“Then” Indigenous Shamans
Facebook Group
Vietnam is made up of fifty-four recognized ethnic groups. The Kinh ethnic group made up of eighty-seven percent of the population. The Tày and Nùng people comprise a little over three percent of the population. Tày and Nùng population live primarily in Northern Vietnam within mountainous provinces such as Lạng Sơn. Their homes are within the valley, among the lower slopes of the mountains, and along the rivers. Because they live side by side with nature, it is no surprise that the natural landscape of their homeland has a profound effect on their spiritual life and belief.Among some of the religious practice, the Tày and Nùng people are best known for a form of shamanism known as Then. I am a member of the Tày ethnic group so this form shamanism is very personal and close to heart.
To define Then is difficult for a multitude of reasons. As with most forms of shamanism or animistic religion, there is no concrete dogma. It is worth noting that there is also no official religious text – though there are indeed commentary writings in recent history. "Then" is practiced by several minority ethnic groups who live across northern and northeastern provinces of Vietnam. Thus, it is no surprise that there would also be a slight difference in beliefs from one group to another which brought about some discrepancies. These indigenous communities also experienced influenced by the three major eastern religions –Buddhism, Daoism, and Confucianism– which further added layers of confusion. Prior to 1945, there appears to be no academic study of Then among the scholars. Of the studies conducted after 1945, most were general and placed primary focus on music and art of Then rather than the beliefs and practice. In addition, Then is still very much a mystery to the majority of the Vietnamese population even at to this day.
The difficulty in defining and understanding Then from an academic point of view or as outsiders is not to say that it lacks substance or a comprehensive system of belief. Then is a rich and profound spiritual practice that is not at all completely apart from the daily lives of these indigenous minority groups. One can say that Then is culturally significant to these populations due to the fact that it goes beyond just religion. Then has a place in almost all aspects of a person’s life from birth until death and is deeply interwoven with the culture, folklore traditions, and the very land of the Tày and Nùng people. A common saying is “If there is no Then, then the mountains and the forests seem to lack their spirit”.
The most essential of Then ritual is a form of trance-like singing, often in praise of gods and spirits, of mountains and rivers, of daily activities and farming, and of the aesthetic beauty of the world. In this way, perhaps we could imagine that Then is not really viewed as a separate matter from the daily lives of the Tày and Nùng people, and therefore the need to define it in a religious context as a comparative religion to other religions is simply not a thing until recent history. However, for the sake of understanding Then, it is necessary to break it down and attempt to make sense of it in ways that we could generally agree upon is the overall beliefs and practice.
The word Then is believed to be related to the word Thiên which is Tiān(天) in Chinese, meaning heaven. Thus, Then is a shamanistic multifaceted practice relating to heaven. This is evident in the Tày and Nùng legend of how Then came to be, or to be more exact, how the shamans of Then came to be.The legend told of ancient times in which the people of these ethnic groups suffered hardship from the lack of necessities. The land didn’t provide fruitful harvests and the people were plagued with diseases. Seeing this, there were three brothers who decided that they would travel to see the king of heaven. As they traveled, they reached a river and rested for the night. Earlier the next morning, the eldest brother left before dawn to see the king of heaven and explained the situation. The king of heaven bestowed him with robe and hat, stallions, and a great number of religious texts to take home in order to help the people. The eldest brother thus became a priest (Thầy Tào). Therefore the priests of Tày and Nùng people would adorn formal religious garments during ceremonies or religious rituals and chant from scriptures. Priests are also generally knowledgeable on history and literature thus they are seen as the highest among the three. The middle brother woke up at dawn to see the king of heaven and was bestowed what left of the texts and a pair of cymbals instruments. He became a witch doctor (Thầy Mò). Once it was bright out, the youngest of the three brothers finally woke up and went to see the king of heaven. At this point, there was not much left to be given so the king of heaven gathered all he could and gave it to the youngest brother. He was given a bamboo broom, a wooden dipper, and a bundle of dried fruits. The youngest brother was exceptionally skilled and made a fan from the bamboo broom, a Đàn Tính (gourde lute with two strings) from the dipper, and the bundle made into a bundle of bells to mimic the sound of a running warhorse. Thus, the youngest brother became a Then shaman (Thầy Then). To this day, all Then shaman utilize Đàn Tính, a fan, and the bundle of bells while performing rituals.
