“I don’t want to call you stupid, but…” “Just say it.” “I’m gonna need you to never leave your room again” Jeremy Heere/Michael Mell
Send me a request!
Title: So In Hindsight Maybe I Really Don’t Know Anything About Cartoon Voice Actors?Fandom: Be More Chill :: Boyf riendsRequested by: @ilossayaPrompt: “I don’t want to call you stupid, but…” “Just say it.” “I’m gonna need you to never leave your room again” from putthepromptsonpaper
“Michael,” Jeremy starts, eyeing his friend, “how high are you?”
“Uh,” Michael pauses, “I dunno. 5’11”, last I checked.”
Jeremy just sighs and picks up his controller again. “I can’t believe we’re still stuck on the cafetorium.”
“M’sorry about Christine,” Michael mumbles, fingers twisting over his controller.
Jeremy watches his character, Player 2, flicker and fall to the zombies.
“It’s okay.”
–
Life more or less returns to normal. Jeremy and Christine stay friends. Sometimes, watching her during play rehearsals, he thinks that maybe he can see why he liked her so much. Other times, he watches her as she interacts with Jake and Brooke and Chloe and Rich and anybody else and he knows they’re better off this way.
In their relationship, they’d both been a match - blazed too strongly and burned out. The breakup had been mutual; soft, apologetic smiles and understanding eyes. He’s grateful to still be her friend. Christine is bright, like a beacon, and her unrelenting happiness is a nice change from his self-deprecating days.
But always, Michael is there.
Without fail, his best friend is there when he needs him. Jeremy knows they both have plenty of issues - like a massive amount of issues - but Michael is his pillar of strength, even when they’re both reduced to playing video games in silence or just tucked up under a blanket. Jeremy doesn’t ever tell Michael how much he appreciates him - and he knows he should, but he’s just never seen the chance. Michael, on the other hand, always seems to find the right time to inform Jeremy how much he appreciates his friendship.
He’s gotten better about it, but Jeremy still isn’t sure how people are so open.
–
“Slushie?” Michael offers. “I think the girl at 7-Eleven was flirting with me. I got a second slushie for free.”
Jeremy takes it. It’s his favorite flavor, sure enough.
“I think any girl would be lucky to have someone like you, Michael,” he says.
Michael pulls his headphones up. “You think?” He asks, but doesn’t meet Jeremy’s eyes.
“Definitely,” Jeremy says, but he knows Michael isn’t listening anymore.
–
“Michael is in the crowd,” Christine tells him, when she ducks backstage, “on the third row, middle section. Sixth seat, I think. I didn’t have a chance to really count.”
“He came to see the play again?”
Jeremy doesn’t know why he’s surprised anymore. Michael has come to every performance since the squip incident. He’s normally somewhere in the front, sipping contently on a Mountain Dew Red.
(“Just in case,” Michael tells him, one of such days, when he comes to congratulate Jeremy again.)
Christine gapes at him. “You’re… you’re joking, right? Jeremy, Michael is-”
“Let him figure it out himself, if he’s that dense about it,” Rich interrupts, slinking by in his boy scout costume to get back on for his scene with Chip and Barfée.
Christine sets her dictionary prop down and sighs. “You’re a Coneybear, alright.”
(After the musical, he finds Michael in the crowd. His friend beams and pushes through the people to meet him.
“I can’t believe you played a hippie child,” he laughs, “that didn’t know what a capybara was.”
“Thanks for coming,” Jeremy replies.
“Anything for you, dude.”)
–
“Fellas,” Michael starts, staring Jeremy down from where his friend stands across the cafeteria, talking to Christine, “is it gay to fantasize about being in a loving relationship with your best friend of sixteen years?”
“Of cou-” Chloe starts, but Brooke and Rich both slaps their hands over Chloe’s mouth with an audible clap.
She yelps behind four palms.
“Nope,” Brooke says, “not at all.”
–
“He really cares about you, Jeremy.”
Jeremy looks up at his dad’s voice and follows his gaze to where Michael is out cold on their couch, arm slung over his face and one leg hooked over the back. Jeremy is sitting nearby, playing a boring game on his phone. Michael had shown up sometime this morning, let himself in, and passed out on the couch. He has yet to wake, and Jeremy isn’t going to bother him.
“I mean, he’s been my best friend for what? Sixteen or seventeen years?” Jeremy lifts an eyebrow. “I’d hope he cares about me. I know I care about him.”
“No, I mean-”
“Aw, you care about me?” Michael’s cooing voice interrupts, and Jeremy jumps, whirling to gape at the boy.
