So I was thinking about this scene today.
Peter sustains a hit to his face, damaging his newly constructed mask and revealing part of his face. He angles himself away, hoping to keep his identity concealed from Otto. "Such a disappointment... Parker." Peter is stunned, and slowly turns to face him. "You knew?" "I tried to warn you, Peter. But you didn't listen." "You knew!"
When Peter first begins the fight against Otto, he pleads with him to come to reason. He's desperate to reach the good that he believes still exists inside his mentor and friend.
"You knew?"
Then Peter learns that Otto has known he is Spider-Man. And despite this, Otto went after him anyway. He sent the other villains after him, he got in Peter's way of securing the anti-serum needed to many lives -- including that of Aunt May's -- and he attacked him and almost killed him, essentially leaving him for dead on the floor of an Oscorp lab.
"You knew!"
From this point on, Peter stops pleading. He feels hurt and betrayed. Everything that comes out of his mouth is anger and pain.
There were never any quips in either half of this fight. This fight is too serious. It's do or die time. The first half is a desperate call to reason, and the second is a trauma response.
If you haven't, I would recommend listening to this fight's track in the soundtrack. It's absolutely my favorite, but it tells the story of this fight in the music. The first half is mostly dominated by Doc Ock's theme, while the second is overtaken by Spider-Man's more hopeful and defiant theme. Both themes are present throughout the entire track, and neither theme truly emerges as victorious, (and if you've seen the way the fight ends, it makes sense), as they constantly battle with each other in a question/answer sort of format.
And as a final thought, the mask breaking serves a double purpose. First of course is to inform the audience and Peter that Otto already knew he was Spider-Man. But it also signifies that after the revelation, the fight is no longer just Spider-Man's to fight, but Peter's too.
I love this game's story so much.
















