like, leaving the rest of the movie aside (which i think more people agree on that it’s pretty much amazing), as a creator i just THRIVE with the openness of it all and the messy, complicated potential consequences of time travels.
I was literally just talking about all this with a friend, how it’s such an amazing sandbox to play in! it’s how fandom keeps creating! it’s an ending that’s not an ending!
Did steve simply grow old with peggy as its implied and let certain things happen cause he really cannot change the way things happened in the past and just walk to that bench when he’s old?
Did his going back automatically create a new reality and did he make tons of changes that we can’t really see because they don’t affect our characters’ reality and then he just used the particles to come back to this reality?
Did he just take one dance with peggy and then rescued that timeline’s steve from the ice, told him about bucky, told him what’s gonna happen, then that steve lives the life our steve always wanted, bonds with tony, helps with NYC, finds sam and bucky when he’s old, gives sam his shield….. and then our steve shows 5 min later, young and with starbucks?
Did he even really marry peggy since he wouldn’t talk about “her” at all? 👀👀
this is how fans keep exploring possibilities and producing content! with open ends and loose threads! i get how the not knowing part is what’s making lots of people sad potatoes, but there’s also a good side to that openness, ya feel?
they knew they had to bench steve somehow because of chris evans’ contract but they chose to gave him closure that wasn’t really closure. they had him choosing this for himself only when he knew bucky was going to be safe. they brought him back to bucky. they left the door open for him to be in the bucky & sam show. they gave us a way to make him young again in this very same movie (like bruce did with scott)!!!!!
to me it didn’t feel at all like them taking the life steve had built for himself away from him, but giving him the possiblity to live BOTH the one he lost and NOW GO BACK TO THIS ONE. they let him have everything!
so yeah as both a writer and a steve stan who was downright terrified of this movie, i’m really fucking happy