Grave Robbing - Chapter One
Warnings: None for this particular chapter. Perhaps brief mentions of having a gun in ones face?
Summary: Reader gets in over her head when taking a midnight drive for ice cream.
Pairing: Sam | Plus Sized Reader
Word Count: 2,741
Chapter: 1/??
âCall 1-800-SLI-MNOW to try a thirty-day free trial of EVER SLIM Tea!âÂ
âUghâŠâ Rolling your eyes, you grabbed the remote from your bedside table and hit the power button, the screen fading to black and the babbling of the infomercial going silent. Late-night television was always a mixed bag of bad soft-core porn, diet ads and infomercials for erectile dysfunction. You had been watching reruns of Law and Order SVU but after those had ended youâd gone down a rabbit hole of bad TV. It was nearly eleven pm now and most of the âday timeâ television channels had been replaced with order-by-phone ads. You were surprised they were still around, honestly. On a night like tonight, when even the TV was reminding you of how âbigâ you were, you had decided that enough was enough. You were either going to commit a crime or pig out on ice cream and it didnât take long for you to decide which.
Rolling off of your bed, you hiked the penguin printed leggings you wore up over your hips with a shimmy, huffing under your breath as a result of the action displaced one of your boobs from the too-big tank top that you wore. âGirl just canât win, can she?â Your words were muttered under your breath as you pulled your top off and grabbed a sports bra off of the top of your hamper of clothes that were clean -- and had been for almost a week if you were being honest with yourself. Picking the shirt youâd been wearing back up, you sniffed it and then shrugged. Youâd showered that morning and it wasnât like youâd done any strenuous exercise unless you counted running across the lawn after your cat who had wormed its way out the front door earlier that afternoon.Â
âIâm just going to get ice cream, Iâm not even getting out of the car.â You reassured yourself and pull the tank top back over your head, your car keys snatched off of your dresser and a quick check done in the mirror to adjust the messy bun that sat atop your head. Itâd been a few days since youâd brushed your hair, but if you were being honest, the lionâs mane had a mind of its own, even with the best of discipline. âThere and back. No getting out of the car. Itâll be fine!â You muttered the words once more as if to scold your anxiety into submission. Youâd never liked going places on your own, especially this late at night but something had you craving ice cream from the twenty-four-hour drive through that was five miles down the road.Â
Bending to give your cat a kiss on its head, you cringed as it sneezed, painting your features with saliva and cat snot. âGee⊠thanks a whole lot, Gouda, I appreciate it.âÂ
The ten-year-old cat that was a few pounds overweight (much like yourself) simply rolled over and exposed its belly with a languid stretch. A certain trap, to be sure. Still, you took the bait and ruffled his fur, the mainecoon in him giving him enough hair that by the time you were done it looked as if heâd been electrocuted.Â
âAlright, be good! Donât be going into Oliviaâs room and bothering those ferrets! You know sheâs allergic to you!â You whisper-scolded your cat and gave him another pat for good measure before standing up and leaving your bedroom, a hoodie grabbed from one of the hooks on your wall on your way out.Â
Making your way down the stairs of the shared townhome, your roommate (who was your exact opposite in both looks and habits) peered at you from the kitchen. She was up late meal prepping and often offered to teach you, though you would rather watch paint dry than plan any meal that involved eating kale willingly. â(Y/N)? Where are you going? Itâs almost eleven-thirty. Donât tell me youâre going to that skeevy drive through again.â Oliviaâs voice was worried, and while she had always looked like she had walked out of a fitness magazine she never once judged you for your habits or your appearance. She had been your friend since middle school and while she had grown into her body, you had simply grown into your âbaby fatâ.Â
âIâll be back in like⊠thirty minutes tops! Promise!â You called from the entryway of the small home, your eyes scanning the various âlive laugh loveâ messages that dotted the walls. It wasnât your idea of decor but you didnât own the place so who were you to judge? Hearing a heavy sigh from the kitchen, you groaned and leaned against the wall. You were waiting for her to scold you about your late-night drives. Counting down in your head, you reached âoneâ right as she appeared from the kitchen, her arms crossed over her slender chest.
