Serial Killer Arthur Shawcross began his reign of terror in May of 1972, when he brutally sexually assaulted and murdered 10 year old Jake Black. Shawcross lured the young boy into the woods where he strangled him. Jake was found five months later, but with no leads, no one was arrested for his murder. A few months later, 8 year old Karen Anne Hill disappeared. She was found sexually assaulted and murdered under a bridge. Karen had mud and debris forced into her throat and clothing, as well.
Thankfully, a neighbor Shawcross with Karen by the bridge before she disappeared. In October of 1972, he was arrested for her murder. He confessed to her murder, as well as the murder of Jake Blake. Due to the lack of evidence tracing him back to Jake Blake, the charges were dropped against him. Shawcross was sentenced to 25 years for the murder of Karen Anne Hill.
Surprisingly, Shawcross was released on parole after serving 15 years in 1987. Authorities decided to seal his criminal record, as he was forced to leave Binghamton, NY after a public outcry occurred against the child killer being relocated to the area. Shawcross was then able to relocate to Rochester, NY, where after a year, his murders resumed.
In only a span of 2 years, Shawcross sexually assaulted, murdered, and mutilated 12 women, a majority of them being sex workers and drug users. His first victim, in Rochester, was 27 year old Dorothy Blackburn. She was found in the Genesee river, strangled with bite marks around her groin area on March 24th, 1988.
Next, 28 year old Anna Steffen was murdered on September 4th, 1989. Shawcross strangled and dumped Anna in a similar manner as Dorothy Blackburn. Due to her body being found far away from Blackburns, police didn’t think that this was the work of serial killer.
In October 1989, 59 year old Dorothy Keeler. She was strangled. Only 6 days later, 25 year old Patricia Ives was found, strangled as well. Due to this link, the press grew interested in the murders. They even name the murderer “the Genesee River Killer”.
June Scotts murder showed Shawcross growing and experimenting as a murderer as she was found strangled as well as mutilated after death. Shawcross removed her labia and gutted her from her throat to her crotch area. Scott was found on Thanksgiving.
29 year old Elizabeth Gibson was found on November 27, 1989. She was found in Wayne county. Before her disappearance, Gibson was seen with a suspect called “Mitch”. After the murder of Dorothy Keeler, police found out that there was a regular among sex workers that they called “Mitch”. They described him as “prone to violence”.
On December 31st, 1990, police found pants belonging to 20 year old Felicia Stephens. This lead police to conduct an aerial search of the area. This lead to the discovery of the body of 33 year old June Cicero on January 2, 1990. She was laying on the surface of the frozen river by a bridge.
Instead of retrieving her body, the authorities decided to keep surveillance on the area as they profiled that the killer would come back to the scene of the crime to relieve the pleasure of the experience. Thankfully, they were right.
Arthur Shawcross was apprehended after he was caught masturbating and urinating on the bridge where Junes body was found. He finally confessed after jewelry belonging to June Cicero was found in his girlfriend possession. Shawcross also confessed to the murders of Maria Welsh and Darlene Trippi. His confession ended up being 80 pages long.
During his trail, he tried to plea insanity as he claimed he was sexually abused as a child as well as suffering from PTSD due to fighting in the Vietnam war, where he claimed to have cannibalize 2 women and decapitate many children. He was declared sane and was convicted of 10 counts of second degree murder in Monroe county and 1 count of second degree murder in Wayne county. He was given 250 years in prison. Shawcross died of cardiac arrest on November 10th, 2008