I always, always take recipes which tout themselves as the ‘best’ of anything with a grain of salt, so while I was enthusiastic about trying this one, I still kept my expectations in check. However, I can say with full confidence that these are indeed by far the best vegan chocolate chip cookies I’ve ever made. Honestly, no way would you ever guess that they were vegan. They have the exact texture I love in a cookie, very much like Nestle Tollhouse. I would usually save such praise for the end of a review, but I will go ahead and declare here that this will be the only ever basic chocolate cookie recipe I use from here on out.
Remus and I (well, mostly me) made about 3/4 of this recipe using a mix of snapped dark chocolate buttons and M&S chunks. I honestly was most motivated to make this recipe since it called for both coconut milk and applesauce, both of which I have been trying to use up, but somehow that created the perfect combo for deliciously gooey cookies.
We ended up with about 15 cookies and perhaps did not give all of them enough room for spreading. Ever concerned about our over-hot oven, I pulled the first batch at 8 minutes, thought the ends were too crispy, and so went for 7 on the second. I think, however, just because they were so crowded, 8 was actually probably the right call. Yes, the edges were a bit crispy, but with 7, the middles perhaps were not baked thoroughly enough.
But you know what, they’re vegan, so who cares if they’re not fully baked! Then you just miss out on all that extra gooeyness. And gooey goodness is exactly what this recipe promises. I know this is now going to be a forever favorite.












