Destiel AU, vol.2 - Two People Love Triangle and Other Configurations
Destiel AU, vol. 2 - Two People Love Triangle and Other Configurations. One of my all time favorite fanfic tropes is Two People Love Triangle - a classic set up where Dean and Cas get to know each other through some kind of anonymous communication and also meet in real life. It takes time to put both personas together while falling in love and lust with both. But which one they will chose? This trope has a wonderful character tension and potential for delicious reveals that I adore.
Our Destiel AU rec lists are intended for first time recs (see here), but since this trope is hard to come by, I’m taking an opportunity to rec couple of new fics alongside older fics that are scattered through the blog, on our Anonymity/ Internet tag and some other tags.
First time on the blog or previously unofficially recced but untagged fics are posted with summaries and assigned proper tags on this post, similarly to Destiel AU vol 1 post. Rest of the links go to our tagged reviews and submitted rec posts with summaries to save space on this post. I’ve added posting dates and platforms to all fics to give a better perspective on destiel fic through the years.
Thank you, Elena, for letting us to use your wonderful art! Link to artist’s tumblr: @purgatory-jar !!! <3 Link to original art post.
1. Two People Love Triangle
Astrolabe by reluctantabandon and winter_of_our_discontent [NC-17, 35,400 word count, posted 2015, AO3]
Go Down With This Ship by PorcupineGirl (submitted rec) [NC-17, 31,400 word count, posted 2016, AO3]
In Real Life by CloudyJenn [T, 6,900 word count, originally posted on LJ and FF net, 2010, now also on AO3] (unofficially recced here) #fluff, #teacher!cas, #writer!!cas, #writer!dean, #anonymity
Dean and Cas know each other online. Sam and Cas know each other in real life. Sam makes the connection first and has a lot of fun with it.
Looking For Group by athaclena [T, 25,200 word count, posted 2017, AO3]
Mi Casa es tu Casa by MalMuses !! NEW REC!! [M, 29,500 word count, posted 2018, AO3] #fluff, #coworkers, #anonymity, #coming out, #rom com, #sabriel, #feelings recovery
Castiel Novak has a dull, predictable life. He’s single, lonely, and lives with his cat. He’s also had the same job at Sandover International for eight long years. Dean Winchester doesn’t seem to be going anywhere. His job sucks, and his previous bad experiences have put him firmly back in the closet. He’s spent so long looking after his brother, he doesn’t remember how to have anything for himself. Everything changes for them both when Castiel’s brother talks him into partnering on a new business venture - Casa2, an LGBT-friendly venue in their small, conservative town. Working in the bar at night, Castiel begins receiving phone calls from a cautious-but-charming mystery man ‘Armando’. His new acquaintance is trying to get up the courage to come out to more people than just his brother, and Castiel finds himself invested in helping. An odd phone-friendship blooms, as they both turn out to be just what the other needs. Trying not to either risk his job or let down his brother, Castiel finds himself torn. Would Armando ever want more than friendship from him? Or should he beg the sexy new maintenance man at his office to come and fix all his problems…
Reading between the lines by consultingcas (submitted rec) [T, 15,600 word count, posted 2016, AO3]
Unfreeze by youaresunlight !! NEW REC!! [T, 3,00 word count, posted 2017, AO3] #fluff, #college, #anonymity
Dean is crushing on a fellow student (with an incredibly hot voice) who works at their university’s I.T. Help Desk. At the same time, he meets a guy through his dating app who is impossibly gorgeous and equally charming. How in the world is he supposed to choose?
2. Identity Porn. Two People Love Triangle is a part of much larger trope, Identity Porn, which is more popular in fandoms with superheros (see Fanlore definition) where you can get Lois Lane, Clark Kent and Superman tangle. Since Supernatural fandom doesn’t have canon material for Identity Porn stories, destiel fics are exploring secret identity angst in relationship in very creative ways that is sometimes very hard to categorize. Here’s some of my favorite fics with secret identities and delicious tension they bring to the story. As always, this is YMMV kinda rec.
