Betrayal
Horrortober Day 25: Run “You can run, but you can’t hide from me!”
Can you believe... that I wrote this prompt for Leviathan before? How funny is that??? Please read the previous one so this one is a bit easier to understand setting-wise! This is really funny to me, but I spiced it up a little, enjoy!
Warnings: Yandere, Non-Consensual Touches, Hunting the darling, Possessiveness, Jealousy Characters: Leviathan x Reader (x Lucifer)
“You can run, but you can’t hide from me!”
The words haunted you as you cowered behind Lucifer’s bed. It was a shame he wasn’t home, nowhere near actually, and you left your phone in Levi’s room. But still, his room was mostly off-limits for the brothers, and you weren’t sure if anyone would dare to come in here to look for you. At least for a few minutes, you were able to calm your racing heart and massage your feet, your body aching with anxiety and running around. Everything had been going so well between you and the brothers. Why had it suddenly turned out to be so weird?
Running around, claiming you were ‘theirs’, it was just strange. But there was also Levi behaving like someone very different. Normally, he was more of a shy, funny guy that was quite a lot of fun to hang out with, but when he started to touch you and yank at your arm, he was… scary. It reminded you of his true being, which you should have never forgotten, just because he played video games with you. You certainly did not like that Levi, much less the situation he got you in.
Satan and Belphie, too, had been behaving strangely. You still felt the handcuffs on your wrists as if Satan hadn’t removed them before. The thought alone about what they were planning and the ‘deal’ they were making over your head—it gave you the shivers. Maybe you were still napping, and this was all a bad dream. But no matter how much you wished for it to be a nightmare, it was very much real.
You jolted but quickly regained your senses and ducked low when the door opened. It creaked miserably as someone made their way inside, and they seemed hesitant, quietly calling out, “[Name]?”
Levi.
He found you.
You were praying as you laid low that he’d not come further inside and maybe see you. That the thought alone of Lucifer’s punishment would make him turn on his heels and go away. Obviously, he was cautious, snooping around in the dark on quiet soles, knowing exactly he shouldn’t be here. Other than you, Levi would get a stern scolding from his brother for entering this space without permission. Maybe worse. Oh, you hoped so much that he was more scared of that than having the desire to find you. You weren’t that lucky, unfortunately.
“There you are!” he called out, and you froze, staring at him from below like a scared rabbit. Levi was overjoyed as he dropped to his knees, coming closer and closer until you could no longer back away, hitting the nightstand behind you. “I was searching everywhere for you! Why did you run away?”
His question was confusingly sincere despite his advances continuing, his hands creeping up your legs, pushing them apart for more space that he could take up. Even though you closed your knees, unknown strength seemed to surge through Levi while all you could do was use your arms to keep his torso away from you, stuttering in pure panic.
“D-Don’t come closer! Stay away!”
Despite your raised voice, Levi’s expression only changed into a half-smile, as if he didn’t quite understand what you were saying, the pressure of his hands never disappearing. “But why?” he mumbled, seemingly taken aback by your rejection. “It’s my day. I get to do what I want with you today.”
His statements were so nonchalant, unbothered by their implications. Levi didn’t own you. No one did! He couldn’t just do what he wanted, and you were about to scream that into his face when the creaking of the door returned, the light being switched on.
“Leviathan?” a deep voice asked, and you peeked up at it, hope and relief washing over you.
“Lucifer!” you called out, the word cracking from the tension releasing in you. “H-Help!”
Finally, you could breathe again. The anxiety left your body, and you managed to push Levi away, who looked at his older brother with a burning hatred like you had never seen before. Sprinting towards your savior, you were enveloped in his arms as he caught you jumping into him. You were overwhelmed with relief, knowing everything would be okay now. Lucifer would fix this. He was the only one that could get them under control. And you were a precious exchange student that needed protection at all costs—even against his own brothers.
“Levi pushed himself on me! And… and Belphie and Satan want to lock me into a magical cage just for the two of them! I was so scared! Levi kept saying things like I was some object belonging to him...”
It was pretty childish to rat them out like this, you had to admit, but you were honestly scared to death by their behavior. Maybe it was all just a big joke at your cost, but you weren’t laughing. “I was really, really scared,” you confessed, Lucifer’s hands wrapping around you, calming you as if you were one of his siblings.
“Leviathan…” he grumbled above you, and you expected him to start the scolding right away. Behind you, Levi’s clothes shuffled, and you saw him getting up to his feet as you glanced over your shoulder.
“I am trying not to care what you do on your day with [Name]. But in my room?”
Did you mishear that? Blinking a few times, you couldn’t help yourself from laughing up once and pushing away from Lucifer, ready to ask him to repeat what he just said. But the oldest brother just embraced you tighter, one hand reaching up to press your head back into his chest. “I’m afraid I’ll take them for the rest of the day as punishment.”
“Urgh, so unfair!” Levi complained behind you while you were still blindsided by Lucifer’s words. A few steps and he pushed up against your back, grabbing your upper arms to pull you back. “You can’t just change the rules as you please! They were hiding here! I had to get them!”
“Too bad. You know I don’t tolerate you rascals in here.”
“No! That’s too unfair, you can’t do that! If anyone has them other than me, I’ll get mad! They are mine today. Everyone agreed on the plan!”
The argument continued over your head while they tugged at your body as if you were a doll. This was all too surreal, absolutely unbelievable. How did you get yourself in this position? What was the deal? Why was there a plan? Too many questions and too little answers, but suddenly the attention shifted back to you, the demons looking at you, and they placed you between them. Expectant eyes stared daggers into you as they gave you too much power in this unfortunate situation you were in.
“What about you? Who do you want to spend the day with?” Levi asked, squeezing your arms to a painful extent. He seemed desperate, but he looked at you with the same big, innocent eyes which the Levi had that you liked. But under these eyes, would you find the good or the bad one?
“Choose wisely,” Lucifer reminded you, his eyes burning with a desire to be picked. His pride could not stand the rejection, and you knew it. But… he betrayed you. He didn’t help you with the Levi problem, but he too knew about whatever plan they had. He, too… wanted to claim you as his.
What would happen if you made the wrong choice? Was there even a right one?
Maybe, the best thing you could do... was to keep running.