â(Y/N) youâve been going out a lot recently. I donât really care what you do with your time as you pay all of your bills on time and keep yourself safe but itâs late out, and there was that story on the news about that girl who--â
Holding up your hand, you smiled when she paused. âLivvie, I promise, I donât exactly fit the profile for being kidnapped. My thigh is bigger than your waist, those creeps would have a hell of a time getting me into the back of a van, especially considering my social anxiety. Puppies or candy aside, theyâre not going to fool me. Besides, Iâve got my mace. Like I said, twenty minutes tops.â You knew you had won the argument when she sighed and waved a hand.Â
âFine, but if you get snatched up--â
âIf I get snatched up, I promise Iâll ask the bad guys to let you know so that you can bore them to death with your top ten favorite avocado recipes, alright?â You offered her a smile when she rolled her eyes. You always had been sarcastic and now wasnât any different.Â
âAlright, alright, go, just⊠keep in touch if youâre going to be gone longer, alright? Cute leggings, by the way.âÂ
Nodding and mumbling something that sounded indicative of confirmation and âthanksâ combined into one word, you opened the front door and took a deep breath. Sweet freedom. You loved Olivia but you would have been lying if her health-conscious mannerisms didnât weigh on your patience occasionally.Â
Making sure the door was closed tight behind you, you jogged down the stairs and onto the cracked sidewalk that stretched out between a small, but neatly managed yard. There were garden beds to either side, raised and lush with different herbs and flowers. On either side of the chain-link gate were lawn flamingos, atop which were garden gnomes holding cats. They had been your idea and after much pestering, Olivia had relented.Â
Pulling the gate shut behind you as you exited, you hit the button on the fob for your car, sighing disdainfully when the red light blipped but did nothing. The damn thing had been broken for years and yet every time you left the house you still tried to make magic happen. Manually unlocking the door to the 2001 banana yellow Toyota Celica you pulled open the door and dropped into the front seat. Fall was just around the corner and it had the nights a little frostier than usual, which meant when your ass hit the seat, you hissed and shivered.
âDammit, LarryâŠâ The name slipped between your teeth and you grinned, remembering where the nickname had come from. Your ex had called the car hideous and had abhorred the fact that you had named it. After your breakup, youâd gotten a custom license plate that said L30N4RD so that every time he saw you in town heâd be forced to remember you. It was spiteful, sure, but heâd cheated on you with your ex-best friend and youâd walked in on it; karma was a bitch though, and heâd ended up getting an STI from the girl heâd done the dirty with.Â
Shoving the key into the ignition, you said a silent prayer and hit the gas as you started the car, a sigh of relief as the engine sputtered to life. âThank you, Larry, for once you do something right the first time.â Backing out of the driveway you were careful to avoid Oliviaâs Prius, the yellow headlights from your car basking the quiet suburban street in a dim glow.Â
***
Ten minutes later you and Larry were putting down the road, the drive-through was at the other end of the small town you had lived in for the past five years and it was the only thing open this late. While the town was quiet, it was boring and it had made âMcKreeveyâs Drive-Thruâ the only place worth going. Tapping your fingers on the steering wheel, you tried to ignore the way Larry clanked and whirred as you drove. A few more miles and you would be there and ordering your favorite sundae -- you just had to drive passed Saint Christianâs Cemetery in and youâd be home free. Ever since you had lived there the place had given you the creeps and tonight was no different.Â
Turning up the radio as you drove by, you hummed and bopped your head, doing your best to ignore the way the street lights had disappeared, leaving you in the dark save for the soft glow of your carâs headlights. Another clank, followed by a shattering pop and finally a whir as your car sputtered to a stop and died on the side of the road.Â
âYouâve got to be fucking kidding me right nowâŠâÂ
Your voice was a quiet murmur as you looked out of the windshield to see smoke rising from beneath Larryâs hood, a groan leaving your throat. âGreat, this is fucking perfect. I just wanted some god damned ice cream. Pulling out your phone, you squinted as the screen lit up and then rolled your eyes as the single bar of service flipped over to roaming.Â
âReally? Goddess above I hate this fucking city.âÂ
Pushing open the door, you shoved the seatbelt away from you and slid of your car, the flashlight on your phone illuminating the ground at your feet and showing off a thick, sticky puddle of fluid that trickled out from under Larryâs beat and battered frame.Â