“Have you been awake this whole time?”
Michael grins from beneath his arm. “I might have been.”
Jeremy reaches over and smacks him in the gut so hard that Michael falls off of the couch and just laughs.
–
Christine is staring at him incredulously.
Jeremy can’t figure out why. So what if he just figured out that his feelings for Michael are certainly more than friendly?
“Jeremy Heere,” Christine drags out his name, “Michael is very gay for you.”
“Oh,” says Jeremy, and he promptly gets up and marches out.
–
“Hey, Michael?” Jeremy asks, from his spot on the swings.
It’s been years since they last visited this park - Michael had been driving Jeremy back home when the latter had spotted it and convinced Michael to pull over. In the next swing over, Michael tugs his hood up - that same orange jacket he’s had for years, with the addition of new patches occasionally - and looks over.
“Yeah?”
“You know you’re my favorite person, right?”
For a moment, he thinks Michael might make a coy comment, like the first time he’d said the same during their junior year, but Michael merely blinks at him, dark eyes glittering in the streetlights.
He asks, “Including Christine?”
Jeremy laughs. “Including Christine.”
They spend the next hour swinging and talking of whatever comes to mind. Michael’s hood flies off and he laughs when Jeremy challenges him to see who can jump further. Nonetheless, he takes the dare. They end up jumping the same distance, and neither lands on his feet. Jeremy laughs, winded, and rolls over to use Michael’s outstretched arm as a pillow. It was preferable to the wood chips.
“Hey, Jer?”
“Yeah?”
“Remember that time I brought you a slushie and you told me any girl would be lucky to have me?”
“What about it?”
Michael turns his head to look at Jeremy. “I’m, uh.”
Jeremy pats his friend’s arm. “Gay. I know.”
“You- You know?” Michael looks confused, until he meets Jeremy’s gaze and sighs. “Christine. Of course. That girl can’t keep a secret to save her life.”
“S’okay,” Jeremy murmurs, catching his breath.
“Yeah?”
“Yeah.”
Jeremy doesn’t move off of Michael’s arm. Michael doesn’t ask him to. His glasses came off, and Jeremy figures it happened when they hit the ground. There are wood chips in his dark hair and Jeremy reaches out one arm to pick a couple out.
“Hey, Michael?” He says again, but Michael’s attention is already on him, watching Jeremy with some unreadable expression.
“Yeah?” Michael asks.
“You know I love you, right?”
Michael hesitates. “As a friend?”
“No,” says Jeremy, “more.”
“Oh,” Michael replies.
“Yeah,” Jeremy closes his eyes, “oh.”
–
“Wait,” Jake looks vaguely annoyed, glancing between Michael and Jeremy, “what do you mean you just started dating?”
“Jeremy’s oblivious,” Christine replies, waving a dismissive hand.
“Omigod,” Jenna pokes her head between Chloe and Brooke’s shoulders, “you guys actually ended up getting together? Pay up, Chloe.”
Chloe glowers at the two, before she turns and puts ten dollars in Jenna and Brooke’s waiting hands. Jenna immediately pockets hers and goes back to texting, considerably more eager about it.
“That’s gay,” Rich comments, picking at his nails.
“You’re gay,” Brooke retorts.
“This is bi erasure,” Rich gasps dramatically, slamming his hands on the table so hard that the group halfway down jumps.
“Rich,” Christine asks, “remind me why you aren’t in theatre?”
Jeremy looks at Michael - really looks at him. He’s practically glowing, looking on in amusement at the group. His fingers, interlaced with Jeremy’s, tighten.
–
“God is real,” Michael breathes, staring at level clear screen.
“It only took a year to beat,” Jeremy laughs, “but we finally cleared it. I can’t breathe.”
Michael jumps up from his bean bag. “Jeremy, we did it!”
Jeremy tumbles backwards as Michael half flings himself into his arms. They’re both laughing, something between relief and joy and these - these are the moments Jeremy lives for.
–
“Oh,” Michael says.
Jeremy looks over from his spot on the couch. “What?”
Michael is sitting on the floor in front of the television, legs crossed and shuffling through Jeremy’s multitude of movies.
“I didn’t know Ellen voiced Dory,” Michael says.
Jeremy stares at him for a long time.
“Michael,” he finally starts, “You know- what, every anime voice actor ever? And I don’t want to call you stupid, but…”
Michael resigns himself to his inevitable fate. “Just say it.”
“I’m gonna need you to never leave your room again.”
















