Where's the country music on Pitchfork's Best Albums of the 1980s?
Needless to say, one list of albums does not have a decisive effect on society. But it isnât an overstatement to say that there is a force at work that leads us to view the expression of class interests as a neutral expression of taste. Itâs the same thing that asks us to consider a hierarchical institution like the university a meritocracy. Social theory has a name for this imaginary relationship to existing conditions: âideology.â The project of cultural studies was based on the premise that understanding ideology, by investigating how culture is produced and how canons are formed, can help explain how wider social formations operate.
At Popula, Shuja Haider discusses the relationships between country, rap, indie rock (memorably sent up as, and Iâm paraphrasing, âwah-wah college rockâ by Clueless) and Pitchforkâs criticism and canonization. Itâs a great essay. Genre is politics whether itâs in music or books or website design. I donât know much about contemporary music, but I know the truth off this in books and design.
These days, I feel too busy, too stuck, too old (or crotchety, depending on your perspective) to experience much in the way of new music. Iâm set. But, as I type this, Iâm listening, for the first time, to Mt. Eerie (nĂ©e The Microphones), and realizing this particular musical aesthetic still resonates with me, deeply.
Even more interesting, though, Mt. Eerieâs injunction that âDeath is real,â that itâs not something to sing about. And yet heâs singing about it. (This is unrelated to canon; Iâm just riffing). Heâs employing a genre to destroy it. Itâs aching and beautiful, and the loss it holds makes the container itself lose coherence. I canât even.