We know that Lance is loud and loves to talk. So, imagine when Shklance have sex for the first time Lance is really silent. At first Shiro and Keith think that Lance is just shy and holds his sweet noises back but even with encouragements the same happens again and again. Until they notice that Lance does makes these cute if silent mewl-like sounds when he's really into it and they want to hear more of it.
I’m reminded of an ask a while back where someone offered the idea of Lance’s first time having sex being in an orgy/threesome but unwilling to admit it until much later. That might work well with this. (Not exactly what you asked for but…)
They never expected him to be so quiet. After all, if Lance is known for anything it’s his loudness around the ship but tonight he’s quiet. So quiet that if it weren’t for the heady flush on his face, Keith and Shiro would have no idea he was enjoying their ministrations. They started out with kisses and some light frottage. A little grinding and groping to get those engines going.
When they asked Lance if he wanted to go further, if he wanted to get fucked, he’d flushed but nodded his head. He’d sat in Shiro’s lap and held tight to his shoulders as Keith fingered him open, breathing shallowly against Shiro’s collarbones. They never expected Lance to be so shy about this, not with how he talks a mean game about how often he’s been with people. They chalk it up to him being submissive in the bedroom and just continue.
When Keith pushes inside him, Lance exhales a tight breath into Shiro’s neck. Luckily, Keith did a great job working him open because it only stings a little, his eyes watering just a bit before Keith really gets started. Shiro expresses a little worry at that reaction but Lance assures him he’s fine. It’s just…been awhile, haha. Once they really get going he’ll be used to it, promise.
Throughout Lance bites his bottom lip and exhales weak noises as Keith rocks into him. Keith whispers little things in his ear about how good he feels. That he loves the way his ass just swallows up his cock. That he can’t wait to rough Lance up. Shiro chimes in with little things of his own. Telling Keith to fuck that pretty slut. He’s clearly asking for it and here, he’ll hold him in place for him.
Lance has never felt so turned on despite his inexperience.
“D-Do it,” Lance swallows, eager to please. “Do whatever you…want to me. I’m yours…”
Shiro holds his ass cheeks nice and spread while Keith plows him. It’s harder than he was doing but Lance still manages to bite back his moans and whimpers, caught between pleasure and pain when Keith spanks his ass hard. Shiro sucks hickies into his neck and biting a little to leave marks while Keith fucks into him.
Lance comes with a ragged moan but tells them to keep going. That he wants to satisfy them too. Keith hooks another two fingers into Lance’s ass alongside his cock, pulling and stretching to make room for another cock.
“Bet you’d like to take two at once, wouldn’t you, pretty slut?” Keith asks with a grin.
Yes, it’s dirty talk but it’s also way of seeing how far Lance is willing to go without changing the mood. Problem is, Lance doesn’t answer. Even when he repeats himself. Keith makes a face at Shiro hinting that he should check in.
“Lance?” Shiro inquires, trying to get his attention
Lance is pressing his face to Shiro’s chest and breathing hard. His whole body is tense. Shiro lifts his face to find Lance still flushed but his face wet with tears. Shiro gestures a signal to stop for a moment and Keith pulls out to crawl up the bed to see what the hold up is.
“Lance? What’s wrong?”
“S-Sorry…I…I’m f-f-fine,” he stammers. “I can…I can take you b-both. I just…I need to breathe a minute…”
“Lance…have you…ever done two at once?” Shiro asks and Lance shakes his head. “It’s alright…you don’t have to do it at all, okay?” he says.
“And we can take a break,” Keith assures him. “Since you said it’d been a while, you’re probably overwhelmed. When’s the last time you bottomed?”
Lance flushes red but this time out of shame. He shimmies off of Shiro’s lap, turns away, and covers his face with both hands before letting out a hiccup.
“N…Never,” Lance admits, trying to stifle his sob.
Both men gape and sit up alert before crawling across the bed to put a hand on Lance’s shuddering body.
“What?”
“You’ve never…? But you’ve…had sex before right?” Keith asks and Lance shakes his head.
“N-No…I thought…you wouldn’t want to with me…if I…if I said I hadn’t,” Lance admits through whimpering sobs. “And if I…if I made too much noise…you’d know it…it kinda hurt a little…and you’d stop. A-And I didn’t w-want that…”
“Lance, I wish you’d said something,” Shiro tells him. “We thought you had experience—if we’d known, we’d have eased into this a little better. Been gentler.”
“Yeah,” Keith nods and scratches the back of his head in shame. “I wouldn’t have…you know, said all that mean stuff. Or fucked you so hard. Or hit you. Not if it was your first time.”
“We’d have done this a lot differently, Lance,” Shiro tells him, patting his hair and massaging his neck in an attempt to pacify him. “This is supposed to be enjoyable for everyone…you included. We don’t want to hurt you…”
“I’m s-sorry I lied,” Lance sniffs and wipes his face. He’s finally feeling a little more calm. “I…I really like you guys so I…didn’t want to miss my chance with you. And now I…messed up the whole night.”
“I wouldn’t say that,” Shiro tells him with a fond look. “Let’s take a break…and see how you feel in twenty minutes okay?”
And that’s what they do. They take a short break that consists of some soft making out and groping again, only this time with no clothes on. Simple handjobs and kisses on hot skin so that all parties are sighing contentedly. Lance isn’t up to going again, not yet, but he is up to watching Shiro and Keith go at it.
Keith shows Lance some good techniques for riding cock making Shiro come right inside him. And Shiro demonstrates a very nice blowjob on Keith that he invites Lance to join in. He gives it a try, taking turns on sucking Keith’s cock with Shiro right beside him. It’s enough to get him to relax and Shiro shifts his attention from Keith’s dripping cock to Lance’s tender ass. His licks and laves his hot thick tongue over his hole and this time Lance isn’t quiet.
It feels good and he moans with abandon while his mouth is full of Keith’s cock. Keith’s fingers comb through his hair and tug gently into bobbing. Shiro doesn’t fuck Lance but he slides his cock between his ass cheeks, teasing that sensitive hole with his shaft until Lance comes a second time that night–this one being far more pleasurable.
Such a good ecstatic moan coming out of Lance does it for his partners. Keith comes on his pretty mewling face while Shiro comes on his ass/lower back but both clean him up with their mouths afterward, making Lance feel like the most delicious and pampered first-time slut in existence. And he’s looking forward to doing it more after that night.