âI have no idea what that is Leonard, but you should be ashamed of yourself! That is disgusting!â You scolded your car as if it might suddenly become sentient and realize the mess it left you in. Instead, you were left to look around for any sign of life. On the right, there were fields upon fields of corn that swayed in the breeze. To the left, the cemetery.Â
âGreat. I feel like Iâm in a horror movie. Iâll bet Iâm about to get murdered by some hobgoblin hiding in that damned corn. Walking around the front of your car, you quickly decided on the graveyard with the reasoning that you might be able to find a live-in groundskeeper or something to at least let you borrow a phone for a cab. Using the flashlight on your phone to light the way, you stopped halfway across the sprawling plot when an orange glow of light caught your distance.Â
âOh! Maybe there is someone. Digging a grave Iâll bet. Jeez, what a shitty job. Shittier for the person going in it, I suppose.â You snorted as you caught yourself talking to yourself. It happened frequently and most of the time it was someone else that caught you, the look on their faces often worth the awkward silence. Creeping slowly closer, you were maybe ten yards away when a figure jumped out of one of the graves, his toned frame tossing a shove to the ground.Â
âFigure theyâd at least use a backhoe or somethinâ.â You whispered under your breath and leaned against the tree. Maybe it was best to wait until they were done, as they seemed to almost be. Squinting and killing the flashlight on your phone, you watched as a second figure stepped out of the shadows, a canister of something in his hand.Â
âWhat theâŠ?âÂ
Watching as the taller figure poured something into the hole followed by the smaller one (the one who had jumped out of the hole in the first place) squirting some sort of liquid, you watched as one of them struck a match and dropped it into the grave.Â
âOkay what the-- OH MY GOD!âÂ
Your voice rose three octaves as a plume of fire shot from the hole in the ground, followed by what could only be described as a wraith from some b-horror movie that screeched louder than any cheerleader at a pep rally whoâd just seen her friends ever could, itâs spectral body engulfed in flames before disappearing into the night sky.Â
âWhatthefuck?! Oh god, what the fuck⊠shit⊠fuckity shit!âÂ
At this point, you had forgotten all about the people by the grave and had instead focused on what had just come out of the grave.Â
***
âWell, at least thatâs done. Itâs nice to have something nice and easy for once. Can we get out of here now? Itâs cold.â Sam shivered and rubbed his hands over his bare arms. He hadnât thought to bring a jacket. Beside him, Dean shoved the lighter fluid and salt back into the duffel bag, picking it up and slinging it over his shoulder a few moments later.Â
âSammy youâre the size of a literal moose and youâre bitching because itâs cold out? Bring a jacket next-- wait, shhh.â Dean lifted a hand to his mouth when something in the distance cracked, followed by a high pitched wheezing. Looking to his brother, who shrugged, Dean pulled his gun out and stalked forward, having passed the duffel off to Sam who followed close behind.Â
***
Wheezing quietly, you cursed the fact that youâd decided to get ice cream. All you wanted was something sweet and now here you were, stuck in a creepy ass cemetery with grave robbers that had just lit a corpse on fire for the fun of it! You werenât sure what had come out of the grave afterward but you were willing to convince yourself that you were seeing things for the sake of your sanity.Â
âOh cheese on a tortilla, Gods of the gobstoppers and Nephilim of nerds ropes I swear I will never leave the house again if-- clickâ
Freezing solid when a very familiar sound clicked behind your ear, you slowly stood from behind the three youâd hidden behind and turned; only to come face to face with the muzzle of a handgun held by a man that looked about as happy as a hare in a field of copperheads. Swallowing thickly, you screamed as loud as you could -- a technique taught to you by Olivia. When the scream did nothing but make the male furrowed his brow deeper, you struck out with your chuck covered foot and nailed him between his legs, a fist following shortly after to meet his face with a crunch.Â
âHey Woah! Woah, miss!â The taller male behind the gun-toting one lifted his hands in mock defense as the first crumpled to the ground with a groan and a barely audible âsonofabitchâ that was choked from between gritted teeth. Lifting both of your hands, you prepared yourself to try and take on the colossus that had come up behind the smaller one, your (Y/E/C) eyes darting to and fro and your heart slamming against your chest.Â
âIâll kick your dick all the way to Fort Worth you creep sonuvabitch! Donât try me! Iâll⊠Iâll do it⊠you burnt a thing and⊠IâŠ. I think Iâm gonna--âÂ
Your fear and anxiety got the best of you a moment later and you collapsed to the ground with a dull thud, your body having looked none too graceful in your penguin pants and messy bun (now complete with mud stains and leaves stuck into it, respectfully). You had seen plenty of crime shows, but never once had you seen anything about grave robbing, screaming corpses, or being an accomplice to a heinous crime. And to think, all you had wanted was some god damned ice cream.










