- You do NOT need to be related to be an organ donor.
- Carly and Nelle were NEVER biologically related. They were adopted by the same man: Frank Benson. This does make them legally sisters. Which yes, means that legally... Nelle slept with her nephew (I do use the term "legal" loosely here as both were black market adoptions).
- Frank Benson adopted Carly as a newborn with his wife Virginia in Florida. He left both of them when Carly was 3-years-old and she never saw him again until Nelle was 4-years-old (shown in flashbacks).
- Frank had been writing to Carly for years begging for money, Jax knew this and contacted him to use his connections to get a kidney for Josslyn.
- The picture of little Nelle is indeed Nelle. This is the same exact child actress from the flashbacks of young Nelle in the April 2020 special Nelle history episode. Which apparently most of you missed since it was the original reveal for the necklace.
- Nelle has had the necklace since she was at least 4-years-old (shown in the April 2020 flashback episode).
- Nelle had the necklace since she arrived in Port Charles (shown as early as March 2017, over a full year before Willow came on the show).
- Willow has never had a heart-shaped necklace on the show. She has worn a crescent moon with a star necklace that does look similar from a distance.
- Willow's only reaction to Nina's necklace was that she thought it was nice that her daughter was given something from her, as Harmony never passed things down to her.
- The writers have confirmed several times that Nelle was written to be Nina's daughter from the start. Nelle was written very similar to Nina, Britt, Madeline, and Liesl for this reason.
For anyone who may take offense to this (I'm an enneagram 9w1, I fear upsetting people), I am not saying you can't have theories about it not being Nelle, or of it being Willow, or whatever. It's a soap, everyone should have fun with it and think of twists.
BUT, your theories should support the facts as we know them right now. The above is what the writers have shown and told us at this point.
Don't make-up things that never happened, say they are true and confuse others who believe you. Don't take the word of gossip/”spoiler sites”. If you have a theory, make sure you clarify that's all it is. Some people are new, some don't watch every day, they will take your word for it and be confused.