended). I ultimately broke down and ate the floor tom, but not before adding just a touch of salt, because that's how my Grandma taught me watermelon was meant to be eaten, dammit.
The cymbals: Sound like hitting a hunk of watermelon
Ask anyone who knows me and they will tell you that I am the first person to appreciate lopping the top off a watermelon and piercing it with a wooden dowel for the purpose of using it as a nice dark-dry ride cymbal, or perhaps a bright and personable splash cymbal. However, I cannot in good faith recommend these particular cymbals. While they produce an interesting, melon-like thumping sound that is both resonant and pleasing (especially for jazz and country), they can't compete with even the mid-level series of cymbals from Zildjian, Paiste and Sabian. Worth noting: I will say that when you hit these melon-cymbals with a drumstick, it produces a sound reminiscent of the sound of a drumstick striking against the skin of a hunk of watermelon, although I suppose this probably is to be expected.
Summary
You can't say that the watermelon drums are not beautiful and colorful, and nobody is arguing that surrounding the drum kit with a cornucopia of berries and grapes doesn't provide a refreshing and tasty snack. While I applaud this entry into the world of percussion products by Whole Foods, the mushy, melon-like sound of this drum kit cannot compete with even some of the student-level drum kits that are available today. If you are looking for an interesting and low-cost set of drums, you probably are better off going with one of the flat and portable drum kits such as the Traps A400 kit. Or, consider making your own drum kit out of a variety of gourds and seasonal tubers.











