[insert strawberry here] Ysamyne!
sorry for missing this last night!!
wanted to talk about ysamyne as sheogorath for a bit. ysamyne as an OC is almost 2 years old at this point (baby!!! love her!!!!) and she’s evolved a lot over time and as i have learnt more about the games (i had a post-oblivion story planned for her before i played shivering isles and having to throw that out. was painful) and i have changed my tune on where she stands as sheogorath
to begin: ysamyne was raised around daedra, with knowledge of the daedra, and also, resenting the daedra. her bio parents were former daedric cultists who died in a failed revolt; her adoptive parent was a comrade and a lapsed daedric cultist and taught ysamyne a lot of daedric magic that wasn’t intended to be shared with outsiders. when her mother died, ysamyne began selling illegal necromancy scrolls on the black market in vivec; this led to the mythic dawn trying to recruit her. ysamyne since the beginning has had her life surrounded by daedric cults, by lives who have been warped to fit the whims of daedric princes, is keenly aware of how daedric princes use mortals like pawns in a much grander game.
she does not like the daedra. at all. yes, she is a witch who practises “dark” magic - summoning, conjuration, weird rituals - but that does not mean she has to like the daedra. after meeting martin - who was of a similar background, at least, as far as daedra are concerned - she makes it her mission to destroy them all.
when i made ysamyne i had no intention of her actually ever going back to the daedra. shivering isles frustrated me a lot because it didn’t fit with the character arc i had in mind. i first wanted to just, retcon it completely. i then made a compromise - shivering isles happened but ysamyne backed out midway through the mantling process and started a rebellion against sheogorath in his realm. she defeated jyggalag through revealing all his logica contradictions: he was an order’s vision of chaos, and was a tyrant who didn’t belong on the isles, he was never sheogorath, nor could he ever be. and that was that. and ysamyne would spend the rest of her life trying to trick and thwart daedric princes in a similar fashion - outsmarting them, outwitting them, proving them wrong, seeding dissent, and so on. a particular favourite story of mine is how she got caught trespassing in nocturnal’s realm, but managed to win a bet with nocturnal through befriending the fickle blackfeather court, who guided her out of a forest in on a starless night - and thus she is allowed to trespass nocturnal’s woods in the witching hours of the night (hence her association with crows).
but i’ve come around on her being sheogorath. partially because there’s no satsifying ending for an arc where she is trying to outwit daedric princes until the end of time. partially because that behaviour is very sheogorath - although she’d never admit it, at first.
i think most events happen in the same way - but it better explains how ysamyne was able to take the city of vivec and place it in her realm to guard it from the effects of the red year. i think what happens is that she remains much the same - a determined meddler with forces beyond her reckoning, who takes joy in angering gods, who during those first years on the isles took pains to look out for the lost, the outcast, those on the outside - and sheogorath grows into her shoes as much as she grows into the role over time. a long time - over centuries, likely. mantling is described as “walk like them until they walk like you” and what happens is that last statement, too. sheogorath is no longer a prince in a palace but a wanderer on the road who sees a man trying to pull down a mountain with a tiny little pickaxe, or sees a woman trying to make beautiful music with a broken instrument, and goes “me too, buddy”. the isles are the place where you go when you get truly lost, and sheogorath is not its ruler and is not your jailer, but a kindred spirit who understands what it is to be utterly lost. and why. and for what kind of reasons. and will accompny you until you can find your way again.
ysamyne isn’t aware of this at first - and then becomes aware of it, and tries desperately to stop it, which is very sheogorath of her, really, and the sheo quest in skyrim likely doesn’t apply to ysamyne - her general opinion on dead monarchs is ‘lol fuck them’ - but a similar situation is occurring - she’s fucked off to nirn and is avoiding the isles even as that has negative consequences because she’s trying not to be herself and the dragonborn has to help her help another of the “mad”, of the “lost”, before she can return back to the isles.