So, personally I feel like the ut/dr fandom is just so conditioned to mystery man being gaster, but what if he’s NOT gaster??? It hasn’t been directly confirmed BY TOBY yet, soooooo what if?? BUT mystery man is most likely gaster because of the evidence, but like seriously WHAT IF? ALSO mystery man/gaster shares similarities with the knight (Im not finding pictures bear with me) theyre both black and white, also LOOK AT THE HANDS. The knight has the same print as mystery man/gaster on their hands. But I have 3 theories on this. 1: gaster and mystery man are the same person and is the knight. 2: they are completely unrelated and MYSTERY MAN is the knight with gaster being a completely separate character. And 3: they are unrelated with gaster being the knight while mystery man is just mystery man. Also, “darker yet darker”… guys who does that link to?? GASTER. and who is the main person making the fountains? THE ROARING FUCKING KNIGHT. please it’s gaster i sweeaaarrr. I feel like dess being the knight doesn’t just make sense to me personally because she WENT MISSING. I personally believe that dess is literally just straight up dead?? I feel like Toby wouldn’t make it THAT obvious either. And you could make the same argue as gerson, because he was in the dark world because of his ashes and a hammer, but thats debunked with dess because we see the knight IN THE LIGHT WORLD. I feel like this also debunks almost EVERY lightner knight theory because if the knight was a lighter wouldn’t their form change back in the light world??? Idkkk I feel like that would make sense. Which means the knight would have to be someone who defies that logic… maybe a guy whose name starts with a W. D. and ends in Gaster…. 👀👀 ok thanks for listening to my shit theory 🤞