In 1503, the governor of the island Nicolás de Ovando sent word to Anacaona that he was going to Jaragua for a friendly visit. This visit had the pretext of improving the relations between the conquerors and the Indians. Before this visit, Anacaona gathered numerous caciques from the area and offered Ovando and his companions a great reception with dances and parties, the same one he had done years before with Bartholomew Columbus.
Despite the demonstrations of friendship offered to the governor, he believed the chiefs were planning a conspiracy. For that reason, Ovando pretended to reciprocate the honors with which he was received and invited Anacaona and the other caciques to witness a military drill in his honour. They assembled in a large main house of wood and thatched roof, built to house Ovando and his companions. Those on horseback and those on foot began to surround them and when more enthusiastic were the lords, at a agreed signal, all the cavalry with spears and swords attacked violently against them, setting fire to the house and killing many of them. Diego Méndez, one of the protagonists of the fourth voyage of Columbus, lived in Jaragua at that time. He stated in his testament that 84 caciques died.
Anacaona was transferred to Santo Domingo, and three months later she was tried and sentenced to death hanged, punishment that was applied at that time to the accused of conspiracy. Ovando's performance in this act is one of the most inexplicable and cruel acts of his rule. The impact of this punishment quickly reached Queen Isabella I of Castile, who promptly dismissed him from her deathbed upon hearing of his actions.











