Hi! So I saw this idea from another's blog's ask (credits to the OG idea to Hyper anon) and decided to present the idea to you as well! ^^
Basically, the cookies can see through the reader's camera and think the characters they're cosplaying as are different entities. While they think the reader on their own is "The Caretaker", they will also think the characters the reader is cosplaying as to be different gods that the reader has contact with.
So, my request is; What do you think it would be the cookies reactions (cookies of your choosing ofc) when they see The Baker!Cosplayer!Reader accidentally appearing into the crk world and have the reader appear as one of the characters they were cosplaying as? (For example; you have "The knight", the cookies believe this is a god of war and they pray to this "god" to have strength and power for the battle)
Oh yeah i think i remember seeing the request ur talking about.
The cookies see these characters and believes them to be gods. And there are probably multiple of them the cookies see. The Knight is one, and cookies preparing for battle pray to this god. I can imagine the Dark Cacao kingdom having a small shrine dedicated to them, and they frequently pray for both strength to make it through tough weather conditions and battle.
Of course, there are also costumes they see as more evil. Maybe one day the reader decided to dress as a malicious and intimidating looking villain. Of course, most of the cookies get frightened when they see this and believe it to be a bad omen. Though, The cookies of Darkness and the cookies who are villains in the narrative find delight in seeing this god. After all, this god would most likely represent evil and violence.
There are multiple gods that the cookies believe see from the screen, from wizards, to villains, to heroes. (I feel like cookies would freak if they saw you were dressed as a witch)
Yet, the one dubbed as "The Caregiver" is likely most of the cookie's favorite. This god represents neutrality, and they care for all cookies no matter how good or evil. They emanate a sort of warmth to all cookies, and some say those who witness them are blessed with good luck.
So, for the cookies' reactions, it depends who your cosplaying as. If your dressed as "The Knight" or any other god that represents good, they'll worship you, giving you gifts and kneeling at your feet. They beg of you to wish them luck and fortune.
If you're dressed as a villain, things go south fast. Cookies avoid your line of sight, panicking and hiding away. However, if you manage to meet any of the narrative's "evil" cookies, they'll be overjoyed. Hell, Pomegranate cookie begins to treat you like she does to Dark Enchantress cookie. These cookies worship you, endlessly praise you, and obey your every command.
However, it's a shock for both sides to find that, there isn't multiple gods. It's just you, The Caregiver, dressing up as them for fun. I think their reactions would be more positive and they would admire you even more. The gods they believed were real was just one god all along, and they think you hold all the strength, wisdom, and kindness that the other gods represented. The worship would get worse, honestly. Unless you manage to convince them that you aren't a god, just a mortal having fun cosplaying, the cookies cater to your every needs. They need to make sure their ultimate god is safe and comfortable after all. Let them show you what they have to offer you for your kindness and care towards them!

















