I'd rather be in outer space 🛸

Love Begins
TMBGareOK. The Official They Might Be Giants tumblr
EXPECTATIONS
The Bowery Presents
No title available
almost home
Cosimo Galluzzi

Discoholic 🪩
Monterey Bay Aquarium
Claire Keane
art blog(derogatory)
No title available

PR's Tumblrdome
h
Interview Vampire Daily
Lint Roller? I Barely Know Her

Origami Around

#extradirty

shark vs the universe
seen from United States

seen from United States

seen from Netherlands
seen from Norway

seen from Ecuador
seen from Saudi Arabia
seen from Chile

seen from Germany

seen from Türkiye

seen from France
seen from Israel
seen from Türkiye

seen from Netherlands

seen from Poland

seen from T1
seen from United States
seen from United States

seen from Brazil

seen from Spain
seen from United States
@utka-skandalist
These are the characters in my book
My oc🥹
· His name is Heaven Pallium
· He is Prince Charming
· He is an angel serving his kingdom
· I came up with his name while listening to Sabaton
· He is at war
· Absolute🚬🙂
Asketic: Give me some bread.
Kerry: Don't give him bread.
Mophead: Gives bread.
Asketic: Look what I can do...
I have a theory. It's not without its problems, but if it happens to be correct, it might provide explanations for some of my questions. So, my previous theory was that Mophead is not Eriche. I'll develop it further.
I've seen the theory that Eriche committed suicide, and Munroe helped him. But it was important to them that no one would come looking for Eriche. So, Munroe committed a crime: he struck some random guy in the head with a rifle butt and covered the resulting wound with Erich's scalp. This leads to the plausible theory that Mophead is composed of different bodies.
Things that indirectly support this theory:
· Munroe is afraid of Mophead and doesn't want to talk to him about the past, because if Mophead starts remembering something, Munroe will be in serious trouble.
· Also, the scene where Munroe lights a candle for Eriche. He wouldn't do that if Erich were still alive. After all, he only lost his memory, he didn't die.
But here are the questions:
· Why didn't Munroe just tell Mophead he was Erich from the start?
· Why didn't he go through with his plan and tell the command that this was Eriche?
Perhaps there simply wasn't a need. No one cared that Eriche was missing, and Munroe realized his plan was stupid and decided to pretend nothing happened. But then Mophead started pressing him. He couldn't admit that Mophead lost his memory because of him and then just call him Eriche.
Or... another thought occurred to me: Mophead is running from something, right? So, he committed some act and, while trying to escape, stumbled upon Munroe burying Eriche. He asked Munroe to help him hide, and Munroe either tried to disguise him with Erich's hair, or — out of fright — struck Mophead with the rifle butt and only then decided to disguise him. Yes, this sounds more convoluted and therefore less likely, but it explains why Munroe dragged Mophead into this whole scheme in the first place.
Now I'll address some of the questions that arise— specifically the technical aspects. The blow from Munroe could have killed Mophead; it didn't necessarily have to be precise. The scalp could have been tied to Mophead's head with bandages. It's unlikely that the medical staff examined him closely — the machine would fix everything anyway. This might have been his first death, so the mutation wasn't very noticeable, or perhaps he didn't die at all
Here's a new theory. Again, I heard it from another person, but without an explanation of what he meant. Namely, that Mophead is not Eriche. And this is actually very interesting. It's not the most obvious thought.
So, what evidence do we have for this? The only thing similar between Eriche and Mophead is their hair. They have different faces, different scars, different heights. And a different vibe. I think their characters differ; just compare Mophead's behavior to how Eriche was in the photo. It's like comparing a Chihuahua and a St. Bernard. Of course, amnesia could change a personality—I don't fully know how that works.
So, now the explanation. It's not entirely clear how Munroe found Mophead. Was it on the battlefield or in the hospital? He could have lost Eriche and mistaken someone who just somewhat resembles him for him.
By the way, I don't quite understand why Kerrie and Warwick didn't know anything about him. Perhaps Munroe's entire squad, including Eriche, went missing, and Munroe was transferred to a new squad along with Mophead, whom he supposedly knows. But then where did Mophead come from, and what does this theory give us?
Again, I had two theories. The first was that Mophead is running from something, which caused his amnesia, and the second is that he is the Chosen One. And, in principle, both versions could fit with this new theory quite well.