2.1. Superhero AU
Lois Lane Never Had it So Hard by FunnyWings !! NEW REC!! [T, 29,200 word count, posted 2018, AO3] #superheros, #coworkers, #danger sacrifice, #writer!dean, #writer!cas, #love hate, #cassie
It started with the most humiliating picture of Dean Winchester’s life and just snowballed from there. When a sinister new big bad moves into Lawrence Kansas, will the local heroes (and maybe a few villains) be able to band together and save their home?
Check out our Superheroes tag for more fic and this ask with superhero fics with one sided anonymity!
2.2. One sided anonymity/ secret identity - at least one person is aware of secret identity, his own or other person’s, and keeps it undisclosed.
And This, Your Living Kiss by opal_bullets [T, 57,000 word count, posted 2019, AO3]
Cinderwings by bendingsignpost [M, 182,000, word count, posted 2018, AO3]
The Complete Works of Emmanuel Allen by violue [NC-17, 56,300 word count, posted 2016, AO3]
Kite Songs by ladytalemachus [T, 9,100 word count, posted 2010, on LJ] (unofficially recced here) #love hate, #writer!dean, #teacher!cas
In which Cas seeks internet notoriety with his controversial views on the latest darling of American fiction, and stumbles across something else entirely
National Muggle Awareness Month by prideofportree [T, 36,800 word count, posted 2015, AO3]
That’s not my name by dizbil [NC-17, 36,500 word count, posted 2012, LJ and AO3] #fluff, #writer!dean, #teacher!cas, #rom com, #anonymity, #fuckup!dean
Do you know Sarah Wesson? The famous writer giving advices to people? Well she has nothing to do with Dean, the man just works in the same newspaper as her. That's all. Expect that it's not really the truth, but Dean doesn't have time to worry about that. No, he's too busy falling in love with that perfect literature teacher, Castiel Novak.
2.3. One sided anonymity with smut
All A Boy Could Give by rockstarpeach !! NEW REC!! [M, 3,600 word count, posted 2014, AO3] #fluff, #college, #anonymity, #roommates, #writer!!dean
College AU. Castiel comes across a Dr Sexy kink meme and every prompt he leaves gets filled almost immediately. Also, he has a not-so-secret crush on his roommate. You can see where this is going :) Probably half this fic is Dr Sexy fanfic, which I had a blast writing.
Confessions of a Cam Boy by MsCaptainWinchester (rons_pigwidgeon) (submitted rec) [NC-17, 13,000 word count, posted 2016, AO3] #pornstar!dean, #coworkers, #anonymity
hardcorewings.com by CloudyJenn [NC-17, 17,000 word count, posted 2010 (?) originally on LJ, see download links on the review]
If At First You Don’t Succeed (Destroy All Evidence That You Ever Tried) by justkeeponwriting [NC-17, 49,000 word count, posted 2015, AO3]
No, He Can’t Read My Poker Face by HigherMagic [NC-17, 10,100 word count, posted 2012, FF net and LJ] (unofficially recced here) #high school, #porn, #anonymity
It’s a Masquerade Ball. Normally something Castiel would want to avoid – too many people getting drunk while taking part in the total lack of inhibitions that a mask can give them. The last part, well, Castiel intends to take full advantage of.
The Prank That Filled The Spank Bank by bookkbaby [NC-17, 41,000 word count, posted 2012, LJ and AO3]
well this is awkward by jhoom !! NEW REC!! [M, 8,400 word count, posted 2016, AO3] #coworkers, #anonymity
Mr. Novak frequently calls in to IT for help with his computer. Dean offers to field all his calls because there’s something about the guy’s voice that just gets him going…
Don't miss our other Destiel AU rec lists, check them out here!
Or, maybe after all AU cuteness, it’s time to check out Destiel Canon fic rec lists?
If you enjoyed the fic, please drop by the archive (AO3) and let the author know with your comments and/or kudos! And if you found our recs useful, let us know by Liking and/or Reblogging our posts.











