It’s been a week - and more than a dozen rewatches - and I’m still not sure 100% where I stand on the Carmuel short story (and full disclosure: I haven’t attempted Season 4 yet - not sure my shipper heart can take it!)
So starting with the positives; this episode felt like a gift to the fans and an acknowledgement of the impact this pairing - and Ester and Itzan’s chemistry - has had on the success of Elite.
I loved the fluff: Samuel being a hopeless romantic in bed, Carla’s final heartbreaking voice note, the very hot Truth or Dare game, and the sweet moments they shared while living together.
It was so good to see them have fun together and actually smile for once! Sure, some of Samuel’s lines in the first short felt a little too confident for his character, but the lightness and humour was a huge relief after the pain of the previous season.
But despite loving a lot of the scenes, I don’t think the short stories brought the closure for Carmuel that we were promised. There was just so much left unsaid. Would it have killed them to have an actual conversation? I know that Carla naturally holds back but there were many missed opportunities for her to open up, whether it was during the drinking game or when Samuel was nagging her about visiting her parents. If she’d been allowed to explain any of her actions in season three to Samuel - her Dad’s threats, her relationship with Yeray, her drug use - I would really have felt that this relationship is the truest thing in her life.
The break-up was inevitable and it was always going to be rushed in a short story but it still felt like their conflict came out of nowhere. To boil their issues down to money and class - and for Samuel to do a complete 180 - just didn’t seem believable to me.
This is the person he described as the love of his life, the person he can’t imagine a future without, and the person he still fought for after everything that happened in season three. But it took just seven (apparently blissful) days together and one argument to convince him that he’d never feel good enough? Carla might have been the one to call things off but it seemed like it was Samuel’s shifting feelings that had driven her to that decision, rather than her desire to leave him.
All that being said, I do still have hope that they’ll reunite down the road - even if it happens off-screen. It’s a classic right person, wrong time situation and with some time apart - Samuel becoming more sure of himself and Carla learning there’s strength in vulnerability - they could still be the perfect match.
Now, please tell me someone is already writing a fanfic about those missing seven days...