Firstly, I don't think Eriche is capable of doing something he would need to run from. But Mophead could. Well, then what's the point of all this fuss with Eriche? So that Mophead has no connections to his past, and it wouldn't be revealed immediately in the plot.
Now, the theory about him being the Chosen One. I had a thought that he might not have a past at all. He was born from the war to fulfill some purpose.
Another interesting detail in this case is that Mophead is literally an Ersatz — a cheap replacement for Eriche.
I would like to talk about how I see the continuation of Ersatz. It's something between a theory and fanfiction. More precisely, what decisions I would have made. The main question so far is why Mophead lost his memory. And all we can definitely expect from the future plot is the answer to why. I have already analyzed the theories. It would be funny if the one I dismissed immediately turned out to be true, namely that Mophead lost his memory because he was assembled from different parts. And I put forward two assumptions that would radically influence the plot in different ways. This is that Mophead is running from something and that he is the Chosen One. And here we have two options, because if we combine these theories, something strange comes out. These theories seem mutually exclusive to me, because I don't think the Solar God cares about Mophead's bad memories. It would just look like a coincidence that he lost his memory both because of the god and because of trauma.
And so we have two options. If it's trauma, then the plot becomes more localized. It will probably be a sitcom (like All Quiet on the Western Front) focused on character development. You could say it's boring, but this option makes everything hopeless. As it begins, so it ends. This really suits the narrative. Also, in this case, the plot could be focused on a personal rebellion that leads to nothing. Another theory I have is that in this case, if the hero feels like he's achieving something, he might experience amnesia again, become a replacement for himself again, and become a completely different person who is not interested in any of this. I would develop the story something like that.
We should also discuss the chosen one option. In fact, it doesn't disrupt the narrative as much as it seems. It's all about the very existence of the Solar God. I can't point my finger at the sky and claim what Saint wanted to say with this, but many fans have come to the consensus that he symbolizes hope. Well, that means things aren't completely hopeless right from the first episode. But it looks like teasing, and a full-fledged plot with a chosen one is no longer teasing. Why all of a sudden? We don't know the god's true goals. You could come up with a lot of interesting and not very positive things here. The only problem in this case is the very fact of change. But the likelihood of suffering ending is one thing, and the likelihood of it changing is another. Although, yeah, it's too complicated. In any case, there will be less hopelessness than in the first episode. But hopelessness, in my opinion, is the main value of the series so far, intentionally or not. Immortality is scarier than death. I tried to justify the second option. I don't know how Saint wants to place the emphasis, or maybe I see the strength of the project in something everyone else doesn't care about, but this is still fanfiction. The first option seems more economical. You can shoot an epic on a budget, for some reason I'm thinking about Evangelion and Ena. Should we make a plot about rebellion? For now, it seems the most logical. It's just that in the first option it seems completely impossible, like against whom? Will they reveal the identities of the command? Give them faces? That's an obvious option, but not the best one. They don't even show the enemies here. And the distance to them is shorter than to those sitting in uniforms with medals. But still, Mophead has a character capable of rebellion. He is very persistent and willing to do anything to achieve his goals. I don't think that's for nothing. I think it fits well with the theory of chosenness. For example, in addition to amnesia and improved appearance, Mophead will begin to show some extraordinary abilities, and those higher up will become interested in him. That's definitely interesting, but damn the narrative. And it's also likely that Mophead will have to part with the characters shown in the first episode.