It is probably safe to say the story is a a recent construct in order to explain the various religious practices among the Tày and Nùng people of the present day. The first hint was that the king of heaven in which the brothers went to see was no other than the Jade Emperor of the ritual Daoist pantheon, thus it is no surprise that the priests adorn robes quite similar to ritual Daoist priests and read from Daoist texts in Nho writings (Chinese). In addition, they are also considered the most superior of the three which seems to indicate some bias from the author(s). The story itself doesn’t provide an actual origin of Then but what it does provide is a glimpse into the role of Then shamans in these communities. From the story, the Then shaman was given items that are commonly used on a daily basis of the people such as a broom and a water dipper. The Then shaman then turned these mundane items into items with spiritual significance. The story is symbolic in drawing the connection of Then shaman and their intimate relationship to the everyday life of the people. The shaman was also the only of the three brothers who did not receive any religious text and therefore Then shamans do not chant from texts during rituals. Instead, Then shamans sing songs which were orally passed down from ancient time. Passing down knowledge orally is perhaps considered to be the most primitive form of knowledge exchange. From this, we can conduce that while the Then shaman was seen as the inferior of the three, at least in this story, it is most likely that Then is the earlier religion which is native to these indigenous groups.
The origin of Then is unknown though it is generally believed to have developed over thousands of years along with the indigenous ethnic groups it belongs to. Present-day province of Lạng Sơn,Cao Bàng and surrounding area are among some of the regions with the earliest settlement by people of Vietnam and Southeast Asia. Tày and Nùng people live primarily in these provinces. Over the millennia, the people occupying these regions developed a rich culture lasting to this day. These groups resisted cultural assimilation during ancient Chinese domination and many of the Vietnamese dynasties to preserve a cultural identity that is distinctly different from the rest of the country. While there is no written record, the history of these indigenous ethnic groups is remembered through the songs sung by Then shamans passed down through generations. Another vital aspect of Then shamanism is its connection to the natural world and the belief that spirits are found in the landscape itself. Mountains, rivers, and forests all have their own spirits. The people in these regions depended on the natural resources of the land and sea of where they live so it is no surprise that Then places importance on nature and its significance. Then is an ancient religion and developed simultaneously along with the cultural formation of these communities.
There are three different realms of existence in Then – Celestial realm earthly realm, and water realm which includes the underworld. A Then shaman is someone believed to be capable of traveling between the realms with ease through a trance. This journey in spirit body across the realms allow the shaman to do what needed to be done by either seeking the aide from the gods, receiving guidance from ancestral spirit, exorcising earthly spirits, or eradicating demons from the world below.The celestial realm is made of multiple planes. The highest of these planes resided the various gods. Among the gods are Then Luông who is the king of the gods, Then Ló the god of blacksmithing, and Then Cả the god of wisdom and beauty. These gods are powerful and have full control over the fate of humanity. They can also create rain and clouds, storms and flood, lightning and thunders. They have full control over all natural phenomena including plagues. Another plane of the celestial realm is called the “Suspending Plane”. Here reside the spirits of all the ancestors. In addition, the Thái ethnic minority believes there is a realm higher and beyond the celestial realm called Nọ Pha. In this realm lives a great serpent along with a plant like that of a banana sprout. They believe those who lived a virtuous life would ascend onto this realm and either drinks a droplet of dew from the banana sprout of a drop of sweat of the serpent and would instantly become immortal.
In the earthly realm lives human along with plants and animals. Along with physical life forms, there are also earthly deities such as the tutelary deity of the land, guardian deity of a village/town, and other nature deities. There are also various kinds of spirits. Some spirits are benevolent while some are malevolent.
The realm of water is divided among twelve palaces. The chief of the twelve palaces belongs to Long Vương or dragon king. The other palaces are controlled by various water deities. The highest among the deities and second to Long Vương is the god Hà Bá. He governs all of the monsters and demons found within all bodies of water. This realm also functions as a form of the underworld where spirits of those who lived an evil life would be captured and taken to.