With the explanation, Natalie couldn’t help but feel her stoicism fall flat and give way to noticeable woe on Antonio’s behalf. That certainly was distressing and not something to be taken lightly. She wouldn’t say he messed up, although it seemed he did, but how could that be his fault? She heard the name in passing before too, only having known of his rank - but all she heard from what Antonio said was that this man was corrupt. And if he were responsible for killing fourteen others, then what else had he done? More importantly, what did he do while a knight? And to have bruised Antonio’s ego this awfully…
All Natalie could do was insist. “It wasn’t your fault. How could any of us had known a wolf killer was right under our noses? How could you have known?” It was important she figuratively beat that into his head. It’s not your fault, it’s not your fault, it’s not, it’s– Until the words lost their meaning in her own head. Out of frustration that she couldn’t seem to make the words factual, to give them convincing weight, Natalie shot up onto her feet and marched the short distance to where Antonio sat and stood in front of him, trying very hard not to cross her arms over her chest. Looming over him wouldn’t send the right message, it was an intimidation tactic - a way to assert dominance and power. And as a beta, she knew alphas didn’t like that. To be challenged by someone lesser? Absolutely not. But she did not care. Antonio was pitying himself, she could see that, hell, everyone in attendance could see it but she would be damned if she didn’t get him to lift that head of his and smile.
Waves were heavy and they were violent when they crashed onto land but she would not let him be swept away into its pulling current. She would not let anyone she cared about be drowned. Maddox, Alexander, Dimitri– All of them. Even Tatiana, for crying out loud. They were her family, more than her parents ever could be. She hoped Samson would be proud of her.
“Stop telling me stories about him,” Natalie ordered firmly because really, this was how she cheered people up. She gave direction, not emotion. “You are glorifying his onslaught and I will not sit here and listen while you deprecate yourself in the process.” She grabbed onto his chin and raised his head so they were eye level. “He is a monster and all monsters can be stopped. Do you understand that? Good always prevails,” Justice always won in the end. Always. “Now you will get up on your feet, find yourself a dancing partner, and enjoy your evening because for all we know, this will be the last celebration we have in a while. You cannot spend it wallowing in this chair, loathing yourself and despairing over what could have been. What’s done is done, you cannot change it but you have plenty of opportunities to stop it. Now you know who he is, we all do. So rather than think about what you could have done differently, think about what you will do. Do you understand me?”
Tonio glanced up briefly, searching for some kind of... maybe forgiveness for what he’d done, or maybe condemnation, which he felt was probably more appropriate. What he saw in her eyes was distress, and his heart plummeted again. Why was he subjecting her to this? If he had any decency left, he would excuse himself now and save her from the rest of his misery. That was all he saw in his future going forward, at least for the foreseeable future. Until maybe something proved to him that the world was not as dark as it appeared and their odds not as slim as they felt.
“I keep asking myself that,” he mumbled, his hand traveling from his shoulder to his face, swiping over the skin as though he could wipe off the taint he felt clinging to him. “I’ve been asking myself that every night before I go to sleep, and the answer is the same. I couldn’t, but I still feel like I should have.” He met her gaze, though it was a struggle, and shook his head as he went on. “All my life, I’ve had great taste in everything. It’s a small thing to be proud of, pretty superficial, and yeah, probably more than a little egotistical, but nobody’s ever proven me wrong. Until now. I always thought I would know evil when it was in front of me. I thought I’d seen in when I went away to fight, and it didn’t seem so bad or so terrifying. But that wasn’t true evil, not by a long shot. True evil wears a smile and pours you a drink and reminisces over similar past woes and future desires.” Tonio leaned forward, something between desperation and humiliation on his face as his fears began to flood from his mouth. “Now that I’ve let it trick me into letting innocents die, how am I supposed to help fight that? What about when it turns up in front of me in another form, what horrors will it make me do then? Natalie, I... I don’t want to give up hope. I don’t. But I can’t trust myself or my instincts right now and–”
In one fluid movement, the she-wolf was towering over him and fixing him with a look he’d seen many times but never been on the receiving end of. He felt instinct stir in him, curiosity at her direction morphing slowly but surely into offense at her boldness. It had only ever rarely occurred to him that Natalie was a beta; so much of her temperament had him instinctively assuming her to be an alpha that he never questioned it. And in the rare moments when he was reminded of the fact, it always came as a complete surprise. In this particular case, the surprise was more indignant than amused, as his own wolf side demanded to know (albeit in a lethargic way, as if it was awakening from sleep) just what this beta thought she was doing? He hardly noticed his jaw clenching, his shoulders squaring, or his posture straightening until he was about to leap to his own feet and bark at her to back down. He barely pulled himself up short. What kind of way was that to react to what she was saying? Her voice rang in his ears, and with his undivided attention, her message was more than clear.
He understood quite well what she’d done. Clever girl, he thought, reigning in his instinct just a touch to prevent him from taking too much of her well-meaning bait. But he clung to the sense of self that she’d suddenly awoken in him with her odd but effective approach. He hadn’t felt like this in days. Hell, he hadn’t realized it until now, but he hadn’t even felt like a wolf. More like a dog that had been kicked to the curb to lick his wounds and wonder what he’d done to deserve such misery. He did not try to defend himself against her words, merely listened and nodded, the shadow of a smile solidifying into a small quirk of the lips. “I understand,” he said. Honestly, he was still feeling pensive and less than energetic, not the ideal state for celebrating, but she had alleviated a large portion of the guilt he was feeling. He rose slowly, looking into her eyes and putting a hand on her shoulder. “Thank you, Natalie. I will keep it in mind. And... I will try to enjoy myself, just for you. It may take me a while to find a partner, though. I feel like I may have offended more than a few people tonight with my less than exuberant attitude. I don’t suppose you’re feeling up for a turn or two?” There was no pressure to his offer, he knew that it wasn’t really her bailiwick, but it would allow him the comfort of her company for a little longer. And maybe that would help push him further into a better frame of mind.