After having dealt with Arnolf, his brood and their mutual TREACHERY, not much surprised Alys anymore when it came to that part of the family. However, nothing could have prepared for the sudden glassiness ( she REFUSED to think of them as tears ) that took over Lotharâs shockingly blue eyes. He turned his head away from hers quickly so she only caught a glimpse, and Alys herself did the same as soon as she realised what was happening. She was just as uncomfortable with his uncharacteristical show of emotion as he was, and it was unspoken but plain that none of them would acknowledge it, EVER. She cleared her throat noisily, as if to clear the air of any awkwardness with that gesture, but the sound was lost amongst the loud merriment that still raged around them, ignorant of the tense conversation that was taking place in a shadowy corner of the great hall. Even her father, who normally rarely strayed his eyes away from her for too long, seemed to have FORGOTTEN about their existence entirely.
âSure,â Alys said with a shrug, her voice sounding easy and careless â though she still refused to look at him in the eye, not wanting to see whatever emotion they may carry. âI donât particularly care what you do all day. I just said it to start a SOMEWHAT PLEASANT conversation.â A task, needless to say, that she failed miserably. When she finally turned to face him again, her expression was coloured with surprise and SUSPICION, as she couldnât tell whether he was telling the truth or if this was one of his many sarcastic japes. He always did have a âsense of humourâ that she could never seem to understand.
âPoetryâŚâ She spoke the word incredulously, barely able to refrain herself from SNEERING or worse. âYou donât strike me as much of a poet type but⌠whatever you say.â Alys herself was guilty of enjoying books and lore more than most of her noble counterparts, but poetry was something she always considered to be a waste of time. Mostly because she simply didnât have the talent, patience or the SPIRIT for it. âWhat do you write about, then?â Not wanting him to take her question as a sign of genuine interest, she quickly added, âHow much you despise us, perhaps? I seem to recall a lady from the Reach who wrote hundreds upon hundreds of pages about how much she despised her lord husband.â
Out of nowhere, she caught Harrionâs eye, who seemed to be watching them like a hawk, displeasure written all over his face. Alys didnât doubt that with the slightest sign of âdanger,â he would make his way over to them, probably with a blade in hand. Her brother rose an eyebrow in question, after shooting Lothar the DIRTIEST look she had ever seen. Eager to avoid any possible scene, Alys shrugged and shook her head at Harry, hoping to deter him from doing something most unwise. Lord Rickard had no great love for her current companion either, but he wouldnât look kindly upon one of his sons causing a scene in front of all these guests.
Heâs trying, heâs really trying to be honest, to be friendly, seemingly something she had demanded, yet it feels like his honesty is being trashed at every turn. Why had he bared himself open if it was to only receive hurtful words in return when heâs finally being honest as she had wanted. Had she not wanted to hear his honesty after all? Lothar looks down in silence, unable to form any clever words against what feels like a barrage of attacks. Sheâs mocking him, dismissing his words, presuming his guilt already - thatâs what her words feel like to him, like daggers digging into his chest, twisting and driving deeper.Â
He stays silent for a moment, wondering if he should be honest any further given the state of things, but what more could he lose? She was either going to believe him or not, maybe she will use it against him in the future, maybe she will use it to mock him or tell her brothers, at least he will know to be ready. âI write about a knight....a knight looking for respect, status, and someone to love him...a knight who is a hero of the people...â
That had been Lotharâs dream as a boy. He had desperately wanted to be a knight like all the other boys before his father had shouted at him that he was a useless cripple so he needed to stop believing in stupid dreams. His mother had berated him for upsetting his father. Lothar had cried in his room that day, crying for a dream that would never be his. He would never be a knight, nor have respect, nor anyone to love him.
He was about to say more when a shadow cast over him and Lothar looked up to find his stern-faced father Arthor, son of Arnolf. A shiver ran through him as his father wasted no time gripping him by the scruff of his neck to pull him up, intending to led him away.
âApologies, Lady Alys, I must have a word with my son.â And with that Arthor practically dragged Lothar away and into the corridors, the younger one struggling to keep up, wincing at the pain in his legs as he shuffled along on his staves. His father shoved him against the wall, eyes glaring in anger. âYou disgrace your family, and now I find you consorting with Alys Karstark looking all sad. Pathetic.â
A resounding slap sent Lothar crashing into the ground. He didnât even have time to recover before he cried out in pain as it erupted in his leg. He realized his father was stepping on one of his twisted knees, he could feel bones breaking under the weight. âFather please...â Lothar begged, even though he knew that his father hated to hear him beg and saw it as a sign of weakness. But he was in pain, he just wanted to escape, to get away.
âBegging is beneath a Karstark. Youâre weak, and weaklings like you do not deserve any sympathy. You will go to your room and stay there, you will not have food tonight or tomorrow morning until I send for you if I deem fit.â Arthor picked up the staves and wasted no time in shattering them against the wall and throwing down the pieces for Lothar to see, âSince you deem to not behave like a man, you will crawl to your room like the animal that you are.â With one last kick delivered to Lotharâs abdomen, Arthor Karstark left his son on the ground.
Lothar laid there in silence, bleeding from a cut lip, one cheek already red from the slap, and throbbing pain in his now-broken knee. Normally he would never have let his fatherâs words effect him. He would take the beating and go to his room. But today was worse than any time before, his walls werenât up, his defenses werenât up, and the pain hit him like waves on the ocean. His father would hate him forever, he would never have his fatherâs love, or anyoneâs love. What had he really done to deserve this? Wouldnât it be better if he had just died as a baby? He could have saved everyone the trouble.