We should also discuss the war itself. Perhaps I'm overestimating its endlessness. Again, my earlier theory. One way or another, the enemy side could assemble a soldier's body and properly dispose of it. I don't know how well trench warfare tactics suit this. But still, the machine's capabilities are not limitless. But still, the war could last hundreds or thousands of years. Its end is also a guaranteed death. I reasoned about its meaning. And I personally would choose that its meaning is the simulation of human life and the life of the state. With the advent of the machine, a lot has lost its meaning. Life has no meaning without death, just as war has no meaning without victory. But war and life exist. This looks interesting and, again, hopeless. And very human. What is left for an immortal person but to suffer endlessly? And at the same time, keep signing up for this endless suffering.
I forgot one detail. Munroe for some reason didn't want to talk about Erich's past. This points more to the first theory. Mophead has something to run from and Monroe has something to hide. To summarize, at the crossroads, I would choose the first option. And I really liked the idea of the amnesia cycle. You can even do it without rebellion. Mophead just does something again that he wants to run from and forgets everything again. And gets stuck in this cycle. It seems like something is changing for him, but still, it's infinite.
I’ve heard many thoughts about why Eriche remembers nothing. Many overlook the fact that he started looking better after resurrection, while resurrections disfigure other characters. So, here are the possibilities:
· Eriche is assembled from several bodies. In my opinion, many in Ersatz are assembled from multiple bodies, but it doesn’t have the same effect. Maybe I’m missing something, but the nurse couldn’t really explain the reason for the amnesia, meaning she hadn’t encountered it before.
· Concussion or head injury. This doesn’t explain why he looks better. By the way, Munroe likely had brain damage, indicated by his eyes being different sizes, but his memory is fine.
· Here’s a more interesting option. Asketic mentioned that Mophead might be running from something. I rarely see this idea being explored. It still doesn’t explain his appearance, but I think Eriche might have done something terrible.
· Improved appearance is normal. No one was surprised by this, which I find strange. But Karrie said he looks like a new fighter. And it’s all weird because all fighters are disfigured except him.
· Mophead is the chosen one. I haven’t seen this theory yet. The Solar God appeared to him in a nightmare for a reason—he chose him for some purpose. Yes, it sounds ridiculous, but it explains why he’s unique. Plus, there must be some plot ahead; I don’t think it will just be repetitive trench filler episodes.
I have some thoughts about the war in Ersatz. It seems somewhat absurd, since the enemies cannot kill each other, which is essentially the core of the conflict. So what's the point? Most likely, it's not about victory, but could there really be other possibilities? I think there can.
· There is no meaning. Not in the sense that clownsaint didn't think it through. There was no meaning from the start. It seems impossible to a human that something could have no purpose, but the one(s) who started and continue it may have a not very human perspective on the world.
· It could have existed, but it was forgotten with the development of military technology, and the war continued as something taken for granted.
· We are definitely dealing with a more technologically advanced society where life can last forever. This should have broken the old paradigms. But human nature remained the same, and war is its integral part. What is an immortal state to do, except simulate its normal existence, guided by the human psyche? Of course, wage war.
· A fundamental conflict. This seems unlikely to me, since people are shown to have little interest in lofty matters, yet the war could demonstrate what irreconcilable contradictions in people's views, or not of the people themselves but of the propaganda of different states, can lead to. But this issue wasn't raised in the film.
· A kind of sadism of the rulers. There are simply those who enjoy watching endless suffering, and people are happy to participate because it grants them immortality and they are used to it. The fear of death overpowers the desire for comfort.
· Or maybe I'm overthinking it. And the point is to achieve some result. We don't know what the enemy is. It seems to me that what best resonates with the film's idea is that they are the same people, and nothing indicates they are any different from the heroes, yet it could still be something else, something that, if not contained, could destroy all life. But that somehow violates the idea of hopelessness.
· And yes, it's important not to forget that the central theme of Ersatz is hopelessness. Victory seems impossible or is impossible. But soldiers are still being convinced of the possibility of victory. It is symbolized by the solar god. I think he does imbue all this darkness with some meaning. However, I don't think anyone takes this seriously, or that the Crown's goals intersect with this in any way. It's just a beautiful symbol, preventing the soldiers from going mad.