https://www.tumblr.com/vboyrules/725896149442183168/green-nonsense-10-thinking-it-would-have-been?source=share
I saw greenie stans say that Nyra would have killed a woman who 'dared' come forward if Jace or Luke raped them???? And I am like????? It's not Jace or Luke raping the servant girls 🤷
It's generally ridiculous when greenies try to say that Alicent "stuck her neck out" for women and I am like how??? By giving her moon tea and gold to get out??? Okay but she still instilled her rapist son into the most powerful position of the realm???? It's generally disturbing how George is like "hey, how we treat kids born out of wedlock is wrong." They legit just close their eyes and act as if Nyra NOT WANTING TO ASSAULT HER GAY HUSBAND is a crime purchasable by usurping and or death???? And like???? It would have been nearly impossible to find a guy who she could trust to keep the secret and would allow his children to be claimed/adopted by another man (And don't even get me started on the greenies hating Harwin either 💀)
It's wild that they legit say they hated how Alicent was portrayed as an evil step mother (in the books) but then reduce her down to a pawn and a child bride. Like??? At least book Alicent had ambition and wasn't otto's pawn???? If my fantasy book ever becomes a show and they pull the same shit they did for Alicent and Nyra I will shoot myself 😭
"If my fantasy book ever becomes a show and they pull the same shit they did for Alicent and Nyra I will shoot myself 😭"
I actually laughed at that, you are so right anon, for how much (especially in the early 2010s) GOT got praised for having 'strong female characters', they really butchered both Alicent and Rhaenyra to make them both sympathetic.
I saw numerous posts about the greens fantasizing about Jace and Luke committing r4pe and Rhaenyra covering for them on reddit, those are have to be the biggest copiums ever :D They would do anything, but actually acknowledge that they are supporting a man who is canonically a r4pist. Recently, I have noticed this pattern, how they try to bring down Rhaenyra and her sons to the same level as Alicent and her sons (minus Daeron). They are so close to getting it, yet they refuse to see it. The delusion can be quite blinding, I guess.
Oh, I agree with you so much! Claiming that team green is actually team women is even bad as a joke. It’s honestly exhausting, how they have to bend over themselves in so many ways, making up things so they can wash themselves of any criticism. You can support whoever team or character you want, but at least own up to what you stick your neck out for. Claiming that team green is ‘team women’, when their entire cause is based on the very fact and claim that they think a woman shouldn’t rule and instead a man should, just for the mere fact that he is in possession of a dick is anything but ‘team women’. Their idea of womanhood borders with victimhood. I swear, I’m baffled how HOTD brought up so many forgotten ideologies about a “woman’s place” in asoif. Same with the bastardy issue. Game of Thrones wasn’t perfect, but if it did anything right (in the beginning at least) then it was fighting hateful ideologies marginalized groups faced.
People were ready to call for Gendry ( a bastard son of Robert) or Jon Snow ( a man known as a bastard in his entire life, given some very questionable, half-assed reason how he is trueborn - legally, he can’t be trueborn, because multiple wives are not accepted in Westeros at that time) to sit on the Iron Throne as the rightful heirs (over Daenerys, a woman, with both the claim and the ambition to be Queen, but that’s another post for another day), yet all was forgotten, when it’s about a woman having ‘bastards’. Jace, Luke and Joffrey are not bastards on the same level as Gendry or even Jon Snow. For one, they were never legally anything, but trueborn. Two, they were born in a mutual understanding between consenting parties, with the knowledge and clear support of Laenor. I know it’s rotten work to try to place team black characters into modern perspective (that’s only allowed for the likes of Alicent!), but their situation was basically a form of surrogacy/adoption.
Honestly, I loved book!Alicent. Yes, she was a horrible person, but she was actually smart, cunning, ambitious and ruthless, when needed. She could have been an amazing antagonist, if they were willing to write her with some agency of her own. That doesn’t even mean that she had to remain the stereotypical evil stepmom. Her character, her motivation, especially in parallel to Rhaenyra could have been so interesting, actually starting conversations about topics such as womanhood, feminism, motherhood, the very thin line between greed or ambition, but no, all we got instead is the forever 14 childbride with the always teary eyes, getting pushed around, and made into a dumb, delusional person. What a waste Alicent was made into in the show!